Can Interactive Systems Be Designed for Conviviality?: A Case Study

Marc Choueiri, Schuyler Duffy, Sanjay Guria, Conrad McCarthy, Pehuen Moure, Anagha Todalbagi, Yixiao Wang, Carlos Henrique Araújo de Aguiar, Keith Evan GreenConference on Designing Interactive Systems (companion Volume) 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "Helping Hand" and "Tilting Table," two interactive systems designed to enhance conviviality for individuals with reaching and dexterity limitations. By drawing inspiration from Ivan Illich's concept of "convivial tools," the research aims to empower users and foster independence in daily tasks, moving beyond purely assistive or replacement technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of designing interactive systems that truly empower individuals with physical limitations, rather than simply replacing human function or focusing solely on rehabilitation. While much research in assistive technologies has concentrated on specialized devices for rehabilitation, surgery, or as robotic replacements, this work highlights a gap in enabling tools and furnishings for home and workplace environments. The authors argue that existing adjustable furniture often requires physical capabilities that users with limitations lack, creating a barrier to independence. They propose a new paradigm of "convivial tools" that extend human capability and allow individuals to shape their environment with high, independent efficiency.

Methods

The research team employed a human-centered design approach, starting with the creation of a persona, "Michael," representing an older adult with post-stroke limitations. To understand the practical needs and challenges, they conducted usability evaluations with role-playing participants acting as "Michaels." The design of the "Tilting Table" involved biomechanical and ergonomic considerations for reaching and dexterity, leading to a mechatronic system controllable via wireless, voice, or gesture. The "Helping Hand" is a pneumatically actuated silicone gripper designed to assist with grasping small objects, drawing inspiration from soft robotics. The formative user study involved showing participants a video, providing a live demo, and collecting feedback through Likert-scale and open-ended questions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper describes a persona ("Michael") and a formative user study with five older adult participants, but does not mention formal datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Conviviality as a Design Goal: The paper champions "conviviality" – tools that empower users and foster independence – as a crucial design objective, moving beyond purely functional assistance.
  • Bridging the Gap in Assistive Tech: It identifies a significant gap in interactive systems designed as enabling tools for everyday tasks, as opposed to rehabilitation or replacement devices.
  • Empowering Through Design: The "Helping Hand" and "Tilting Table" demonstrate how mechatronics and thoughtful design can significantly improve the ability of individuals with limitations to perform routine domestic and work tasks.
  • The Persona as a Design Tool: The use of a detailed persona ("Michael") effectively guided the design and evaluation process, ensuring a focus on real-world user needs.
  • Addressing the "Manual Adjustment" Barrier: The Tilting Table's automated adjustments overcome the physical limitations that prevent many users from benefiting from adjustable furniture.

Key Results

The formative user study with five older adult participants yielded positive results. Participants generally embraced the tools, understanding their operation and recognizing their potential to make domestic tasks easier. Key survey results (Table 1) show high agreement (mean scores between 3.2 and 4.6 on a 5-point Likert scale) for statements like "I could envision the 'Helping Hand' in my home" and "The 'Helping Hand' assists the 'Helping Hand' in making daily activities easier to perform." Similar positive sentiment was observed for the "Tilting Table."

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the current work is a case study and part of a larger ambition called "home+." They are currently user-testing "home+" artifacts with a wider range of stakeholders to ensure conviviality in routine domestic tasks. Future work will likely involve further iteration and testing of these and similar interactive systems to inspire designers to strive for conviviality in their own creations. The paper also implicitly suggests that further research into intuitive control methods (voice, gesture) and the integration of such systems into a broader "smart home" ecosystem would be valuable.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{choueiri2018can,
  author = {Marc Choueiri and Schuyler Duffy and Sanjay Guria and Conrad McCarthy and Pehuen Moure and Anagha Todalbagi and Yixiao Wang and Carlos Henrique Araújo de Aguiar and Keith Evan Green},
  title = {{Can Interactive Systems Be Designed for Conviviality?: A Case Study}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Designing Interactive Systems (companion Volume)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1145/3197391.3205437},
}
Figure