Can phoretic particles swim in two dimensions?

David Sondak, Cory Hawley, Siyu Heng, Rebecca Vinsonhaler, Eric Lauga, Jean‐Luc ThiffeaultPhysical 2016 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Artificial phoretic particles swim using self-generated gradients in chemical species (self-diffusiophoresis) or charges and currents (self-electrophoresis). These particles are vital for studying collective motion in active matter and have potential applications in bioengineering. In self-diffusiophoresis, classical models rely on steady-state solutions of the diffusion equation. However, the two-dimensional diffusion equation lacks a steady state under standard boundary conditions. This study uses Laplace transforms to examine the long-time behavior of disk-shaped particles in thin films. We find that for fixed chemical fluxes, the swimming velocity decays logarithmically in time. Crucially, we demonstrate through numerical solutions of the full advection-diffusion equation that finite advection (non-zero Péclet numbers) regularizes the problem, allowing particles to maintain a steady speed by moving into unconsumed reactant regions.

The 2D Mathematical Conundrum

Phoretic particles, such as Janus particles half-coated with a catalyst, propel themselves by creating local gradients. While their physics is well-understood in 3D, 2D environments—like thin liquid films or microfluidic chips—present a unique challenge. In 3D, a point source of chemical flux reaches a steady state. In 2D, the diffusion equation's concentration field grows logarithmically over time. This implies a 2D swimmer should eventually "suffocate" in its own depletion zone, with its velocity decaying to zero. This paper investigates whether steady swimming is possible in 2D and identifies the physical mechanism that prevents this mathematical breakdown.

Methodology

The researchers employed a dual approach to resolve this issue:

  1. Analytical Asymptotics: By ignoring fluid advection initially, they used Laplace transforms to solve the time-dependent diffusion equation for a disk-shaped particle. They implemented a "concentration-limited" boundary condition, where the reaction rate slows as local reactant is depleted.
  2. Numerical Simulation: To account for motion, they solved the full advection-diffusion equation coupled with Stokes flow. Using second-order central differences and a forward Euler method, they simulated how a particle's movement carries it into fresh, reactant-rich fluid.

Results and Discussion

The Role of Advection

The study confirms that in a purely diffusive regime, the swimming velocity $U(t)$ follows a $1/\log t$ decay. However, the introduction of fluid advection (at Péclet numbers $Pe > 0$) acts as a "savior." By moving, the particle constantly encounters unconsumed reactant, which regularizes the 2D singularity and allows the system to reach a constant steady swimming velocity ($U_{steady}$).

Comparison of numerical and approximate analytical solutions for the Laplace-transformed swimming velocity $s\tilde{U}$ as a function of $1/s$ for various background concentrations $C$.

Concentration and Velocity Dynamics

  • Saturation: While the steady velocity increases with background reactant concentration ($C$), it eventually saturates. At high concentrations, the surface reaction rate becomes the limiting factor rather than the availability of fuel.
  • Velocity Overshoot: Simulations revealed that at high background concentrations, the particle's speed briefly overshoots its final steady-state value before stabilizing.
  • Linearity: At low concentrations, the swimming velocity scales linearly with the particle's mobility ($\mu$), but this relationship becomes non-linear as concentration increases.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work demonstrates that while 2D phoretic motion is theoretically unsteady in a purely diffusive environment, the act of swimming itself provides the necessary regularization for steady-state motion. Future research may explore more complex geometries (e.g., ellipses or crescents), the influence of film thickness on the transition from 2D to 3D behavior, and optimized coating patterns to enhance swimming efficiency.

Summary updated

Abstract

Artificial phoretic particles swim using self-generated gradients in chemical species (self-diffusiophoresis) or charges and currents (self-electrophoresis). These particles can be used to study the physics of collective motion in active matter and might have promising applications in bioengineering. In the case of self-diffusiophoresis, the classical physical model relies on a steady solution of the diffusion equation, from which chemical gradients, phoretic flows, and ultimately the swimming velocity may be derived. Motivated by disk-shaped particles in thin films and under confinement, we examine the extension to two dimensions. Because the two-dimensional diffusion equation lacks a steady state with the correct boundary conditions, Laplace transforms must be used to study the long-time behavior of the problem and determine the swimming velocity. For fixed chemical fluxes on the particle surface, we find that the swimming velocity ultimately always decays logarithmically in time. In the case of finite Péclet numbers, we solve the full advection-diffusion equation numerically and show that this decay can be avoided by the particle moving to regions of unconsumed reactant. Finite advection thus regularizes the two-dimensional phoretic problem.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sondak2016can,
  author = {David Sondak and Cory Hawley and Siyu Heng and Rebecca Vinsonhaler and Eric Lauga and Jean‐Luc Thiffeault},
  title = {{Can phoretic particles swim in two dimensions?}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.94.062606},
}
Figure