Calculation of Quantum Tunneling for a Spatially Extended Defect: The Dislocation Kink in Copper Has a Low Effective Mass

Tejs Vegge, James P. Sethna, Siew Ann Cheong, Karsten W. Jacobsen, Christopher R. Myers, Daniel C. RalphPhysical 2001 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how atomic-scale quantum tunneling can occur in metals, a puzzle given the large mass of metal atoms. By simulating dislocation kinks in copper, they discover that these extended defects involve hundreds of atoms moving collectively, drastically reducing their effective mass and tunneling barrier, making quantum tunneling plausible.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The existence of atomic tunneling defects in plastically deformed metals has been observed experimentally, but it's counterintuitive. Metal atoms are heavy, and quantum tunneling is typically associated with much lighter particles like electrons. The challenge is to explain how such heavy atoms could tunnel through energy barriers. Previous models of tunneling in materials like glasses or doped crystals often focused on one or a few atoms. This paper explores whether a more extended, collective atomic motion could be the key to enabling quantum tunneling in undoped, pure metals, specifically focusing on defects in dislocations.

Methods

The researchers employed classical molecular dynamics simulations using an effective-medium interatomic potential. This potential is computationally efficient and provides accurate elastic properties. They simulated two screw dislocations in copper with opposite Burgers vectors, arranged periodically to mimic bulk material. To study tunneling, they focused on two types of defects: dislocation kinks and jogs. They calculated the structures, energy barriers for migration, and effective masses of these defects. For quantum tunneling rates, they utilized instanton theory, a generalization of WKB analysis for multi-dimensional configuration spaces, and derived an upper bound for the tunneling matrix element using the effective mass approximation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulations using a classical interatomic potential, not on experimental datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Collective Motion is Key: The most significant insight is that quantum tunneling in metals isn't about individual atoms tunneling in isolation. Instead, it's a collective phenomenon where hundreds of atoms move in a coordinated fashion.
  • Extended Defects Enable Tunneling: Dislocation kinks, being spatially extended defects, allow for this collective motion. This delocalization is crucial for reducing the effective mass and tunneling barrier.
  • Jogs vs. Kinks: While jogs (more localized defects) have relatively large effective masses and tunneling barriers, making them unlikely to tunnel, kinks are the prime candidates for quantum tunneling in pure metals.
  • Effective Mass Reduction: The collective motion of hundreds of atoms, each shifting a tiny amount, dramatically reduces the effective mass of the kink, making quantum tunneling significantly more probable.
  • Low Barrier Explained: The extremely low energy barrier for kink migration is attributed to the wide, spread-out nature of the partial dislocations that constitute the kink.

Key Results

  • Jogs Unlikely to Tunnel: Jogs exhibit a tunneling barrier of 0.015 eV and an effective mass of approximately 0.36 M<sub>Cu</sub>. The calculated WKB tunneling factor is extremely small (~10<sup>-14</sup>), indicating negligible tunneling.
  • Kinks Highly Prone to Tunneling: Kinks have a remarkably low migration barrier of 0.15 µeV and an effective mass of approximately M<sub>Cu</sub>/130.
  • High Tunneling Probability for Kinks: The WKB factor for kinks is calculated to be 0.985, meaning that even at zero temperature, kinks behave almost like free particles and are highly likely to tunnel.
  • Kink Width and Mass: The effective mass of the kink is reduced by factors related to the split nature of the screw dislocation into partials and the transversal spreading of these partial cores. The effective mass is inversely proportional to the cube of the spatial extent of the kink.
  • Barrier Sensitivity: The energy barrier is highly sensitive to the kink width, with a small change in width leading to a large change in the barrier height.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Classical Potential: The study relies on a classical effective-medium interatomic potential. While it's computationally efficient and generally accurate for elastic properties, it doesn't capture quantum mechanical effects directly. The authors acknowledge that the qualitative result of low barriers and effective masses is robust, but quantitative barrier values are sensitive to potential accuracy.
  • Approximation of Tunneling Path: The calculation of the tunneling barrier uses a straight-line path approximation, which provides an upper bound. More sophisticated instanton calculations could refine this.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their findings could explain phenomena like quantum creep, glassy low-temperature behavior, and non-magnetic Kondo effects observed in plastically deformed metals. They also propose that similar mechanisms might apply to other noble metals and simple transition metals. Further theoretical and experimental investigations into the quantum behavior of dislocation kinks are warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Several experiments indicate that there are atomic tunneling defects in plastically deformed metals. How this is possible has not been clear, given the large mass of the metal atoms. Using a classical molecular-dynamics calculation, we determine the structures, energy barriers, effective masses, and quantum tunneling rates for dislocation kinks and jogs in copper screw dislocations. We find that jogs are unlikely to tunnel, but the kinks should have large quantum fluctuations. The kink motion involves hundreds of atoms each shifting a tiny amount, leading to a small effective mass and tunneling barrier.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vegge2001calculation,
  author = {Tejs Vegge and James P. Sethna and Siew Ann Cheong and Karsten W. Jacobsen and Christopher R. Myers and Daniel C. Ralph},
  title = {{Calculation of Quantum Tunneling for a Spatially Extended Defect: The Dislocation Kink in Copper Has a Low Effective Mass}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.86.1546},
}
Figure