Calibration Method for Airborne Infrared Optical Systems in a Non-Thermal Equilibrium State

Mingyuan Dong, Honghai Shen, Ping Jia, Yang Sun, Chao Liang, Fan Zhang, Jinghua Hou2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel radiometric calibration method for airborne infrared optical systems that accounts for internal stray radiation in non-thermal equilibrium states. By developing a more accurate model that considers changing optical temperatures, the method significantly improves calibration accuracy and reduces temperature measurement errors, making it more reliable for real-world airborne missions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Airborne infrared optical systems are crucial for various applications, from military reconnaissance to environmental monitoring. To ensure accurate measurements, these systems undergo radiometric calibration. However, traditional calibration methods often assume the system is in thermal equilibrium, meaning all its components are at a stable temperature. This assumption breaks down in actual airborne scenarios where internal heating and external temperature fluctuations cause the system's optical components to be in a "non-thermal equilibrium state," where temperatures are constantly changing. This dynamic state, coupled with significant internal stray radiation (unwanted light reflections and emissions within the system), leads to substantial errors in radiometric measurements. Existing methods struggle to accurately model and compensate for these dynamic stray radiation effects, especially when optical temperatures are high and changing rapidly.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of an enhanced radiometric calibration method that addresses the non-thermal equilibrium state.

  • Internal Stray Radiation Model: The authors first analyze the changes in optical temperature within the system during unsteady heat transfer. They then propose a simplified model for internal stray radiation that accounts for these temperature variations, moving beyond the assumption of a single, constant ambient temperature.
  • Reference Optical Temperature Selection: Recognizing that airborne systems have limited space and power, making it difficult to control all optical component temperatures independently, the paper proposes a strategy to select a single "reference optical temperature" that best represents the system's internal thermal environment. This is achieved using Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) analysis to identify and select the most representative temperature sensor (in this case, a sensor at the MW rear optical groups, P4) that exhibits minimal multicollinearity with other temperature variables.
  • Calibration Formula: Based on the refined stray radiation model and the selected reference temperature, a new calibration formula is derived. This formula explicitly incorporates the reference optical temperature and its change relative to a thermal equilibrium state, allowing for more accurate compensation of stray radiation.
  • Calibration Procedure: The proposed method involves performing NES (Near Extended Source) radiation calibration at a minimum of two ambient temperatures. Crucially, it requires recording optical temperature information concurrently with image acquisition. VIF analysis is then used to select the relevant optical temperature variables for the final calibration model.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from an airborne infrared optical system during radiometric calibration experiments. This data was gathered under various ambient temperatures (-30 °C to 15 °C) and included measurements from multiple optical temperature sensors within the system, as well as blackbody temperature data. The experiments were conducted using a specific MWIR channel of the system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-thermal equilibrium is a critical factor: The paper strongly emphasizes that the assumption of thermal equilibrium is a major source of error in airborne infrared system calibration, especially during operation.
  • Internal stray radiation is dynamic: Unlike static models, the authors demonstrate that internal stray radiation is not constant but changes significantly with varying optical temperatures and their gradients.
  • A single reference temperature can suffice: Despite the complexity of multiple changing temperatures, the VIF analysis shows that a single, well-chosen reference temperature sensor can effectively capture the relevant thermal dynamics for calibration.
  • Simplified approach for complex systems: The proposed method offers a practical way to improve calibration accuracy for complex airborne systems without requiring additional experimental steps or complex temperature control.

Key Results

The proposed calibration method demonstrated significant improvements in accuracy:

  • Calibration Accuracy: Achieved better than 3.13% accuracy in the 3.7-4.8 µm band, and better than 3.87% across various optical filters within the -30 °C to 15 °C ambient temperature range. This is a substantial improvement over existing methods.
  • Temperature Measurement Error: The maximum temperature measurement error was less than ±1.01 °C in the 3.7-4.8 µm band, and less than ±1.56 °C overall.
  • Comparison: The proposed method outperformed Model 1 (which ignored internal stray radiation) and Model 2 (which assumed thermal equilibrium at the measurement time). For example, in the 3.7-4.8 µm band, Model 1 had an accuracy of 13.12% and an error of ±3.64 °C, while Model 2 had an accuracy of 8.32% and an error of ±2.28 °C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • System Specificity: While the method was validated on a specific MWIR channel of a particular airborne system, the authors suggest it can be applied to other MWIR or LWIR systems. Further validation across a wider range of systems would be beneficial.
  • Reference Temperature Selection: The selection of the reference temperature sensor (P4) was based on VIF analysis for the specific system tested. Future work might explore more generalized or adaptive strategies for reference temperature selection in diverse system architectures.
  • Ambient Temperature Range: The experiments were conducted within a specific ambient temperature range (-30 °C to 15 °C). While the results show stability, extending the validation to more extreme temperatures could further confirm the method's robustness.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{dong2023calibration,
  author = {Mingyuan Dong and Honghai Shen and Ping Jia and Yang Sun and Chao Liang and Fan Zhang and Jinghua Hou},
  title = {{Calibration Method for Airborne Infrared Optical Systems in a Non-Thermal Equilibrium State}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23146326},
}
Figure