Can motor competence be influenced by the type of training interventions preschool children are exposed to? A randomized experimental study comparing sports games and psychomotricity activities

Xiaodan Guo, Chuangtao Li, Zhaoxiang Zhang, Ana Filipa Silva, Filipe Manuel ClementeFrontiers in Psychology 2024 · DOI

This research paper, published in Frontiers in Psychology (December 2024), explores how different physical education strategies impact the development of motor competence in preschool children. By comparing structured sports games to individualized psychomotor activities, the authors provide evidence that social, competitive, and task-specific play is superior for developing fundamental movement skills.

TL;DR

A randomized controlled trial of 88 five-year-olds found that structured sports games (SG) significantly outperform traditional psychomotricity activities (PCM) in improving locomotor and manipulative skills. While both interventions were better than no intervention, the competitive and social nature of sports games provided a critical "boost" for skills like running, jumping, throwing, and kicking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Motor competence (MC)—the ability to perform various fine and gross motor tasks—is not a "guaranteed" developmental milestone. It requires practice and environmental stimulation. With sedentary behavior on the rise among preschoolers, there is an urgent need to identify which types of structured interventions are most effective.

The researchers addressed a specific gap: Is it better to focus on Psychomotricity (PCM), which emphasizes individualized body awareness, balance, and sensory-motor integration, or Sports Games (SG), which focus on team dynamics, competition, and goal-oriented tasks (like scoring a goal)? The authors hypothesized that SG would favor locomotor and manipulative skills, while PCM would better support stability.

Methods

The study employed a randomized experimental design over 10 weeks (8 weeks of intervention plus 2 weeks of assessment).

  • Participants: 88 five-year-old children were split into three groups: SG ($n=30$), PCM ($n=30$), and a Control Group ($n=28$).
  • Interventions: Both experimental groups received two 30-minute sessions per week.
  • SG Group: Activities included "Balloon Football," "Kick the Toy," and "Pass to Your Captain," emphasizing team cooperation and object manipulation.
  • PCM Group: Activities included "Leap Frog," "Chopstick Relays," and "Tape Mazes," focusing on individual coordination and spatial awareness.
  • Assessment: The researchers used the Motor Competence Assessment (MCA) battery, measuring three domains:
  • Locomotor: Standing long jump and shuttle run.
  • Stability: Jumping sideways and shifting platforms.
  • Manipulative: Ball throwing and kicking velocity (measured via radar gun).

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset of 88 participants recruited via convenience sampling from kindergartens. The results were standardized into percentiles based on age and sex using established normative values for the MCA battery. This allowed the researchers to compare children's performance against a broader developmental "baseline."

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Social Stimulus" of Competition: The SG group’s superior performance suggests that the "fun" and "competitive" elements of sports games act as a catalyst for learning. The need to react to unpredictable game scenarios (open-loop skills) likely forced more rapid neural adaptations than the more predictable PCM exercises.
  • Specificity Rules: The SG group practiced kicking and throwing at targets, which translated directly to higher velocities in the manipulative tests. This reinforces the "Principle of Specificity" in motor learning: you get better at exactly what you practice.
  • Stability is a Developmental "Hard Nut": Surprisingly, neither intervention significantly improved stability scores compared to the control group. The authors suggest that stability (balance) may be more tied to biological maturation of the vestibular system or may require much longer, more specialized training (like yoga or gymnastics) to move the needle in just eight weeks.
  • The 8-Week Threshold: No significant differences were found at the 4-week mark. This indicates that motor skill acquisition follows a non-linear path, requiring a sustained "dose" of practice before measurable improvements in automaticity and coordination emerge.

Key Results

The SG group was the clear winner in two out of three domains:

  • Locomotor Domain: Post-intervention, the SG group scored significantly higher than both the Control (mean difference: 17.0%, $p=0.021$) and the PCM group (mean difference: 19.8%, $p=0.005$).
  • Manipulative Domain: The SG group again outperformed the Control (diff: 19.3%, $p=0.009$) and PCM (diff: 21.4%, $p=0.003$).
  • Effect Sizes: The improvements in the SG group were substantial, with Cohen’s $d$ values ranging from 0.78 to nearly 1.0, indicating "moderate" to "large" effects.
  • Stability: No significant differences were observed between any groups ($p=0.218$).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Dose-Response Tracking: While the session duration was fixed, the researchers did not measure the "internal load" (heart rate or steps) for individual children, meaning some may have been more active than others during the same 30-minute window.
  2. Duration: Eight weeks may be too short to see changes in stability or to determine if these gains persist long-term.
  3. Assessment Sensitivity: The MCA battery is excellent, but the authors suggest that alternative tests might be needed to capture the subtle improvements in stability that this study missed.

Future Direction: The researchers suggest that a "hybrid" approach—combining the social/competitive elements of sports games with the foundational balance work of psychomotricity—might be the gold standard for preschool physical education.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our study highlights the significant benefits of increased practice in developing motor competence, particularly in children's locomotor and manipulative skills. Additionally, at this age, fun, competition, and social interaction seem to play a crucial role, as the SG group demonstrated greater improvements compared to the PCM group.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2024can,
  author = {Xiaodan Guo and Chuangtao Li and Zhaoxiang Zhang and Ana Filipa Silva and Filipe Manuel Clemente},
  title = {{Can motor competence be influenced by the type of training interventions preschool children are exposed to? A randomized experimental study comparing sports games and psychomotricity activities}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1476297},
}
Figure