Can contract farming improve farmers’ technical efficiency and income? Evidence from beef cattle farmers in China

Yuan Liang, Wentai Bi, Yuejie ZhangFrontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Contract farming is more than just a guaranteed sale; it is a powerful catalyst for productivity. This study of 610 Chinese beef cattle farmers reveals that participating in contracts boosts household income by over 15% and significantly improves technical efficiency, with production-management agreements offering the most substantial benefits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many developing economies, smallholder farmers are trapped between "small-scale production" and an increasingly complex "big market." They face high transaction costs, limited access to modern technology, and volatile market prices. China’s beef industry, in particular, struggles with low standardization and a shortage of grain-feed resources.

While contract farming (CF) is often touted as a solution, the "welfare effect" is debated: does it actually make farmers more efficient, or does it simply trap them in unfair agreements? The authors investigate whether CF improves technical efficiency (getting the most output from a set of inputs) and how that efficiency gain translates into higher income.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-stage econometric approach to ensure their findings weren't just a result of "better" farmers choosing to sign contracts (self-selection bias):

  • Propensity Score Matching (PSM): This creates a "synthetic" control group by matching participating farmers with non-participating farmers who share similar characteristics (age, education, farm size).
  • Stochastic Frontier Analysis (SFA): Used to measure technical efficiency. It calculates how close a farmer is to the "production frontier"—the maximum possible output given their specific inputs (calves, feed, labor).
  • Mediating Effect Model: A statistical path analysis to determine if the income boost is direct or if it happens because the contract made the farmer more efficient.

Datasets

The study uses primary survey data collected between July 2020 and September 2021 from 610 rural households across four major beef-producing regions in China:

  • Heilongjiang
  • Jilin
  • Inner Mongolia
  • Hebei

The sample included 426 contract participants and 184 non-participants, further categorized by contract type: marketing, production-management, and resource-providing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Efficiency Bridge: Contract farming acts as a conduit for knowledge. By providing technical training and standardized production requirements, firms help farmers close the "efficiency gap."
  • Not All Contracts Are Equal: The study distinguishes between three types. Production-management contracts (where firms specify methods) and marketing contracts significantly boosted income. However, resource-providing contracts (where firms provide inputs on credit) did not show a significant income effect, likely due to the farmers' vulnerable bargaining position against monopolistic firms.
  • The Mediation Effect: Technical efficiency is a "hidden" driver of wealth. The analysis shows that improved efficiency accounts for 14.7% of the total income increase brought about by contract farming.
  • Heterogeneity Matters: The "win" isn't universal. Farmers with more experience (breeding years) and larger farm sizes saw higher income gains. Interestingly, while training is vital, the quality and method of training mattered more than just the number of sessions attended.

Key Results

  • Income Boost: Participation in contract farming increased net cattle income by an average of 15.32%.
  • Efficiency Gains: Contract farmers achieved an average technical efficiency of 0.902, compared to 0.817 for non-participants.
  • Contract Performance:
    • Marketing contracts: +14.91% income growth.
  • Production-management contracts: +13.82% income growth.
  • Concentration of Success: Contract farming led to a "centralization" of efficiency; nearly 60% of participating farmers reached an efficiency level above 0.9.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Cross-sectional Data: The study captures a snapshot in time. Future research should use longitudinal (panel) data to see how these relationships evolve over several years.
  • Household vs. Plot Level: The data is at the household level. Plot-level data could provide more granular insights into how specific land management choices affect efficiency.
  • Institutional Risks: While CF is beneficial, the lack of significant gains in resource-providing contracts suggests a need for better "benefit-sharing" mechanisms to protect smallholders from opportunistic behavior by large agribusinesses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Introduction Contract farming is seen as a tool to create new market opportunities that can address market imperfections in many developing countries and thus increase smallholder income. Methods This study examines the impact of contract farming on farm household income using survey data from 610 rural households in China. The propensity score matching method addresses the sample selection bias of participation in contract farming. Results Contract farming can significantly increase farmers’ income, and both marketing contracts and production-management contracts can substantially increase farmers’ income levels, with production-management contracts having a greater degree of impact. Additional analysis reveals that breeding years, farm size, and training time can significantly affect how contract farming enhances farmers’ income. At the same time, contract farming can also considerably improve farmers’ technical efficiency in agricultural production. Participation in contract farming enhances the tendency to centralize the technical efficiency of agricultural production. Further analysis shows that the technical efficiency of agricultural production partially mediates the effects of contract farming on farm household income. Discussion Contract farming can be an effective institutional arrangement for improving the technical efficiency of farm household production and revenue. We also point out that farmers should strengthen their comprehensive ability levels and actively participate in training to acquire new knowledge and improve their cognitive ability. Simultaneously, according to the characteristics of farmers’ resource endowments, small farmers are encouraged to cooperate with companies in depth and develop contractual contracts in a targeted manner. Promote win-win cooperation and benefit-sharing among various business entities to promote the sustainable and high-quality development of China’s beef cattle industry.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liang2023can,
  author = {Yuan Liang and Wentai Bi and Yuejie Zhang},
  title = {{Can contract farming improve farmers’ technical efficiency and income? Evidence from beef cattle farmers in China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fsufs.2023.1179423},
}
Figure