Calibrating CHIME, A New Radio Interferometer to Probe Dark Energy

Laura Newburgh, Graeme E. Addison, M. Amiri, Kevin Bandura, J. Richard Bond, Liam Connor, Jean-François Cliche, G. Davis, Meiling Deng, Nolan Denman, M. Dobbs, Mateus Fandino, Heather Fong, K. Gibbs, A. Gilbert, Elizabeth Griffin, M. Halpern, D. Hanna, Adam D. Hincks, G. Hinshaw2016

TL;DR

The CHIME radio interferometer aims to map neutral hydrogen to probe dark energy by measuring baryon acoustic oscillations. This paper details the crucial calibration requirements and the methods being developed to achieve the necessary precision, including novel techniques like pulsar holography and broadband noise injection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding dark energy, the mysterious force accelerating the expansion of the universe, is a major goal in cosmology. One promising way to study it is by measuring baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO), which are fossil imprints of sound waves in the early universe that manifest as a characteristic scale in the distribution of matter. The Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment (CHIME) is designed to map this large-scale structure by observing the 21cm emission from neutral hydrogen across a vast portion of the sky. However, the faintness of the BAO signal (on the order of 0.1 mK) compared to bright astrophysical foregrounds (up to 700 K) makes precise calibration of the radio interferometer absolutely critical. This paper addresses the challenge of achieving the extremely high calibration accuracy needed for CHIME to successfully extract the BAO signal from noisy, foreground-dominated data.

Methods

The paper outlines several key calibration strategies:

  • Beam Characterization: Precisely mapping the antenna's response (beam) across the sky and its frequency dependence is vital. This is being done through:
  • Source Transits: Analyzing the signal from bright, known radio sources as they pass through the CHIME beam to determine basic beam shape and pointing.
  • Pulsar Holography: A novel technique involving a second, tracking telescope (the 26m telescope at DRAO) to precisely map the polarized response of the CHIME beam. This method uses pulsars, which provide a sky-subtracted signal, to disentangle instrumental effects from astrophysical ones.
  • Complex Gain Determination: Measuring and correcting for the time-varying amplitude and phase of each receiver (complex gain) is essential for accurate relative brightness measurements. Techniques include:
  • Broadband Injection Signal (BIS): Injecting a stable, known noise signal across the entire CHIME bandwidth. By comparing measurements with and without the injected signal, the complex gains can be determined with high precision.
  • Pulsar Calibration: Utilizing pulsar transits as a natural switching noise source, similar to BIS, to assess gain stability.
  • Redundant Baselines: CHIME utilizes a large number of physically identical baselines (the distance between pairs of antennas). This redundancy allows for simultaneous solving of complex gains and sky visibilities, providing a powerful self-calibration tool. An efficient, hybrid method combining logarithmic linearization and singular value decomposition (SVD) is being developed for this.
  • Thermal Characterization: Measuring the sensitivity of the low-noise amplifiers (LNAs) to temperature changes allows for post-processing corrections to account for environmental drifts.

Datasets

  • Simulated Data: Extensive use of end-to-end simulations is employed to set calibration requirements and test algorithms. These simulations model realistic sky signals, instrument noise, and foregrounds.
  • Observational Data:
    • Cas A Transits: Used for preliminary beam assessment.
  • Pulsar Transits: Used for initial beam measurements and gain stability assessments.
  • Broadband Injection Signal (BIS) Data: Preliminary data from the CHIME Pathfinder used to demonstrate the effectiveness of the BIS technique for gain calibration.
  • ATNF Pulsar Catalogue: Used to identify suitable pulsars for holography measurements.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Pulsar Holography is Key for Polarized Beams: The paper highlights that precisely mapping the polarized beam shape, a critical requirement for CHIME, is extremely challenging. Pulsar holography, by leveraging a second telescope and the pulsed nature of pulsars, offers a promising solution.
  • Broadband Noise Injection Achieves High Precision: The Broadband Injection Signal (BIS) system has demonstrated the ability to calibrate complex gains to within 1% on short timescales, meeting a crucial requirement for CHIME.
  • Redundant Baselines Offer Powerful Self-Calibration: The inherent redundancy in CHIME's design is a significant asset, enabling sophisticated self-calibration algorithms that can simultaneously solve for instrumental gains and sky signals, reducing reliance on external calibrators.
  • Foregrounds Dictate Calibration Precision: The immense dynamic range between foregrounds and the faint BAO signal is the primary driver for the stringent calibration requirements, necessitating accuracies of 1 part in 10⁵ for some aspects.

Key Results

  • Beam FWHM Precision: Each feed beam FWHM must be known to 0.1% to avoid biasing the derived power spectrum.
  • Complex Gain Stability: Random gain variations must be less than 1% on 60s time scales.
  • BIS Calibration Precision: Preliminary BIS measurements show a dynamic range of ~ -20 dB, corresponding to relative gain errors below 1%.
  • Redundant Baseline Simulation: Simulations show that relative gain amplitude can be recovered to better than 0.1% and gain phase with an RMS uncertainty of 0.7° per observation. Perturbing primary beams by 2% (rms) leads to a systematic error of 0.2% in gain amplitude, highlighting the need to account for beam variations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Beam Variations: While redundant baseline methods are powerful, slight differences in primary beams between feeds introduce non-redundant visibilities. Future work involves developing algorithms to accommodate these variations through perturbative expansions.
  • VLBI for 26m Calibration: Calibrating the polarized response of the 26m telescope is difficult due to its equatorial mount. Future plans include using a large alt-azimuth telescope (46m dish at ARO) for VLBI measurements to achieve this.
  • Ongoing Simulations and Testing: The paper emphasizes that much of the calibration strategy relies on ongoing simulation programs and preliminary data analysis. Further work is needed to refine these techniques and validate them with more extensive data.
  • Cross-talk and Passband: Understanding and mitigating cross-talk between channels and precisely characterizing the instrument passband remain active areas of investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Canadian Hydrogen Intensity Mapping Experiment (CHIME) is a transit interferometer currently being built at the Dominion Radio Astrophysical Observatory (DRAO) in Penticton, BC, Canada. We will use CHIME to map neutral hydrogen in the frequency range 400 – 800 MHz over half of the sky, producing a measurement of baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) at redshifts between 0.8 – 2.5 to probe dark energy. We have deployed a pathfinder version of CHIME that Send correspondence to [email protected] ar
BibTeX
@misc{newburgh2016calibrating,
  author = {Laura Newburgh and Graeme E. Addison and M. Amiri and Kevin Bandura and J. Richard Bond and Liam Connor and Jean-François Cliche and G. Davis and Meiling Deng and Nolan Denman and M. Dobbs and Mateus Fandino and Heather Fong and K. Gibbs and A. Gilbert and Elizabeth Griffin and M. Halpern and D. Hanna and Adam D. Hincks and G. Hinshaw},
  title = {{Calibrating CHIME, A New Radio Interferometer to Probe Dark Energy}},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure