Capturing Nonlinear Electron Dynamics with Fully Characterised Attosecond X-ray Pulses

Lars Funke, Markus Ilchen, Kristina Dingel, Tommaso Mazza, Terry Mullins, Thorsten Otto, Daniel E. Rivas, Sara Savio, Svitozar Serkez, Peter Walter, Niclas Wieland, Lasse Wülfing, Sadia Bari, Rebecca Boll, Markus Braune, Francesca Calegari, A. De Fanis, Winfried Decking, Andreas Duensing, S. Düsterer, Arno Ehresmann, Benjamin Erk, D. E. Ferreira de Lima, Andreas Galler, Gianluca Geloni, Jan Grünert, Marc Guetg, Patrik Grychtol, Andreas Hans, Arne Held, Ruda Hindriksson, Ludger Inhester, T. Jahnke, Joakim Laksman, Mats Larsson, Jia Liu, J. P. Marangos, Lutz Marder, David Meier, Michael Meyer, Najmeh Mirian, Christian Ott, Christopher Passow, Thomas Pfeifer, Patrick Rupprecht, A. Schletter, Philipp Schmidt, Frank Scholz, Sarah Schott, E.a. Schneidmiller, Bernhard Sick, Sang-Kil Son, K. Tiedtke, Sergey Usenko, Vincent Wanie, Markus Wurzer, Mikhail Yurkov, Vitali ZhaunerchykarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers at the European XFEL have achieved a major milestone in ultrafast science by fully characterizing individual, high-power attosecond X-ray pulses on a shot-by-shot basis. By combining "angular streaking" with machine learning, they successfully observed nonlinear electron dynamics in neon atoms, revealing how the probability of creating rare "double-core-hole" states depends directly on the peak intensity of these sub-femtosecond pulses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Free-electron lasers (FELs) are the world's most powerful X-ray sources, capable of producing pulses so short they can capture the motion of electrons. However, most FELs rely on a process called Self-Amplified Spontaneous Emission (SASE), which is inherently "stochastic"—meaning every pulse is a random, unique snowflake in terms of its timing, energy, and shape.

For researchers trying to study nonlinear dynamics (where a system absorbs multiple photons in rapid succession), this randomness is a nightmare. If you don't know the exact duration and peak power of the specific pulse that hit your sample, your data becomes a blurred average. To bridge the gap between physics and chemistry, scientists need a way to characterize these pulses in real-time, effectively providing a "stopwatch" for every single shot.

Methods

The team employed a technique called angular streaking at the Small Quantum Systems (SQS) instrument of the European XFEL.

  1. The Setup: They overlapped the X-ray pulse with a circularly polarized mid-infrared (MIR) "streaking" laser in a gas of neon.
  2. The "Clock": The MIR laser acts like the hand of a clock. When X-rays kick electrons out of the neon atoms, the MIR laser gives those electrons an extra "kick" (momentum shift) depending on exactly when they were released within the laser's optical cycle.
  3. Reconstruction: By measuring the final momentum of the electrons using an array of 16 spectrometers, the researchers can work backward to reconstruct the X-ray pulse's temporal shape.
  4. The Innovation: While they used a standard iterative algorithm for high-precision reconstruction, they also introduced a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN). This machine learning approach can process the complex electron spectra much faster than traditional methods, opening the door for "online" feedback during experiments.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data generated at the European XFEL. For the machine learning component:

  • Training/Validation Set: A massive dataset of 64,776 samples for training and 7,200 samples for validation.
  • Test Set: 400 samples were held back to compare the ML predictions against the "ground truth" provided by the iterative algorithm.
  • Physical Samples: The primary physical target was gaseous neon, used both for pulse characterization (1s-photoelectrons) and for studying nonlinear Auger decay.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Post-Sorting" Strategy: Since SASE pulses cannot be perfectly controlled, the researchers embraced the chaos. They recorded thousands of random shots and used their characterization tool to "post-sort" the data. This allowed them to see how physical processes changed as a function of pulse duration (from 600 attoseconds to several femtoseconds) without needing to change the machine settings.
  • A Race Against Decay: The team focused on the formation of Double-Core Holes (DCH). This happens when one photon removes an internal electron, and a second photon removes another before the atom can relax (a process called Auger decay, which takes about 2.4 femtoseconds in neon).
  • Intensity Matters: They proved that DCH formation isn't just about the total energy in the pulse; it's about the peak intensity. Shorter pulses (attosecond-scale) pack more photons into a smaller window, significantly increasing the odds of hitting the atom twice before it can "reset" via decay.

Key Results

  • Record Performance: The team characterized pulses with durations as short as 600 attoseconds and peak powers reaching 200 Gigawatts at ~1 keV photon energy.
  • Statistical Success: In their "short pulse" setting, 38% of shots were under 1 femtosecond, and 17% were below 750 attoseconds.
  • ML Accuracy: The machine learning model achieved a Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.91 compared to the iterative method, proving it can accurately capture pulse shapes in a fraction of the computation time.
  • Nonlinear Observation: They demonstrated a clear increase in DCH signal yield as pulse duration decreased, confirming the theoretical prediction of peak-intensity dependence in nonlinear X-ray matter interaction.

Limitations and Future Work

While the ML approach is fast, it currently relies on labels generated by the slower iterative algorithm; future work aims to make this pipeline fully autonomous and "online."

The authors also noted that at extremely high intensities, higher-order effects like "saturation" or additional ionization of valence electrons come into play, which require more sophisticated quantum-mechanical simulations to fully understand. Looking ahead, the team plans to move beyond simple atoms to complex molecules like peptides, where these attosecond pulses could track how energy and electrons migrate across a molecular backbone—the very first steps of a chemical reaction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Attosecond X-ray pulses are the key to studying electron dynamics at their natural timescale in specifically targeted electronic states. They promise to build the conceptual bridge between physical and chemical photo-reaction processes. Free-electron lasers (FELs) have demonstrated their capability of generating intense attosecond X-ray pulses. The use of SASE-based FELs for time-resolving experiments and investigations of nonlinear X-ray absorption mechanisms, however, necessitates their full pulse-to-pulse characterisation which remains a cutting-edge challenge. We have characterised X-ray pulses with durations of down to 600 attoseconds and peak powers up to 200 GW at ~1 keV photon energy via angular streaking at the Small Quantum Systems instrument of the European XFEL in Germany. As a direct application, we present results of nonlinear X-ray--matter interaction via time-resolved electron spectroscopy on a transient system, observing single- and double-core-hole generation in neon atoms. Using the derived temporal information about each single X-ray pulse, we reveal an otherwise hidden peak-intensity dependence of the probability for formation of double-core vacancies in neon after primary K-shell ionisation. Our results advance the field of attosecond science with highly intense and fully characterised X-ray pulses to the state-specific investigation of electronic motion in non-stationary media.
BibTeX
@misc{funke2024capturing,
  author = {Lars Funke and Markus Ilchen and Kristina Dingel and Tommaso Mazza and Terry Mullins and Thorsten Otto and Daniel E. Rivas and Sara Savio and Svitozar Serkez and Peter Walter and Niclas Wieland and Lasse Wülfing and Sadia Bari and Rebecca Boll and Markus Braune and Francesca Calegari and A. De Fanis and Winfried Decking and Andreas Duensing and S. Düsterer and Arno Ehresmann and Benjamin Erk and D. E. Ferreira de Lima and Andreas Galler and Gianluca Geloni and Jan Grünert and Marc Guetg and Patrik Grychtol and Andreas Hans and Arne Held and Ruda Hindriksson and Ludger Inhester and T. Jahnke and Joakim Laksman and Mats Larsson and Jia Liu and J. P. Marangos and Lutz Marder and David Meier and Michael Meyer and Najmeh Mirian and Christian Ott and Christopher Passow and Thomas Pfeifer and Patrick Rupprecht and A. Schletter and Philipp Schmidt and Frank Scholz and Sarah Schott and E.A. Schneidmiller and Bernhard Sick and Sang-Kil Son and K. Tiedtke and Sergey Usenko and Vincent Wanie and Markus Wurzer and Mikhail Yurkov and Vitali Zhaunerchyk},
  title = {{Capturing Nonlinear Electron Dynamics with Fully Characterised Attosecond X-ray Pulses}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2408.03858},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2408.03858},
}
Figure