Carbon cycling and interior evolution of water-covered plate tectonics and stagnant-lid planets

Dennis Höning, Nicola Tosi, Tilman SpohnSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper models the long-term carbon cycle on entirely ocean-covered planets, comparing plate tectonics and stagnant lid regimes. It finds that mantle cooling generally leads to a decrease in atmospheric CO2, potentially helping to counteract increasing stellar luminosity and maintain habitability over geological timescales.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The long-term stability of Earth's climate is largely attributed to the carbonate-silicate cycle, a negative feedback mechanism that regulates atmospheric CO2. This cycle relies on continental weathering, which requires exposed landmasses for efficient erosion and the exposure of fresh rock for carbonation. However, many exoplanets might be entirely covered by oceans, lacking significant land. In such scenarios, the primary weathering mechanism would be seafloor weathering, which is less efficient and more directly tied to volcanic activity. This paper investigates how the carbon cycle operates on these "water worlds" under different tectonic regimes (plate tectonics vs. stagnant lid) and how this impacts their long-term habitability, particularly in the face of a gradually brightening Sun.

Methods

The authors developed coupled box models of the long-term carbon cycle and planetary thermal evolution. They simulated two main scenarios:

  • Plate Tectonics: Modeled carbon recycling through subduction zones, considering how the temperature gradient within subducting slabs affects carbonate stability and decarbonation. They explored two seafloor weathering models: one dependent on atmospheric CO2 partial pressure and another dependent on pore-space temperature.
  • Stagnant Lid: Modeled carbon degassing via volcanism at hot spots, followed by burial and potential metamorphic decarbonation of the crust. Similar to the plate tectonics model, they investigated both CO2-dependent and temperature-dependent seafloor weathering.

Crucially, they coupled these carbon cycle models with parameterized thermal evolution models of the planet's interior to track mantle cooling over billions of years. They also incorporated a simple climate model to link atmospheric CO2 to surface temperature and account for increasing solar luminosity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and parameter values derived from existing literature on Earth's geology and planetary science.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seafloor Weathering is Key: On water-covered planets, seafloor weathering becomes the dominant mechanism for removing atmospheric CO2, directly linking climate regulation to volcanic activity.
  • Mantle Cooling is a Universal Stabilizer: In both plate tectonics and stagnant lid regimes, as the planet's mantle cools over time, atmospheric CO2 levels tend to decrease. This is a crucial finding for long-term habitability.
  • Tectonic Regime Matters for CO2 Accumulation:
    • Plate Tectonics: Carbon can be recycled back into the mantle through subduction. The fraction of subduction zones that are "cold" enough to avoid decarbonation increases as the mantle cools, leading to more efficient carbon sequestration.
  • Stagnant Lid: Carbon degassed from the mantle cannot be recycled back. Instead, it accumulates in the crust and atmosphere. As the mantle cools, the depth at which decarbonation occurs increases, effectively burying carbon deeper and reducing its atmospheric impact.
  • Initial Mantle Temperature's Differential Impact: For plate tectonics planets, the initial mantle temperature has a minor long-term effect on atmospheric CO2. However, for stagnant lid planets, a hotter initial mantle leads to more significant CO2 degassing early on, with this degassed carbon largely remaining in the crust and atmosphere, thus having a more pronounced long-term impact on climate.
  • Weathering Model Choice is Critical: The relationship between seafloor weathering and either CO2 partial pressure or temperature significantly influences climate evolution. A temperature-dependent weathering model appears to be more effective at stabilizing surface temperatures.

Key Results

  • Habitability Without Land or Plate Tectonics: The study suggests that planets entirely covered by oceans can remain habitable over geological timescales, even without continental weathering or plate tectonics, due to the long-term carbon cycle's regulatory effects.
  • CO2 Reduction with Mantle Cooling: For both tectonic regimes, mantle cooling leads to a decrease in atmospheric CO2. This effect can partially offset the increase in solar luminosity over billions of years, helping to maintain temperate surface conditions.
  • Stagnant Lid CO2 Sensitivity: Stagnant lid planets are more sensitive to their initial mantle temperature regarding atmospheric CO2 levels. A difference of 100 K in initial mantle temperature can lead to a 50 K difference in surface temperature after 4.5 Gyr when using a CO2-dependent weathering model.
  • Temperature-Dependent Weathering Enhances Stability: A seafloor weathering model that depends on pore-space temperature provides a stronger negative feedback, leading to more stable surface temperatures, especially on stagnant lid planets.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subduction Zone Complexity: The model simplifies subduction zone processes, using a parameterized approach for temperature-depth gradients. A more detailed treatment of variations in subduction zone parameters (angle, speed) and their scaling with mantle temperature is needed.
  • Decarbonation Assumptions: The model assumes dry carbonate decarbonation and does not explicitly account for fluid-mediated reactions, which could lead to underestimation of decarbonation flux. The parameter 'f' (fraction of subducted CO2 not released by arc volcanism) is kept constant, whereas it could be temperature-dependent.
  • Ocean Carbon Reservoir: The study neglects the ocean as a significant carbon reservoir, which is a valid simplification for planets where the climate is primarily regulated by the long-term carbon cycle, but less so for "water worlds" with very deep oceans.
  • Tectonic Mode Transitions: The model assumes a fixed tectonic regime (plate tectonics or stagnant lid) throughout the planet's evolution, whereas transitions between these modes are possible and could influence climate.
  • Planetary Mass: The study focuses on Earth-sized planets. The effects of planetary mass on heat flow, volcanism, and atmospheric escape are not considered.
  • Snowball State: The model does not explore transitions to snowball states or the conditions required for recovery from such states, which could be relevant for planets with low carbon inventories.

Future work could address these limitations by incorporating more complex subduction zone physics, fluid-mediated decarbonation, ocean carbon cycling, and tectonic mode transitions. Investigating the impact of planetary mass and exploring the conditions for avoiding or recovering from snowball states would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aims. The long-term carbon cycle for planets with a surface entirely covered by oceans works differently from that of the present-day Earth because inefficient erosion leads to a strong dependence of the weathering rate on the rate of volcanism. In this paper, we investigate the long-term carbon cycle for these planets throughout their evolution. Methods. We built box models of the long-term carbon cycle based on CO2 degassing, seafloor-weathering, metamorphic decarbonation, and ingassing and coupled them with thermal evolution models of plate tectonics and stagnant-lid planets. Results. The assumed relationship between the seafloor-weathering rate and the atmospheric CO2 or the surface temperature strongly influences the climate evolution for both tectonic regimes. For a planet with plate tectonics, the atmospheric CO2 partial pressure is characterized by an equilibrium between ingassing and degassing and depends on the temperature gradient in subduction zones affecting the stability of carbonates. For a stagnant lid planet, partial melting and degassing are always accompanied by decarbonation, such that the combined carbon content of the crust and atmosphere increases with time. While the initial mantle temperature on planets with plate tectonics only affects the early evolution, it influences the evolution of the surface temperature of stagnant-lid planets for much longer. Conclusions. For both tectonic regimes, mantle cooling results in a decreasing atmospheric CO2 partial pressure. For a planet with plate tectonics this is caused by an increasing fraction of subduction zones that avoid crustal decarbonation, and for stagnant-lid planets this is caused by an increasing decarbonation depth. This mechanism may partly compensate for the increase of the surface temperature due to increasing solar luminosity with time, and thereby contribute to keeping planets habitable in the long-term.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{honing2019carbon,
  author = {Dennis Höning and Nicola Tosi and Tilman Spohn},
  title = {{Carbon cycling and interior evolution of water-covered plate tectonics and stagnant-lid planets}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/201935091/pdf},
}
Figure