Carbon Neutrality Strategies for Chinese International Oil Company Based on the Rapid Development of Global Carbon Market

Dan Wang, Juheng YangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a strategic framework for Chinese international oil companies to achieve carbon neutrality by actively participating in the global carbon market. It outlines the landscape of carbon markets, compares cap-and-trade and carbon tax systems, and introduces three tiered trading strategies, supported by a shadow pricing model, to help companies reduce emission costs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global imperative to limit temperature rise to 1.5°C by 2050, as reinforced by the Paris Agreement and COP26, places significant pressure on industries to decarbonize. Chinese international oil companies, in particular, face mounting carbon cost pressures from both domestic and international regulations. While various low-carbon technologies exist, their adoption and integration into a cost-effective decarbonization strategy are complex. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive approach that leverages the rapidly developing global carbon market to help these companies navigate this challenge and achieve carbon neutrality efficiently.

Methods

The paper employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Market Landscape Analysis: It systematically illustrates the global carbon market, comparing the characteristics and mechanisms of cap-and-trade systems and carbon taxes.
  • Inter-market Connection Identification: It explores the links between compulsory (compliance) and voluntary carbon markets, highlighting the role of carbon credits as a bridge.
  • Strategic Framework Development: Three distinct levels of carbon trading strategies are proposed for Chinese international oil companies:
  • Develop low-carbon projects and trade within a single jurisdiction.
    1. Develop low-carbon projects and trade across different jurisdictions.
    2. Trade carbon credits or allowances in conjunction with physical commodities.
  • Decision-Making Model: A shadow pricing model for carbon emission rights is introduced to provide decision-making tools for evaluating the profitability of each trading strategy level.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper relies on existing literature, industrial reports, and market data (e.g., from IHS) for its analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Carbon Credits as a Bridge: Carbon credits, particularly those issued by globally recognized standards, are identified as a crucial mechanism for connecting disparate compliance and voluntary carbon markets, facilitating a more integrated global carbon market.
  • Tiered Trading Strategies: The proposed three-level strategy offers a progressive approach, starting with localized trading and moving towards more complex international arbitrage and commodity-linked trading, allowing companies to scale their participation and profit potential.
  • Shadow Pricing for Strategic Decisions: The shadow pricing model provides a quantitative tool for companies to assess the economic viability of investing in low-carbon projects versus purchasing allowances or credits, guiding their strategic choices.
  • Synergy with Physical Commodities: The paper emphasizes the untapped potential of integrating carbon trading with the trading of physical energy commodities, suggesting this can create new revenue streams and mitigate risks associated with carbon leakage.

Key Results

The paper does not present specific quantitative results from a simulation or empirical study. Instead, its key contributions are conceptual and strategic:

  • A clear overview of the global carbon market, including the distinctions and connections between compliance and voluntary markets.
  • A comparative analysis of cap-and-trade systems and carbon taxes, outlining their advantages and disadvantages.
  • A framework of three actionable carbon trading strategies for Chinese international oil companies.
  • A theoretical model (shadow pricing) to support decision-making for these strategies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplification Assumptions: The authors acknowledge that the shadow pricing model makes simplifying assumptions regarding parameters like the linear relationship between carbon emissions and production scale, and the constant conversion factor.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future research should focus on developing more sophisticated and authentic calculation methods to enhance the effectiveness of the proposed trading strategies in reducing carbon costs for Chinese international oil companies. Further investigation into the practical implementation and economic impact of these strategies would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

A comprehensive solution for the Chinese international oil company to achieve carbon neutrality, through participation in the global carbon market, is developed. In this work, the overall landscape and operation mechanism of global carbon market is clearly and systematically illustrated by comparing the characteristics of the cap-and-trade system and the carbon tax. The feasibility of developing a global liquidity carbon market is pointed out by finding the connections among compulsory and voluntary carbon markets around the world. Based on the profound understanding of global carbon market, three levels of carbon trading strategies are proposed to help Chinese oil companies reduce emission cost: (1) Develop low carbon projects and trade in one jurisdiction; (2) develop low carbon projects and trade in different jurisdictions; and (3) trade carbon credits or allowance with physical commodities. Three decision-making methods are provided, respectively, for the above three levels of carbon trading strategies by introducing a shadow pricing model for carbon emission rights.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2022carbon,
  author = {Dan Wang and Juheng Yang},
  title = {{Carbon Neutrality Strategies for Chinese International Oil Company Based on the Rapid Development of Global Carbon Market}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141811350},
}
Figure