Canonical Divergence Analysis

Hoang Vu Nguyen, Jilles VreekenarXiv 2015 · arXiv

Introduction

In modern data science, a common challenge involves identifying relationships between disparate datasets. Traditional methods like Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA) are highly effective but rely on a strict assumption: the data must be perfectly paired. This requires an equal number of samples in both sets, where each sample $i$ in set A corresponds directly to sample $i$ in set B. However, real-world scenarios—such as comparing metabolic profiles across different species or energy usage across buildings with varying sensor arrays—often lack this one-to-one correspondence.

Hoang-Vu Nguyen and Jilles Vreeken address this gap in their paper, "Canonical Divergence Analysis," by introducing a framework designed to relate random vectors that differ in attributes and realizations, even when a joint distribution is absent.

Methodology

Canonical Divergence Analysis (CDA) shifts the focus from individual sample pairings to the similarity between probability distributions. The objective is to find projection vectors $u$ and $v$ such that the projected 1D probability density functions (pdfs) of datasets $X$ and $Y$ are as similar as possible.

The authors propose three primary divergence measures:

  • $CDA_M$ (Extended Mallows Distance): Generalizes CCA for cases where sample sizes $n \neq k$.
  • $CDA_Q$ (Quadratic Measure): Utilizes Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) to compare distribution shapes.
  • $CDA_P$ (Pearson Divergence): A robust measure for multi-dimensional analysis.

To enhance computational efficiency, they introduce Reconstruction CDA (RCDA), which employs "soft" reconstruction costs. This formulation allows for the use of efficient optimizers like L-BFGS, making the algorithm significantly faster than constrained versions.

Experimental Results

The framework was evaluated using synthetic data, UCI benchmarks, and real-world architectural and energy datasets. A key finding is CDA's inherent robustness to data ordering. Unlike CCA, which relies on row alignment, CDA is distribution-based and thus immune to row-shuffling.

Comparison of CDA variants against baseline methods under various data settings.

As shown in the table above, when row order is randomized, CCA's performance degrades significantly (e.g., error increasing from 0.26 to 0.48 in linear settings), whereas CDA variants maintain stable performance. Furthermore, CDA remains applicable in $n \neq k$ scenarios where traditional CCA cannot be computed.

The practical utility of CDA was also demonstrated on UCI clustering benchmarks. By finding non-redundant subspaces, CDA improved classification accuracy across multiple domains.

Accuracy comparison between RESCU and R-CDA-M on UCI benchmark datasets.

Conclusion and Future Work

CDA provides a powerful generalization of CCA, capable of uncovering latent structures between entirely different populations. While the current implementation focuses on linear mappings, the authors suggest that extending CDA to non-linear mappings via kernel methods or deep learning is a promising future direction. Additionally, the framework's potential applications in privacy-preserving data release warrant further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

We aim to analyze the relation between two random vectors that may potentially have both different number of attributes as well as realizations, and which may even not have a joint distribution. This problem arises in many practical domains, including biology and architecture. Existing techniques assume the vectors to have the same domain or to be jointly distributed, and hence are not applicable. To address this, we propose Canonical Divergence Analysis (CDA). We introduce three instantiations, each of which permits practical implementation. Extensive empirical evaluation shows the potential of our method.
BibTeX
@misc{nguyen2015canonical,
  author = {Hoang Vu Nguyen and Jilles Vreeken},
  title = {{Canonical Divergence Analysis}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1510.08370},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1510.08370},
}
Figure