Calibration strategy of the JUNO-TAO experiment

Hangkun Xu, Angel Abusleme, Н. Анфимов, S. Callier, Agustín Campeny, G. F. Cao, Jun Cao, C. Cerna, Yu Chen, A. Chepurnov, Yayun Ding, Frédéric Druillole, Andrea Fabbri, Zhengyong Fei, M. Gromov, Miao He, Wei He, Yuan-qiang He, J. Y-k. Hor, S. Hou, Jianrun Hu, Jun Hu, Cédric Huss, X. L. Ji, Tao Jiang, Xiaoshan Jiang, Cécile Jolliet, Daozheng Li, Min Li, Ruhui Li, Yufeng Li, Caimei Liu, Mengchao Liu, Yunzhe Liu, Claudio Lombardo, Selma Conforti Di Lorenzo, Peizhi Lu, Guang Luo, Stefano M. Mari, X. Y. Ma, P. Montini, J. P. Ochoa‐Ricoux, Yatian Pei, Frédéric Perrot, F. Petrucci, Xiaohui Qian, Abdel Rebii, Bedřich Roskovec, Arsenij Rybnikov, Hans Steiger, Xilei Sun, Pablo Walker, Derun Wang, Meifen Wang, Wei Wang, Zhimin Wang, Diru Wu, Xiang Xiao, Y. G. Xie, Zhangquan Xie, Wenqi Yan, H. X. Yang, Haifeng Yao, Ziping Ye, Chengzhuo Yuan, Kirill Zamogilnyi, Liang Zhan, Jie Zhang, Shuihan Zhang, Rong ZhaoThe European Physical Journal C 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper details the calibration strategy for the JUNO-TAO experiment, a crucial satellite detector for the JUNO neutrino observatory. By employing a sophisticated system of radioactive sources and an automated deployment unit, TAO achieves unprecedented energy resolution for reactor antineutrino measurements, with residual non-uniformity below 0.2% and non-linearity controlled to within 0.6%.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Neutrino physics experiments, particularly those studying reactor antineutrinos like JUNO-TAO, rely on precise measurements of their energy spectra. The liquid scintillator (LS) detectors used in these experiments, while effective, suffer from two primary challenges that degrade energy resolution: physics non-linearity (where the detected light isn't directly proportional to the deposited energy due to ionization quenching and Cherenkov radiation) and detector non-uniformity (where the detected light varies depending on the particle's position within the detector due to light attenuation and scattering). To achieve the ambitious energy resolution goals of JUNO-TAO (<2% at 1 MeV), these effects must be meticulously calibrated and corrected.

Methods

The paper outlines a comprehensive calibration strategy using two main systems:

  • Automated Calibration Unit (ACU): This system deploys radioactive sources along the central axis of the detector. It houses a turntable with three independent assemblies, each capable of deploying a source. These include a UV light source for monitoring detector stability, a ⁶⁸Ge source for calibrating annihilation gammas, and a combined source containing multiple gamma emitters (¹³⁷Cs, ⁵⁴Mn, ⁴⁰K, ⁶⁰Co) and a neutron source (²⁴¹Am-¹³C).
  • Cable Loop System (CLS): This system is designed for off-axis calibration. It uses stepper motors to move a radioactive source (¹³⁷Cs) along a cable within the detector, allowing for calibration at various positions.

The calibration process involves:

  • Non-linearity Calibration: Using mono-energetic gamma sources from the ACU and the ¹³⁷Cs source in the CLS, the physics non-linearity is modeled using a combination of Birks' empirical formula for ionization quenching and a function for Cherenkov radiation. The model is then fitted to the calibration data. Cosmogenic ¹²B decay events, produced by cosmic muons, are also utilized to further constrain and improve the non-linearity correction, especially at higher energies.
  • Non-uniformity Calibration: The CLS system, with its ability to position sources at multiple points, is key here. The paper describes optimizing the placement of anchors for the CLS cable and selecting specific calibration points to create a detailed map of the detector's response variation across its volume. This map, denoted as g(r, θ), is then used to correct the visible energy of detected events.
  • UV LED Calibration: A separate UV LED system is used for continuous monitoring of detector parameters like SiPM gain and timing, ensuring long-term stability.

Datasets

The paper primarily discusses the use of simulated data for developing and validating the calibration models. Specifically, it mentions using Geant4 simulations to model detector geometry and physics processes.

For calibration, the following radioactive sources are used:

  • ⁶⁸Ge (for annihilation gammas)
  • ¹³⁷Cs, ⁵⁴Mn, ⁴⁰K, ⁶⁰Co (for gamma energy calibration)
  • ²⁴¹Am-¹³C (for neutron source, leading to ¹⁶O* gamma events)
  • Cosmogenic ¹²B decay events (produced by cosmic muons interacting with the liquid scintillator)

The paper also refers to the experience and data from previous experiments like Daya Bay and JUNO for systematic bias analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Calibration: The combination of ACU (on-axis) and CLS (off-axis) systems provides a comprehensive approach to map the detector's response across its entire fiducial volume.
  • ¹²B as a Non-linearity Constraint: The use of ¹²B decay events, which have a continuous beta spectrum, is a clever way to improve the accuracy of the non-linearity correction, especially in energy ranges where other sources might be less effective or have limited statistics.
  • Optimized Calibration Points: The paper highlights the importance of strategically selecting calibration points along the CLS cable to efficiently capture the detector's non-uniformity, rather than relying on an impractically large number of points.
  • Understanding Residual Effects: Even after calibration, small residual non-uniformities remain. The paper quantifies their impact on energy resolution and bias, demonstrating that these residuals are well within the experiment's requirements.

Key Results

  • Non-linearity Control: The non-linear energy response is controlled to within 0.6% using radioactive sources. This can be further improved to 0.4% by incorporating ¹²B decay data.
  • Non-uniformity Control: Residual non-uniformity after calibration is reduced to less than 0.2%.
  • Impact of Residuals: The energy resolution degradation and energy bias caused by residual non-uniformity are kept within 0.05% and 0.3%, respectively.
  • Shadowing Effect: The shadowing bias due to source enclosures and weights is found to be smaller than 0.1%.
  • Energy Loss Effect: The fitting bias due to energy loss is less than 0.2% for radioactive sources.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlated Uncertainties: The paper acknowledges that systematic biases like energy loss and shadowing are correlated between different sources and energies. While these biases are corrected, conservative 100% uncertainties are applied.
  • Instrumental Non-linearity: The paper states that the bias caused by SiPM readout non-linearity is negligible due to the detector's design and operating conditions.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that the detailed calibration strategy presented here will be crucial for the successful operation of JUNO-TAO and its contribution to precise reactor antineutrino measurements. The UV LED system is highlighted for its role in ongoing monitoring and stability checks, which will be essential throughout the experiment's lifetime.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The Taishan Antineutrino Observatory (TAO or JUNO-TAO) is a satellite experiment of the Jiangmen Underground Neutrino Observatory (JUNO). Located near a reactor of the Taishan Nuclear Power Plant, TAO will measure the reactor antineutrino energy spectrum with an unprecedented energy resolution of $$&lt;2\%$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:mrow> <mml:mo>&lt;</mml:mo> <mml:mn>2</mml:mn> <mml:mo>%</mml:mo> </mml:mrow> </mml:math> at 1 MeV. Energy calibration is critical to achieve such a high energy resolution. Using the Automated Calibration Unit (ACU) and the Cable Loop System (CLS), multiple radioactive sources are deployed to various positions in the TAO detector for energy calibration. The residual non-uniformity can be controlled within 0.2%. The energy resolution degradation and energy bias caused by the residual non-uniformity can be controlled within 0.05% and 0.3%, respectively. The uncertainty of the non-linear energy response can be controlled within 0.6% with the radioactive sources of various energies, and could be further improved with cosmogenic $$^{12}{\textrm{B}}$$ <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"> <mml:mrow> <mml:msup> <mml:mrow/> <mml:mn>12</mml:mn> </mml:msup> <mml:mtext>B</mml:mtext> </mml:mrow> </mml:math> which is produced by the interaction of cosmic muon in the liquid scintillator. The stability of other detector parameters, e.g., the gain of each Silicon Photo-multiplier, will be monitored with an ultraviolet LED calibration system.
BibTeX
@article{xu2022calibration,
  author = {Hangkun Xu and Angel Abusleme and Н. Анфимов and S. Callier and Agustín Campeny and G. F. Cao and Jun Cao and C. Cerna and Yu Chen and A. Chepurnov and Yayun Ding and Frédéric Druillole and Andrea Fabbri and Zhengyong Fei and M. Gromov and Miao He and Wei He and Yuan-qiang He and J. Y-K. Hor and S. Hou and Jianrun Hu and Jun Hu and Cédric Huss and X. L. Ji and Tao Jiang and Xiaoshan Jiang and Cécile Jolliet and Daozheng Li and Min Li and Ruhui Li and Yufeng Li and Caimei Liu and Mengchao Liu and Yunzhe Liu and Claudio Lombardo and Selma Conforti Di Lorenzo and Peizhi Lu and Guang Luo and Stefano M. Mari and X. Y. Ma and P. Montini and J. P. Ochoa‐Ricoux and Yatian Pei and Frédéric Perrot and F. Petrucci and Xiaohui Qian and Abdel Rebii and Bedřich Roskovec and Arsenij Rybnikov and Hans Steiger and Xilei Sun and Pablo Walker and Derun Wang and Meifen Wang and Wei Wang and Wei Wang and Zhimin Wang and Diru Wu and Xiang Xiao and Y. G. Xie and Zhangquan Xie and Wenqi Yan and H. X. Yang and Haifeng Yao and Ziping Ye and Chengzhuo Yuan and Kirill Zamogilnyi and Liang Zhan and Jie Zhang and Shuihan Zhang and Rong Zhao},
  title = {{Calibration strategy of the JUNO-TAO experiment}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-022-11069-3},
}
Figure