Can electronic quantum criticality drive phonon-induced linear-in-temperature resistivity?

Haoyu Guo, Debanjan ChowdhuryarXiv 2026 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether proximity to an electronic quantum critical point can "soften" optical phonons enough to explain the mysterious linear-in-temperature ($T$) resistivity observed in strange metals. The authors derive a strict mathematical criterion for this to occur ($z_p > d$) and find that while criticality does enhance phonon-mediated scattering, it typically only reaches a "marginal" state in clean systems, suggesting that phonons alone may not be the universal driver of strange-metal transport.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many high-temperature superconductors and correlated materials, the electrical resistivity scales linearly with temperature ($T$) down to remarkably low scales—a hallmark of the "strange metal" state. Standard theory says that optical phonons (lattice vibrations with a minimum energy gap) can only produce $T$-linear resistivity at high temperatures where they are "classical" (the equipartition regime). At low temperatures, their energy gap usually causes the scattering rate to freeze out exponentially.

The authors ask: Can an electronic quantum critical point (QCP)—a point where electronic fluctuations become infinitely long-ranged—interact with these phonons to "soften" them (reduce their energy gap and change their dispersion)? If so, could these softened phonons remain active scatterers even as $T \to 0$, providing a lattice-based explanation for strange-metal behavior?

Methods

The researchers tackle this using a two-step theoretical approach:

  1. Model-Independent Scaling: They first use a general scaling analysis to determine what kind of renormalized phonon dispersion ($\omega_q \sim q^{z_p}$) is required to produce $T$-linear scattering. They employ Migdal-Eliashberg theory to calculate the electron-phonon scattering rate ($\Gamma_{ep}$) across different spatial dimensions ($d$).
  2. Microscopic Field Theory: They analyze a concrete mechanism where an optical phonon couples nonlinearly to a $Q=0$ electronic collective mode (such as an Ising-nematic QCP). To make the math tractable and controlled, they use a large-$N$ field-theoretic formulation (specifically a Yukawa-SYK type construction). This allows them to calculate how the electronic criticality "dresses" the phonon and changes its dynamical exponent $z_p$.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical condensed matter physics paper based on analytical derivations and scaling arguments; it does not use external datasets or training benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The $z_p > d$ Criterion: The most critical "aha moment" is the derivation of a simple rule: for softened phonons to dominate low-$T$ transport, the phonon dynamical exponent $z_p$ must be strictly greater than the spatial dimension $d$. This ensures that as the temperature drops, the "phase space" of thermally occupied phonons doesn't shrink too fast.
  • The Marginality of Clean Systems: In clean, three-dimensional systems, the theory predicts $z_p = 3$ and $d = 3$. This puts the system exactly on the "marginal" boundary. Instead of a robust $T$-linear resistivity, you get $T$ with logarithmic corrections (e.g., $T \ln(1/T)$).
  • The Role of Disorder: Interestingly, the authors find that weak disorder can make phonons even "softer" (increasing $z_p$ relative to $d$). However, disorder also introduces a low-temperature cutoff that eventually suppresses the very effect it helps create.
  • Negative Feedback: When the authors accounted for "feedback"—how the softened phonon affects the electronic QCP in return—the tendency toward $T$-linear transport actually weakened. The system essentially "fights back" against the conditions needed for strange metallicity.

Key Results

  • Scenario (i) (2D electrons, 2D phonons): Yields $z_p = 2, d = 2$. This is marginal, resulting in a scattering rate $\Gamma_{ep} \sim T \ln(1/T)$ rather than pure $T$.
  • Scenario (ii) (2D electrons, 3D phonons): Yields $z_p = 2, d = 3$. This fails the criterion ($z_p < d$), meaning phonons cannot explain low-$T$ $T$-linear resistivity in this geometry.
  • Scenario (iii) (3D electrons, 3D phonons): Yields $z_p = 3, d = 3$. Again, marginal.
  • Umklapp Scattering: The authors clarify that for these $Q=0$ softened phonons to actually cause resistivity (momentum relaxation), they must be supplemented by Umklapp processes or disorder, otherwise, the electrons and phonons would just flow together without resistance (phonon drag).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Clean Theory Limitations: The primary limitation is that the most realistic "clean" models only sit at the marginal boundary. This suggests that while phonon softening is a powerful effect, it might not be the sole reason for the robust $T$-linear resistivity seen in experiments.
  • Acoustic Phonons: This paper focused on optical phonons. The authors note that acoustic phonons (which are already gapless) have different symmetry constraints (Goldstone's theorem) and require a separate, future analysis.
  • Anisotropy: The current model assumes an isotropic (uniform) system. Real materials like cuprates are highly anisotropic, and a "patchwise" analysis of the Fermi surface might reveal specific directions where the $T$-linear scattering is more robust.
  • Direct Boson Contribution: The study focuses on phonon-mediated transport, but the critical electronic bosons themselves also contribute to resistivity. A full theory would need to treat both channels on equal footing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Optical phonons naturally generate linear-in-$T$ resistivity in the high-temperature equipartition regime, but their finite gap prevents this mechanism from surviving to asymptotically low temperatures. Here we analyze whether proximity to an electronic quantum critical point can remove this obstruction by strongly softening an optical phonon. We first derive a model-independent criterion for such softened phonons to control low-temperature transport: besides reducing the renormalized optical gap, the Landau-damped phonon must acquire a dynamical exponent $z_p&gt;d$, where $d$ is the spatial dimension of the phonon, so that a sufficiently large thermally occupied phase space survives as $T\to 0$. We then analyze a concrete mechanism in which the phonon couples nonlinearly to long-wavelength electronic collective modes near a $\vec{Q}=0$ quantum critical point, and apply it to the Ising-nematic case. Within a large-$N$ field theoretic formulation, the phonon softening is enhanced near criticality, but in the clean theory the resulting dynamics lies at or near the marginal boundary for asymptotic $T$-linear scattering. Including feedback from the softened phonon back onto the electronic critical sector further weakens the tendency toward robust low-temperature $T$-linear transport. Our results sharpen both the promise and the limitations of phonon-based explanations of strange-metal transport near electronic criticality.
BibTeX
@misc{guo2026can,
  author = {Haoyu Guo and Debanjan Chowdhury},
  title = {{Can electronic quantum criticality drive phonon-induced linear-in-temperature resistivity?}},
  year = {2026},
  eprint = {2603.11176},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.11176},
}
Figure