Carbon Emission Patterns and Carbon Balance Zoning in Urban Territorial Spaces Based on Multisource Data: A Case Study of Suzhou City, China

Zhenlong Zhang, Xiaoping Yu, Yanzhen Hou, Tianhao Chen, Yun Lu, Honghu SunISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for precisely mapping urban carbon emissions at a micro-scale using multisource big data, enabling detailed carbon balance zoning for targeted low-carbon governance. By analyzing Suzhou City, the study reveals distinct spatial patterns of emissions and sinks, providing a blueprint for differentiated, localized strategies to achieve China's "dual carbon" goals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cities are major contributors to global carbon emissions, making urban carbon management crucial for climate change mitigation. While existing research has explored carbon emissions at national and regional levels, there's a significant gap in high-resolution, micro-scale analysis within urban areas, particularly at the township or grassroots management unit level. This lack of granular data hinders the development and implementation of effective, localized low-carbon policies and refined urban governance. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a method to accurately measure and map urban carbon emissions at a fine spatial scale, which can then inform a more nuanced carbon balance zoning strategy.

Methods

The study employs a two-pronged approach:

  1. Multisource Big Data for Carbon Emission Measurement: The authors move beyond traditional statistical data by integrating multisource big data to achieve high-precision spatialization of carbon emissions. They first calculate sectoral carbon emissions using statistical data (e.g., industrial output, energy consumption, transportation turnover) and then use big data (e.g., POI data, cellular signaling data, land use data) to allocate these emissions to specific spatial plots within the city. This "spatialization" process allows for a detailed understanding of emission patterns at a micro-scale.
  2. Carbon Balance Zoning: Based on the detailed carbon emission spatial patterns, a carbon balance zoning method is developed. This method considers three key indicators:
  3. Carbon Compensating Rate (CCR): Measures the balance between regional carbon emissions and absorption (E/C).
  4. Economic Contributive Coefficient (ECC): Assesses the economic efficiency of carbon emissions by comparing regional GDP to carbon emissions (Gᵢ/Cᵢ).
  5. Ecological Support Coefficient (ESC): Reflects the regional carbon sink capacity relative to carbon emissions (CAᵢ/Cᵢ).

    By combining these indicators, township units are classified into four functional zones: Low-carbon economic zone, Carbon source control zone, Carbon sink functional zone, and High-carbon optimization zone.

Datasets

The study utilizes a comprehensive set of data for Suzhou City in 2020:

  • Statistical Data:
    • Statistical Yearbook for each urban area (energy, industry, transportation, agriculture, demographic, economic data).
  • The Seventh Population Census of Suzhou.
  • The Fourth National Economic Census of Suzhou.
  • Spatial Data:
    • Land use data from the Gaofen-2 remote sensing satellite.
  • POI data obtained from the Gaode API.
  • Mobile phone signaling data from the China Unicom Smart Footprint Platform.
  • Road data from Open Street Map.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Micro-scale Precision is Key: The study highlights that traditional macro-scale carbon emission analysis is insufficient for effective urban governance. The ability to pinpoint emissions at the township level is crucial for targeted interventions.
  • Industry Dominates Emissions: The industrial sector is identified as the primary driver of carbon emissions in Suzhou, underscoring the need for focused industrial decarbonization strategies.
  • Urban-Rural Divide in Carbon Balance: A clear spatial structural pattern emerges, with higher carbon compensation rates in western and southern rural/ecological areas and lower rates in the northern, central, and eastern urban/industrial areas.
  • Economic Efficiency vs. Ecological Capacity: The carbon balance zoning effectively distinguishes areas based on their economic efficiency in carbon use and their ecological capacity to absorb emissions, revealing trade-offs and opportunities for tailored development.
  • Differentiated Strategies are Essential: The four identified carbon balance zones (low-carbon economic, carbon source control, carbon sink functional, high-carbon optimization) provide a framework for developing specific, localized low-carbon development strategies, moving beyond one-size-fits-all approaches.

Key Results

  • Total Carbon Emissions: Suzhou's total carbon emissions in 2020 were approximately 240.3 million tons.
  • Sectoral Contributions: The industrial sector accounted for a significant 81.32% of these emissions. Transportation contributed 5.98%, and resident energy consumption was 12.13%.
  • Carbon Sinks: Total carbon absorption was relatively low, around 0.025 million tons, primarily from agricultural and forestry lands and natural waters.
  • Carbon Balance Zoning Distribution:
    • Low-carbon economic zones: 36 township units (37.11%)
    • Carbon source control zones: 29 township units (29.90%)
    • Carbon sink functional zones: 14 township units (14.43%)
    • High-carbon optimization zones: 18 township units (18.56%)
  • Spatial Patterns: High-emission areas are concentrated in industrial clusters and central urban areas, while low-emission areas are found in suburbs and carbon sink zones. Carbon sinks are more prevalent in the west and south, particularly around Taihu Lake.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations for Specific Sectors: The paper acknowledges that carbon emissions from urban agriculture and waste sectors were calculated using traditional methods and may not be as precise as other sectors.
  • Static Analysis: The study provides a snapshot of carbon emissions and balance zoning for a single period (2020). The authors suggest that future research should explore the spatiotemporal evolution of these patterns to understand dynamic changes.
  • Carbon Compensation Mechanisms: While the study identifies different zones, further research is needed to investigate the specific mechanisms of carbon compensation between these zones and to propose comprehensive strategies for optimizing urban spatial distribution and ecological environment protection.
  • Refining Measurement Methods: Continued efforts to improve the accuracy of carbon emission measurement, especially for sectors like agriculture and waste, are recommended.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2023carbon,
  author = {Zhenlong Zhang and Xiaoping Yu and Yanzhen Hou and Tianhao Chen and Yun Lu and Honghu Sun},
  title = {{Carbon Emission Patterns and Carbon Balance Zoning in Urban Territorial Spaces Based on Multisource Data: A Case Study of Suzhou City, China}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi12090385},
}
Figure