Can Family Involvement Improve Business Performance? Based on the Dual Moderating Effects of Overseas Experience and Charitable Donations

Shuqin Song, Mengyun Wu, Yuqing Zhu, Yihan LvSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how family involvement impacts the performance of Chinese family businesses, specifically examining the moderating roles of family members' overseas experience and the company's charitable giving. The findings reveal that both ownership and management involvement by family members boost performance, but overseas experience can dampen this effect, while charitable donations enhance it.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Family businesses are a significant part of the global economy, yet their long-term sustainability, especially during intergenerational transitions, is a persistent challenge. While family involvement is often seen as a core strength, its precise impact on performance, and how external factors might influence this relationship, remains a complex area of study. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of whether family involvement in ownership and management directly improves firm performance, and how two key factors—the overseas experience of family members and the company's charitable giving—moderate this relationship. The authors highlight recent high-profile failures of family businesses, suggesting a potential disconnect between family involvement and social responsibility, which could hinder long-term success.

Methods

The study employs a quantitative approach using regression analysis on a dataset of Chinese A-share listed family companies. They construct several regression models to test their hypotheses.

  • Core Relationship: Models 1 and 2 examine the direct impact of family ownership involvement (FO) and family management involvement (MO) on firm performance (measured by Tobin's Q).
  • Moderating Effects: Models 3 and 4 introduce interaction terms between family involvement (FO and MO) and overseas experience (Oversea) to assess its moderating effect. Models 5 and 6 do the same for charitable giving (Charity).
  • Robustness Check: A substitution variable method is used, replacing Tobin's Q with Return on Assets (ROA) to ensure the findings are consistent.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from Chinese A-share listed family companies on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges from 2018 to 2020. The primary data sources include the "China Private Listed Companies Database" in CSMAR, along with supplementary information from Flush Finance, Wind database, and Baidu search engine for details on second-generation family members. A total of 3690 observations from 1230 companies were used, forming a 3-year balanced panel dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Family Involvement is a Double-Edged Sword: While family involvement is generally positive, its nature matters. Ownership and active management roles are crucial drivers of performance.
  • The "Globalized" Successor Paradox: Ironically, family members with overseas experience, often seen as bringing valuable international perspectives, may negatively impact short-term firm performance. This suggests a potential conflict between their strategic outlook (e.g., diversification) and the immediate needs of the established business.
  • Charity as a Performance Enhancer: Charitable giving is not just a social responsibility; it acts as a positive moderator. It seems to bolster the positive effects of family involvement, potentially by enhancing reputation, social capital, and internal cohesion.
  • The Importance of "Rule by Man" vs. "Rule by Law": The paper touches upon the cultural context in China, where "rule by man" is prevalent. Overseas experience might introduce Western governance methods that clash with this, leading to resistance and reduced performance.

Key Results

  • Family Ownership Involvement (FO): Significantly and positively correlated with firm performance (Tobin's Q). Hypothesis H1a is supported.
  • Family Management Involvement (MO): Also significantly and positively correlated with firm performance (Tobin's Q). Hypothesis H1b is supported.
  • Overseas Experience (Oversea): Has a significant negative moderating effect on both FO and MO's relationship with firm performance. The interaction terms (FO × Oversea and MO × Oversea) were significantly negative. Hypotheses H2a and H2b are supported.
  • Charitable Giving (Charity): Has a significant positive moderating effect on both FO and MO's relationship with firm performance. The interaction terms (FO × Charity and MO × Charity) were significantly positive. Hypotheses H3a and H3b are supported.
  • Control Variables: Enterprise size, asset-liability ratio, enterprise age, and equity balance were also found to be significantly correlated with firm performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope: The study is limited to publicly listed family companies in China. The authors acknowledge that many unlisted family enterprises also face similar power allocation issues, but data accessibility is a challenge. Future research could involve field studies of unlisted firms.
  • Mechanism Depth: While the study identifies moderating effects, the underlying mechanisms are not explored in great depth. Future work could combine quantitative analysis with qualitative methods like surveys and interviews to delve deeper into the psychological and organizational behavior aspects of family involvement, overseas experience, and charitable giving.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the post-pandemic era, it will become normal for family enterprises to seek innovative development. They have become more committed to building socially responsible companies and are more willing to actively promote corporate values in order to create long-term benefits. Therefore, this paper uses listed family companies entering the intergenerational succession period from 2018 to 2020 as the research object and empirically tests the influence of family involvement on firm performance, as well as the moderating effects of family members’ overseas experiences and family firm’s charitable donation behaviors. The results show that the ownership and management involvement of family members can significantly improve the performance of family enterprises. The overseas experience of family members has a negative moderating effect on the relationship between the two, while the charitable giving behavior of family enterprises has a positive moderating effect on the relationship between the two. The above research provides countermeasures and reference for family enterprises to realize the family business and the lasting development in the process of intergenerational inheritance, upgrading, and transformation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2022can,
  author = {Shuqin Song and Mengyun Wu and Yuqing Zhu and Yihan Lv},
  title = {{Can Family Involvement Improve Business Performance? Based on the Dual Moderating Effects of Overseas Experience and Charitable Donations}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142316141},
}
Figure