Carbon and Phosphorus Allocation in Annual Plants: An Optimal Functioning Approach

Marko Kvakić, George Tzagkarakis, Sylvain Pellerin, Philippe Ciais, Daniel S. Goll, Alain Mollier, Bruno RingevalFrontiers in Plant Science 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a dynamic plant model that optimizes carbon and phosphorus allocation to maximize leaf productivity, aiming to better understand plant responses to varying phosphorus availability. While the model successfully predicts long-term plant functional responses like root-shoot ratio changes, it struggles to fully capture the dynamic uptake and cycling of phosphorus, particularly during early vegetative growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Plants require phosphorus (P) for growth, and its scarcity significantly limits productivity. Plants adapt to low P by increasing root biomass to enhance uptake. While we know plants respond this way, precisely how to functionally model this enhanced root allocation in low-P environments remains an open question. Existing models often rely on empirical relationships for P limitation, which can struggle to reproduce dynamic allocation shifts. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a mechanistic model based on the principle of "optimal functioning" to simulate plant growth and resource allocation under varying P conditions.

Methods

The core of this work is a dynamic plant model that simulates daily carbon (C) and phosphorus (P) allocation. The model is built on the principle of "optimal functioning," which posits that plants allocate resources to maximize growth. Specifically, it optimizes C and P allocation to maximize leaf productivity, considering growth and respiration processes. The model uses linear programming to solve this optimization problem at each time step. Key components include:

  • Assimilation and Respiration: C is assimilated by leaves and respired by all organs.
  • Nutrient Uptake: P is taken up by roots.
  • Allocation: C and P are allocated to different plant organs (leaves, roots, stem, grain) based on optimization.
  • Efficiency Functions: Leaf light use efficiency (LUE) and phosphorus use efficiency (PUE) are modeled as saturating functions of leaf biomass and P concentration, respectively. These are central drivers of plant response to P availability.
  • Allometric Constraints: The model incorporates constraints on how C and P are distributed to stem and grain, and non-photosynthetically active tissues.

The model is novel in its dynamic, daily optimization approach to C and P allocation, moving beyond static or empirical representations of P limitation.

Datasets

The model was calibrated and validated using data from:

  • A field trial: This involved maize (Zea mays) shoot biomass and organ P uptake over a growing season, with three different P input levels.
  • Two hydroponic studies: These examined the early vegetative response of seven temperate annual pasture species and five cereal/legume species across five different P levels.

These datasets represent a combination of field and controlled experimental conditions, providing a range of P availability scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Optimal Functioning as a Framework: The "optimal functioning" hypothesis, which suggests plants optimize resource allocation to maximize growth, provides a robust framework for modeling plant responses to environmental changes, even with a simplified root module.
  • P Limitation Drives Root Growth: The model clearly demonstrates that under low P conditions, plants prioritize root growth to enhance P uptake, leading to a higher root-shoot ratio (RSR).
  • LUE vs. PUE Dynamics: The interplay between leaf light use efficiency (LUE) and phosphorus use efficiency (PUE) is crucial. Initially, LUE drives growth, but as self-shading increases, PUE becomes more critical, necessitating increased root investment.
  • Root P Uptake Rate is Key: The root P uptake rate (kpr) is identified as a critical parameter that directly reflects P availability and significantly influences plant growth and allocation patterns.
  • Model Parsimony: The model's ability to reproduce overall plant responses with a relatively simple set of rules, optimizing for leaf productivity, highlights the power of parsimonious approaches in ecological modeling.

Key Results

  • The model successfully reproduces typical annual plant growth patterns, including early exponential growth and a transition to steady-state maturity with grain filling and P remobilization.
  • It accurately predicts long-term plant functional responses to varying P levels, such as changes in root-shoot ratio (RSR), total biomass, and organ P concentration.
  • The model shows that decreasing P availability leads to decreased total plant biomass, an increased RSR, and reduced leaf PUE.
  • Sensitivity analysis revealed that assimilation rate (kCL) and leaf P demand (PL,max) are key drivers of final plant biomass and P concentration, while root respiration rate (ACR) significantly influences RSR.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dynamic P Uptake and Cycling: The model struggles to fully capture the time evolution of organ P uptake and cycling, particularly underestimating P uptake during the vegetative growth stage. This is attributed to the model's leaf productivity formalism.
  • Luxury Uptake: The model does not reproduce "luxury uptake" of P, where plants absorb more P than immediately needed, as it assumes plants operate in the most frugal way possible.
  • Root Functionality: The model simplifies the root's role to solely P uptake, neglecting other crucial functions like structural support and water transport. This may contribute to RSR underestimation.
  • Environmental Factors: The model does not explicitly account for environmental factors like temperature, water availability, or CO2 concentration, which influence assimilation and respiration rates.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the model to include more detailed root uptake modules (e.g., saturating functions), incorporating other limiting resources (N, water), and integrating it into more physically driven dynamic global vegetation models (DGVMs). They also propose exploring the impact of different architectural and developmental strategies plants employ to cope with P limitation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Phosphorus (P) is the second most important nutrient after nitrogen (N) and can greatly diminish plant productivity if P supply is not adequate. Plants respond to soil P availability by adjusting root biomass to maintain uptake and productivity due to P use. In spite of our vast knowledge on P effects on plant growth, how to functionally model enhanced root biomass allocation in low P environments is not fully explored. We develop a dynamic plant model based on the principle of optimal carbon (C) and P allocation to investigate growth and functional response to contrasting levels of soil P availability. By describing plant growth as a balance of growth and respiration processes, we optimize C and P allocation in order to maximize leaf productivity and drive plant response. We compare our model to a field trial and a set of hydroponic experiments which describe plant response at varying P availabilities. The model is able to reproduce long-term plant functional response to different P levels like change in root-shoot ratio (RSR), total biomass and organ P concentration. But it is not capable of fully describing the time evolution of organ P uptake and cycling within the plant. Most notable is the underestimation of organ P uptake during the vegetative growth stage which is due to the model's leaf productivity formalism. In spite of the model's parsimonious nature, which optimizes for and predicts whole plant response through leaf productivity alone, the optimal growth hypothesis can provide a reasonable framework for modelling plant response to environmental change that can be used in more physically driven vegetation models.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kvakic2020carbon,
  author = {Marko Kvakić and George Tzagkarakis and Sylvain Pellerin and Philippe Ciais and Daniel S. Goll and Alain Mollier and Bruno Ringeval},
  title = {{Carbon and Phosphorus Allocation in Annual Plants: An Optimal Functioning Approach}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2020.00149},
}
Figure