Can sports participation be a protective factor against suicide-related outcomes in adolescents: a systematic review

Meilin Huo, Zhen Yang, Li Yang, Sitong ChenFrontiers in Psychology 2024 · DOI

This systematic review, published in Frontiers in Psychology, synthesizes evidence on whether playing sports acts as a "buffer" against the growing crisis of adolescent suicide. By analyzing data from over 330,000 participants, the researchers found that sports participation is consistently linked to lower rates of suicidal thoughts and attempts, though the underlying causal mechanisms and gender-specific nuances remain areas for future investigation.

TL;DR

A systematic review of 16 studies involving 337,283 adolescents reveals a strong negative association between sports participation and both suicidal ideation and suicide attempts. While the protective effect is clear in aggregate data, the evidence remains insufficient regarding suicide "plans" and inconsistent when broken down by gender.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Suicide is the fourth leading cause of death among 15–29-year-olds globally. While "physical activity" is often cited as a general health benefit, the authors argue that sports participation is a distinct, more complex behavior. Unlike solo exercise, sports involve social hierarchies, team dynamics, and structured environments that may offer unique psychological protections—or, in some cases, unique stressors.

Previous reviews either focused on general physical activity or specific subsets like elite young athletes. This paper addresses the gap by specifically looking at the general adolescent population and distinguishing between three distinct suicide-related outcomes: ideation (thoughts), plans, and actual attempts.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines, searching Web of Science, PubMed, and EBSCOhost for studies published through November 2022.

  • Inclusion Criteria: Observational studies (cross-sectional or longitudinal) focusing on adolescents (ages 12–18) that reported effect sizes (like Odds Ratios) for the link between sports and suicide outcomes.
  • Quality Assessment: The team used the STROBE (Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology) checklist to rate study quality.
  • Synthesis Technique: They employed a "percentage of support" method to categorize the strength of evidence. An association was deemed "existing" if 60–100% of the studies supported it and "consistent" if reported in four or more studies.

Datasets

The review synthesized 16 studies (12 cross-sectional, 3 prospective cohorts, and 1 longitudinal study).

  • Total Sample Size: 337,283 independent participants.
  • Demographics: While the gender distribution was generally balanced, there was a heavy geographic bias: 87.5% of the studies were conducted in the United States, with the remainder from Canada and Belgium. All data came from high-income countries.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Social Support" Hypothesis: The authors suggest that the protective effect isn't just physiological (endorphins). Instead, the "teammate effect"—social belongingness and support from coaches—acts as a primary mediator that reduces vulnerability to stress.
  • The Stress-Diathesis Model: Sports may alter an adolescent's "diathesis" (predisposition/vulnerability). By building self-esteem and providing a healthy outlet for vigorous physical activity, sports may prevent the progression from suicidal ideation to planning and attempts.
  • Not All Sports are Equal: Interestingly, some included studies noted that certain sports (e.g., wrestling or cheerleading in specific contexts) were occasionally associated with higher ideation, suggesting that the culture and specific pressures of a sport matter as much as the activity itself.
  • The "Directionality" Dilemma: Because most studies were cross-sectional, the paper highlights a classic "chicken or egg" problem: Does sports participation protect mental health, or are adolescents with better mental health simply more likely to join sports teams?

Key Results

  • Suicidal Ideation: 78% (7 out of 9) of the relevant studies found that higher sports participation was associated with lower suicidal thoughts. This was classified as "strong consistent evidence."
  • Suicide Attempts: 67% (4 out of 6) of the studies supported a negative association, also meeting the threshold for "consistent evidence."
  • Suicide Plans: The evidence was inconclusive. Too few studies (fewer than four) specifically isolated "plans" as an outcome to draw a firm conclusion.
  • Gender Differences: When stratified by gender, the results became "unclear." Only 33% of studies in males and 43% in females showed a significant negative association for ideation, suggesting that the protective effect may manifest differently or be influenced by different social variables for boys versus girls.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Lack of Longitudinal Data: The authors emphasize that more high-quality, long-term studies are needed to establish causality.
  • Measurement Bias: All included studies relied on self-reported data for both sports participation and suicidal behavior, which is prone to recall bias and social desirability bias.
  • Cultural Homogeneity: The findings are almost entirely based on Western, high-income populations. The protective effects of sports may differ significantly in low- or middle-income countries with different social structures.
  • Future Direction: The authors call for the use of objective measures (like accelerometers) to quantify sports intensity and more nuanced research into how specific types of sports (team vs. individual) impact mental health.

Summary updated

Abstract

Evidence suggests that more sports participations are associated with lower suicidal ideation and suicide attempts in adolescents. However, the directionality of the observed associations should be examined based on more high-quality longitudinal studies in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huo2024can,
  author = {Meilin Huo and Zhen Yang and Li Yang and Sitong Chen},
  title = {{Can sports participation be a protective factor against suicide-related outcomes in adolescents: a systematic review}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1341795},
}
Figure