Carbon Footprinting of Universities Worldwide Part II: First Quantification of Complete Embodied Impacts of Two Campuses in Germany and Singapore

Eckard Helmers, Chia Chien Chang, Justin DauwelsSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper quantifies the "embodied" carbon footprint of university campuses – the emissions associated with construction materials and infrastructure – for the first time. It reveals that these embodied impacts are significant, often dominating building lifecycle emissions, and must be considered for accurate carbon accounting, especially for institutions with renewable energy sources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Universities are increasingly focused on reducing their carbon footprint, but current assessments often overlook the "embodied" emissions associated with the buildings and infrastructure themselves. These emissions, generated during material extraction, manufacturing, and construction, are crucial for a complete life-cycle assessment. Without this data, universities may misjudge their true environmental impact and the effectiveness of their sustainability initiatives, particularly if they've already transitioned to renewable energy for their operational (use-phase) emissions. This paper aims to fill this data gap by quantifying these embodied impacts for two distinct university campuses.

Methods

The study employs a life-cycle assessment (LCA) approach to quantify embodied impacts. For building materials, they compiled quantities from architectural drawings and on-site measurements. These quantities were then converted into CO2e emissions using material-specific emission factors from databases like "Oekobaudat" for Germany and international/Asia-specific data for Singapore. For infrastructure like air conditioning and power lines, they relied on literature data and technical specifications. A key methodological aspect was the inclusion of "on-site construction impacts," which are often neglected in previous studies. They also modeled a hypothetical scenario for the German campus to assess the impact of switching from renewable to fossil-fuel-based energy.

Datasets

The primary data sources were:

  • Architectural drawings and on-site measurements: Collected for the Umwelt-Campus Birkenfeld (UCB) and for a representative sample of buildings at Nanyang Technological University (NTU).
  • Material databases:
    • "Oekobaudat" (German LCA database) for Germany-specific factors.
  • ICE (2019) database and other international/Asia-specific sources for Singapore.
  • Literature data: Used for quantifying impacts of installations (e.g., air conditioning, power lines) and for specific material properties where direct data was unavailable.
  • National construction industry emissions data: Used to derive on-site construction impact factors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Embodied impacts are not negligible: Contrary to the common focus on operational emissions, this study demonstrates that embodied impacts can constitute a substantial portion of a building's total lifecycle carbon footprint, sometimes even dominating it.
  • Renewable energy shifts the balance: For universities that have successfully transitioned to 100% renewable energy for their operations, embodied impacts become even more critical. Without them, the assessment of their carbon footprint would be incomplete and potentially misleading.
  • Holistic approach is essential: Reducing a university's overall carbon footprint requires a comprehensive strategy that considers not just direct building emissions but also embodied impacts and upstream effects, including mobility.
  • Location matters, but so does strategy: While climate zones and campus size differ significantly between the studied German and Singaporean campuses, their overall carbon footprints per square meter were surprisingly similar when all factors were considered. This highlights the importance of strategic choices (like renewable energy and building renovation) over inherent geographical advantages.

Key Results

  • Embodied impacts:
    • UCB (Germany): 13.7 kg CO2e/m²•y, representing 59.2% of its building lifecycle impacts.
  • NTU (Singapore): 26.2 kg CO2e/m²•y, representing 29.8% of its building lifecycle impacts.
  • Total campus impacts (including use-phase and mobility):
    • UCB: 124.5 kg CO2e/m²•y
    • NTU: 126.3 kg CO2e/m²•y
    • Despite significant differences in size, location, and climate, the total impacts are remarkably similar.
  • Contribution of embodied impacts to total:
    • UCB: 11.0%
    • NTU: 20.8%
  • On-site construction impact: This was identified as the largest single embodied carbon emission source, contributing 45% for UCB and 40% for NTU.
  • Renewable energy benefits: A projected scenario for UCB without renewable energy showed a massive increase in lifecycle impacts, underscoring the power of RE.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data completeness: The authors acknowledge that their embodied impacts compilation is not entirely complete, as they were unable to consider foundation structure materials.
  • Extrapolation for NTU: Due to the campus's immense size, data from a subset of buildings was extrapolated to the entire campus.
  • Temporal variations: The study focused on data from a single year (2017), and temporal fluctuations in emissions were not explored.
  • Standardization: The authors call for the development of standardized modeling approaches to improve comparability and enable continuous monitoring.
  • Future work: The paper suggests that future research should focus on developing a worldwide database and standardized modeling approaches to foster university carbon footprinting, optimization, and comparability. They also emphasize the need for additional funding and political measures to support universities in achieving climate neutrality.

Summary updated

Abstract

Universities, as innovation drivers in science and technology worldwide, should attempt to become carbon-neutral institutions and should lead this transformation. Many universities have picked up the challenge and quantified their carbon footprints; however, up-to-date quantification is limited to use-phase emissions. So far, data on embodied impacts of university campus infrastructure are missing, which prevents us from evaluating their life cycle costs. In this paper, we quantify the embodied impacts of two university campuses of very different sizes and climate zones: the Umwelt-Campus Birkenfeld (UCB), Germany, and the Nanyang Technological University (NTU), Singapore. We also quantify the effects of switching to full renewable energy supply on the carbon footprint of a university campus based on the example of UCB. The embodied impacts amount to 13.7 (UCB) and 26.2 (NTU) kg CO2e/m2•y, respectively, equivalent to 59.2% (UCB), and 29.8% (NTU), respectively, of the building lifecycle impacts. As a consequence, embodied impacts can be dominating; thus, they should be quantified and reported. When adding additional use-phase impacts caused by the universities on top of the building lifecycle impacts (e.g., mobility impacts), both institutions happen to exhibit very similar emissions with 124.5–126.3 kg CO2e/m2•y despite their different sizes, structures, and locations. Embodied impacts comprise 11.0–20.8% of the total impacts at the two universities. In conclusion, efficient reduction in university carbon footprints requires a holistic approach, considering all impacts caused on and by a campus including upstream effects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{helmers2022carbon,
  author = {Eckard Helmers and Chia Chien Chang and Justin Dauwels},
  title = {{Carbon Footprinting of Universities Worldwide Part II: First Quantification of Complete Embodied Impacts of Two Campuses in Germany and Singapore}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14073865},
}
Figure