Carbon Emission Reduction Capability Analysis of Electricity–Hydrogen Integrated Energy Storage Systems

Renjie Zhu, Yuxi Li, Xu Huang, Yaoxuan Xia, Yun Tu, Bowen Zheng, Jing Qiu, Xiaoshun ZhangTechnologies 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a framework for optimizing electricity-hydrogen integrated energy storage systems (EH-ESs) to balance cost, carbon emissions, and energy loss under various operational conditions. It highlights that improving electrolyzer and fuel cell efficiency, alongside strategic electricity trading, are key to maximizing carbon reduction potential, especially through direct hydrogen utilization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global push for decarbonization and the increasing integration of intermittent renewable energy sources (like solar and wind) create challenges for industrial energy systems. These systems need to be flexible enough to handle fluctuating renewable energy supply while meeting rigid, high-intensity energy demands. Electricity-hydrogen integrated energy systems (EH-ESs) offer a promising solution by combining electricity and hydrogen storage to enhance grid flexibility and enable low-carbon operations, particularly in hard-to-abate sectors. However, existing research often focuses on system configuration rather than a comprehensive understanding of operational responses, dynamic trade-offs between economic, environmental, and efficiency goals, and the crucial link between energy losses and carbon emissions under real-world disturbances. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a robust framework for assessing the carbon reduction capabilities of EH-ESs.

Methods

The authors developed a comprehensive operational optimization and carbon reduction capability assessment framework for EH-ESs. This framework involves:

  • Integrated System Modeling: A detailed model was constructed, incorporating an electrolyzer (EL), fuel cell (FC), hydrogen storage tanks (HST), and battery energy storage (BES), capturing their structural and operational characteristics.
  • Multi-Objective Optimization: Three key objectives were defined: cost minimization, carbon emission minimization, and energy loss minimization. These were used to systematically analyze the trade-offs between economic viability, environmental performance, and energy efficiency.
  • Linearization and Optimization Algorithms: The original mixed-integer nonlinear programming (MINLP) model was transformed into a mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) formulation using auxiliary variable and Big-M methods. A multi-objective optimization algorithm, specifically the ε-constraint method, was employed to generate a Pareto frontier, illustrating the trade-offs between objectives.
  • Scenario-Based Validation: A seven-day simulation using typical operating conditions, including variations in renewable energy output, load fluctuations, and factory shutdowns, was conducted to assess the system's adaptability and robustness. Sensitivity analyses were performed on equipment efficiency, optimization objectives, and electricity purchase-to-sale ratios.

Datasets

  • Renewable Energy Data: Centralized 90 MW WT farm and 110 MW PV power station data.
  • Load Data: Electricity and hydrogen load data from an industrial park in Jiangxi Province, China, measured in 2023.
  • Time-of-Use (TOU) Electricity Price: Defined according to Ref. [33], based on published tariff schemes.
  • Dynamic Carbon Emission Factor (CEF): Sourced from Ref. [33], derived from grid electricity carbon intensity data.

No new benchmarks were introduced; existing real-world data and established pricing/emission models were utilized.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydrogen Storage Dominance: In optimal configurations, hydrogen storage (EL and HST) plays a more significant role than battery storage, highlighting its importance for long-term energy management in EH-ESs.
  • BES as Auxiliary Regulator: Battery energy storage, despite its smaller scale, acts as a crucial auxiliary component for rapid power regulation.
  • Trade-offs are Inevitable: A "triangular dilemma" exists between economic viability, environmental performance (carbon reduction), and energy efficiency. Prioritizing one objective often compromises another, necessitating a multi-objective approach.
  • Direct Hydrogen is Better: Direct utilization of hydrogen (e.g., for industrial processes) is more effective for carbon reduction than the "electricity-hydrogen-electricity" cycle.
  • EL and FC are Bottlenecks: The efficiency and cost of electrolyzers and fuel cells are critical factors influencing overall system costs and carbon emissions. Significant cost reductions in these components are essential for economically viable carbon reduction.
  • External Trading vs. Self-Sufficiency: While increasing external electricity purchase can reduce costs, higher self-sufficiency (lower external purchase) makes the marginal contribution of hydrogen utilization to carbon reduction more pronounced.

Key Results

  • Adaptability: The proposed EH-ES model demonstrated strong adaptability and robustness across various output and load conditions, including high renewable output, renewable shutdown, stable operation, factory shutdowns, intermittent fluctuations, and intermittent load fluctuations.
  • Cost vs. Emission vs. Loss:
    • Minimizing cost led to prioritizing external market sales of surplus electricity.
  • Minimizing carbon emissions involved maximizing self-sufficiency in green hydrogen production.
  • Minimizing energy losses resulted in system expansion but negatively impacted cost and emission reduction.
  • Carbon Reduction: A significant reduction in carbon emissions (approximately 19.6%) was achieved when minimizing carbon emissions as the primary objective.
  • Energy Loss Reduction: Total energy losses decreased by approximately 7.9% when minimizing energy loss compared to cost minimization.
  • Cost of Carbon Reduction: At a 100% equipment price benchmark, the marginal cost of emission reduction was high (288 CNY/tCO2), indicating a lack of direct economic incentives. This viability improved significantly when equipment prices dropped to around 20% of the benchmark.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study is limited by fixed renewable generation profiles and region-specific operational data, which may affect the generalizability of the results.
  • Future Work:
    • Extend the framework to include stochastic renewable variations.
  • Incorporate different market and policy scenarios.
  • Analyze multi-regional system interactions.
  • Investigate more direct carbon mitigation pathways, such as direct hydrogen supply or process substitution, for deeper and more cost-effective reductions in high-emission industries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Against the dual backdrop of intensifying carbon emission constraints and the large-scale integration of renewable energy, integrated electricity–hydrogen energy systems (EH-ESs) have emerged as a crucial technological pathway for decarbonising energy systems, owing to their multi-energy complementarity and cross-scale regulation capabilities. This paper proposes an operational optimisation and carbon reduction capability assessment framework for EH-ESs, focusing on revealing their operational response mechanisms and emission reduction potential under multi-disturbance conditions. A comprehensive model encompassing an electrolyser (EL), a fuel cell (FC), hydrogen storage tanks, and battery energy storage was constructed. Three optimisation objectives—cost minimisation, carbon emission minimisation, and energy loss minimisation—were introduced to systematically characterise the trade-offs between economic viability, environmental performance, and energy efficiency. Case study validation demonstrates the proposed model’s strong adaptability and robustness across varying output and load conditions. EL and FC efficiencies and costs emerge as critical bottlenecks influencing system carbon emissions and overall expenditure. Further analysis reveals that direct hydrogen utilisation outperforms the ‘electricity–hydrogen–electricity’ cycle in carbon reduction, providing data support and methodological foundations for low-carbon optimisation and widespread adoption of electricity–hydrogen systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2025carbon,
  author = {Renjie Zhu and Yuxi Li and Xu Huang and Yaoxuan Xia and Yun Tu and Bowen Zheng and Jing Qiu and Xiaoshun Zhang},
  title = {{Carbon Emission Reduction Capability Analysis of Electricity–Hydrogen Integrated Energy Storage Systems}},
  booktitle = {Technologies},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/technologies13100472},
}
Figure