Can ESG Indices Improve the Enterprises’ Stock Market Performance?—An Empirical Study from China

Xiang Deng, Xiang ChengSustainability 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance influences the stock market performance of Chinese A-share listed companies. The findings indicate a positive correlation, suggesting that better ESG practices can lead to improved stock performance. Notably, this effect is more pronounced for non-state-owned enterprises and those in the secondary industry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a crucial question in modern business and finance: does investing in sustainability (as measured by ESG indices) actually translate into tangible financial gains for companies? While ESG principles are increasingly accepted as a consensus for enterprise development, empirical evidence on their direct impact on stock market performance, especially in emerging markets like China, remains less explored. The authors aim to fill this gap by examining this relationship and further exploring how it varies across different types of enterprises (ownership structures) and industries. This is important because understanding this link can guide corporate strategy, investor decisions, and government policy towards promoting sustainable development.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative empirical analysis using panel data. They utilized two primary econometric models:

  • Fixed Effects (FE) Model: This model accounts for unobserved heterogeneity across individual companies and over time, helping to isolate the impact of ESG on stock performance.
  • Generalized Method of Moments (GMM) Model: This dynamic panel data model was used to address potential endogeneity issues and provide a more robust analysis, particularly by incorporating lagged stock market performance.

Additionally, a Difference-in-Differences (DID) test was used to assess the impact of ESG signals appearing over time. The study also performed a robustness check by using an alternative performance indicator (EBITPS) and different regression models.

Datasets

The study utilized quarterly data from China's A-share listed companies from 2011Q1 to 2019Q1.

  • Stock Market Performance Data: Quarterly earnings per share (EPS) data was sourced from the WIND database.
  • ESG Indices Data: ESG indices data was collected from reports issued by two professional Chinese rating agencies:
  • SynTao Green Finance ESG rating index (ST-ESG)

    • China Alliance of Social Value Investment ESG rating index (SV-ESG) This data was available from 2015Q2 to 2019Q1.
  • Control Variables: Data for control variables such as ROA, number of independent directors, shareholder ratios, cash shares, sales gross profit, asset-liability ratio, government subsidies, and executive compensation were also obtained from the WIND database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ESG as a Financial Driver: The core insight is that ESG performance is not just a feel-good initiative but can directly contribute to a company's stock market value. This suggests a "win-win" scenario where companies can pursue both social/environmental responsibility and financial success.
  • Heterogeneity Matters: The impact of ESG is not uniform. The study highlights significant differences based on ownership structure and industry, underscoring the need for nuanced analysis rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.
  • Non-State-Owned Enterprises Lead the Way: Non-state-owned enterprises show a stronger positive response to ESG indices. This is attributed to their greater market orientation and shareholder focus, where ESG performance directly influences investor sentiment and thus stock value.
  • Secondary Industry's ESG Sensitivity: Companies in the secondary (manufacturing/processing) industry are more significantly impacted by ESG performance than those in the tertiary (service) industry. This is likely because secondary industries often have a higher environmental footprint, making their sustainability efforts more visible and impactful to the market.
  • Information Disclosure is Key: The paper implicitly suggests that robust information disclosure about ESG performance is crucial for investors to accurately assess a company's value and for the market to react positively.

Key Results

  • Positive Correlation: The study found a statistically significant positive correlation between ESG indices and stock market performance across various models.
  • Heterogeneous Impact (Ownership): The impact of ESG indices on non-state-owned enterprises was found to be greater than on state-owned enterprises.
  • Heterogeneous Impact (Industry): The stock market performance of secondary industry enterprises was significantly more affected by ESG indices than that of tertiary industry enterprises.
  • ST-ESG vs. SV-ESG: The ST-ESG rating system was found to be more representative, with higher coefficients indicating a stronger impact on stock performance.
  • Control Variables: Results for control variables were largely in line with expectations, with indicators like ROA and SFEE positively affecting stock performance, while a high shareholding ratio of the largest shareholder had a negative impact.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: The study notes that there are fewer rating data points for companies in the primary industry, leading to its exclusion from industry-specific analyses. This suggests a need for more comprehensive ESG data coverage across all sectors.
  • Data Sources: While using two Chinese rating agencies, the paper acknowledges that there are other global ESG rating systems, and the specific methodologies of these agencies might influence results.
  • Policy Recommendations: The authors propose recommendations for the government to improve ESG information disclosure, provide policy guarantees considering enterprise differences, and encourage green investment. They also call for increased social responsibility from entrepreneurs and investors, particularly in the context of global initiatives like the Belt & Road. Future work could delve deeper into the causal mechanisms behind these findings and explore the long-term sustainability of ESG-driven performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Environmental, social responsibility, corporate governance (ESG) are increasingly becoming the consensus of enterprises’ development. However, whether the ESG indices of enterprises can improve their performance on stock market is rarely studied. In order to examine the relationship between enterprise’s ESG indices and stock market performance, and to further explore the heterogeneity impact of stock market performance on the enterprises’ ESG indices in different ownership backgrounds, we conducted an empirical analysis based on China’s A-share listed companies. The empirical results show that there is a positive correlation between enterprise’s ESG indices and its stock market performance. Further analysis indicates that, the impact of ESG indices on non-state-owned enterprises is greater than that on state-owned enterprises, and the stock market performance of the secondary industry is much more affected by ESG indices than that of the tertiary industry. Finally, from three aspects including information disclosure, policy protection, transformation and upgrading, recommendations are proposed on the future direction of China’s ecological civilization construction and sustainable development of enterprises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{deng2019can,
  author = {Xiang Deng and Xiang Cheng},
  title = {{Can ESG Indices Improve the Enterprises’ Stock Market Performance?—An Empirical Study from China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/su11174765},
}
Figure