Capturing Design Decision Rationale with Decision Cards

Marisela Gutierrez Lopez, Gustavo Rovelo, Mieke Haesen, Kris Luyten, Karin ConinxInteract 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Decision Cards," a lightweight tool designed to capture the rationale behind design decisions in an organic and minimally structured way. By evaluating these cards with both novice and expert designers, the research demonstrates their effectiveness in supporting awareness, traceability, and communication within design teams, without stifling creativity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Design processes are inherently iterative and often involve a free flow of ideas, making it challenging to document the "why" behind design choices. Existing tools for capturing design rationale are often perceived as cumbersome and interruptive, leading to low adoption rates among practitioners. This lack of documentation can result in misunderstandings, difficulty in tracking design evolution, and a loss of valuable knowledge. The paper addresses the need for a tool that can effectively capture design rationale without adding significant overhead or disrupting the creative process.

Methods

The authors developed and evaluated "Decision Cards," a tool designed to capture three key properties of a design decision: what decision was taken, why it was taken, and who was involved. The approach was bottom-up, informed by existing design practices. They created both paper-based and digital formats of these cards. The validation involved two workshops: one with novice designers in a co-located setting and another with expert designers in a remote setting. A follow-up lab study with HCI practitioners was conducted to assess how well these decision cards facilitated the interpretation and contextualization of design outcomes by individuals not directly involved in the decision-making process.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved collecting decision cards and associated artefacts generated by participants during workshops.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decision Cards as a Low-Threshold Tool: The minimal structure of decision cards makes them easy to understand and use, facilitating their integration into existing design workflows without significant training.
  • Balancing Structure and Creativity: Decision cards strike a balance between providing enough structure to be useful for documentation and traceability, while remaining flexible enough not to constrain creative thinking or idea generation.
  • Value in Externalization: Decision cards are valuable for externalizing design rationale, making it accessible to team members who were not present during the decision-making process, thereby improving awareness and understanding.
  • Completeness Over Detail: For early-stage design, practitioners found high-level, concrete decisions more trustworthy than those with excessive technical details, which could hinder the perception of the creative process.
  • The Importance of "Why" and "Who": Including the rationale behind a decision and the individuals involved significantly enhances its trustworthiness and understandability.
  • Connection to Artefacts is Key: Linking decision cards to relevant design artefacts (sketches, prototypes, etc.) is crucial for providing context and making the evolution of ideas clear.

Key Results

  • Decision cards were adopted by designers with minimal effort, serving as useful tools for recording agreements and externalizing ideas.
  • Both novice and expert designers found decision cards to be valuable for self-reflection, traceability, and synchronizing team discussions.
  • In the lab study, practitioners were able to easily interpret the structure of decision cards and found them helpful in understanding the flow of ideas and decisions.
  • Decision cards were perceived as more trustworthy and appropriate when they were complete, clearly linked to artefacts, and inclusive of team members' perspectives.
  • The study identified three key properties for effective decision cards: completeness, connection to artefacts, and inclusivity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Time and Effort: While decision cards are considered low-threshold, there is still an effort involved in documenting decisions, which could be a limitation for some.
  • Remote Collaboration Nuances: In remote settings, the lack of familiarity with other team members made designers more cautious about who to list as involved in decisions.
  • Automated Tagging: Expert designers highlighted the need for more automated tagging processes to facilitate organizing and retrieving decision cards.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future work should involve longitudinal, "in-the-wild" studies to further validate decision cards in real-world design scenarios. They also propose exploring how decision cards can be further optimized to support the creative flow and externalize design rationale more effectively.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{lopez2017capturing,
  author = {Marisela Gutierrez Lopez and Gustavo Rovelo and Mieke Haesen and Kris Luyten and Karin Coninx},
  title = {{Capturing Design Decision Rationale with Decision Cards}},
  booktitle = {Interact},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-67744-6\_29},
}
Figure