Cancer Genetic Counselor Information Needs for Risk Communication: A Qualitative Evaluation of Interview Transcripts

Casey Lynnette Overby, Wendy K. Chung, George Hripcsak, Rita KukafkaJournal of Personalized Medicine 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the information needs of cancer genetic counselors to improve risk communication with patients. By analyzing interviews with eight counselors, researchers developed a conceptual model that categorizes these needs into clinical, social/cognitive, and motivational aspects, which can inform the design of better patient-facing technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Personalized medicine, or "P4 Medicine" (predictive, personalized, preventive, and participatory), is increasingly reliant on genetic information. However, effectively communicating complex genetic risk information to patients is a significant challenge. Genetic counselors are key to this process, but understanding their specific information needs from patients is crucial for developing tools that can enhance this communication. Existing research often focuses on what information is given to patients, rather than what information counselors need to effectively tailor their discussions. This paper aims to fill that gap by investigating the information genetic counselors seek to facilitate better risk communication.

Methods

The researchers conducted a qualitative secondary data analysis of interviews with eight cancer genetic counselors from three institutions. These interviews, which were semi-structured and open-ended, explored communication processes related to risk. A "selective coding" approach was used to identify major themes related to the counselors' information needs. The data was analyzed using NVivo 8 software, with two graduate-level research assistants double-coding the transcripts to ensure reliability. Themes were confirmed through member checking with one participant.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized a qualitative dataset derived from interviews with eight cancer genetic counselors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Tripartite Model of Information Needs: The study identified three core categories of information genetic counselors need from patients:
  • Clinical Patient Characteristics: This includes family history, personal medical history (especially regarding cancer), and known personal risk factors. This is foundational for risk assessment.
  • Social and Cognitive Patient Characteristics: This encompasses patients' perceptions of risk, their concerns (e.g., about body image, life stage, future family planning), and their personal values. This information is vital for tailoring communication to be personally relevant and understandable.
  • Patient Motivation and Goals: Understanding why a patient is seeking genetic counseling (e.g., to make treatment decisions, understand hereditary risk for family members, or address past cancer experiences) is crucial for guiding the session and tailoring the information provided.
  • Risk Communication is a Multi-Step Process: The study highlights that risk communication involves distinct but related activities: risk assessment, tailoring communication, and the actual risk communication itself. Tailoring is seen as occurring during risk communication, informed by the initial risk assessment.
  • Pre-Visit Information is Key: Counselors often gather significant clinical information (like family history) before the patient even enters the clinic, using questionnaires. This pre-visit data is essential for initial risk calculations and for tailoring the subsequent session.
  • Tailoring is Highly Individualized: The examples provided show how counselors adapt their communication based on a patient's understanding of numbers, their personal values (e.g., body image concerns influencing surgical decisions), and their specific fears or goals.

Key Results

The study generated a conceptual model illustrating the information needs of cancer genetic counselors for risk communication. This model categorizes these needs into:

  • Clinical Patient Characteristics: Family history, personal history of cancer, personal risk factors.
  • Social & Cognitive Patient Characteristics: Perceptions of risk, concerns, personal values, life stage.
  • Patient Goals & Motivations: Personal experiences with cancer, motivations for seeking counseling (e.g., treatment decisions, understanding family risk).

These information needs support two common activity categories: risk assessment and tailoring communication, both of which contribute to overall risk communication. The model is intended to inform the design of technologies for pre-visit patient planning and just-in-time educational support.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • Recall Bias: The data relies on participants' recall of their experiences.
  • Generalizability: As a qualitative study with a small sample size (eight counselors), the findings are limited to the group studied and may not be broadly generalizable to all cancer genetic counselors or other medical specialties.
  • Specificity of Findings: The identified activities and needs are specific to cancer genetic counseling, particularly for BRCA1/2 mutations.
  • Future Work:
    • Broader Applicability: Future studies should explore these information needs across multiple clinical specialties (e.g., cardiac, neurological) and different types of genetic testing (e.g., panel gene testing) to understand how needs might generalize or differ.
  • Contextualizing Information Needs: Further research is needed to delineate when specific types of information (like risk perception) are most critical during the counseling process.
  • Longitudinal Studies: Most existing research, including this study, focuses on initial consultations. Future work should investigate information exchange over time, especially after genetic test results are received.
  • Technology Design: The conceptual model provides a foundation for designing software systems to support pre-visit patient planning and deliver just-in-time educational information, aiming to improve cancer P4 Medicine practices.

Summary updated

Abstract

Personalized medicine is a model of healthcare that is predictive, personalized, preventive and participatory ("P4 Medicine"). Genetic counselors are an ideal group to study when designing tools to support cancer P4 Medicine activities more broadly. The goal for this work was to gain a better understanding of the information cancer genetic counselors seek from their patients to facilitate effective information exchange for discussing risk. This was an analysis of a qualitative data set from interviews of eight cancer genetic counselors, recruited from three institutions. Genetic counselors at each site were interviewed using a semi-structured, open-ended questionnaire. A selective coding approach was used to determine major themes associated with genetic counseling information needs for communicating risk. We generated a model for understanding categories of genetic counseling information needs to support risk communication activities. Common activities for risk communication included risk assessment and tailoring communication. Categories of information needs included: (a) clinical patient characteristics, (b) social and cognitive patient characteristics and (c) patient motivation and goals for the genetic counseling session. A logical next step is for this model to inform the design of software systems for pre-visit patient planning and delivering just-in-time educational information to facilitate cancer risk communication activities.
BibTeX
@article{overby2013cancer,
  author = {Casey Lynnette Overby and Wendy K. Chung and George Hripcsak and Rita Kukafka},
  title = {{Cancer Genetic Counselor Information Needs for Risk Communication: A Qualitative Evaluation of Interview Transcripts}},
  journal = {Journal of Personalized Medicine},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.3390/jpm3030238},
}

Loading related content...

Figure