Calculation of Cauchy stress tensor in molecular dynamics system with a generalized Irving-Kirkwood formulism

Jerry Zhijian Yang, Shukai DuarXiv 2014 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a generalized Irving-Kirkwood (g-IK) formalism that unifiedly incorporates both spatial and temporal averaging into the calculation of continuum mechanics properties from molecular dynamics. By using a space-time coupled kernel, the authors derive a Cauchy stress tensor that, unlike traditional post-processing methods, strictly adheres to the fundamental conservation laws of mass and momentum.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of materials science, there is a massive "scale gap" between Molecular Dynamics (MD)—which tracks individual atoms—and Continuum Mechanics, which treats materials as continuous masses. To bridge this gap, researchers use the Irving-Kirkwood (IK) formalism to translate atomic forces and velocities into macroscopic variables like "stress."

However, the original IK method is mathematically "spiky" (using Dirac Delta functions), making it hard to use in computer simulations. Later improvements, like the Hardy stress, used spatial "kernels" (averaging over a small area) to smooth things out. But even then, MD data is incredibly noisy over time. If you simply take a time-average of the Hardy stress as a post-processing step, you often accidentally violate the conservation of momentum. This paper seeks a mathematically rigorous way to smooth MD data in both space and time simultaneously without breaking the laws of physics.

Methods

The authors propose the generalized Irving-Kirkwood (g-IK) formalism. The core innovation is the use of a space-time kernel function $\Phi(\mathbf{x}, t)$.

Key aspects of their approach include:

  • Unified Averaging: Instead of averaging over space and then averaging the result over time, the g-IK formalism defines mass density and momentum using a single integral that covers both dimensions.
  • Inseparable Kernels: The authors highlight that their method allows for "inseparable" kernels—where the spatial averaging domain can actually change over the duration of the temporal average. This provides more flexibility than traditional "separable" methods (where space and time are treated as independent filters).
  • Derivation of Cauchy Stress: Using the Liouville equation and conservation laws, they derive a new expression for the Cauchy stress tensor ($\sigma^G$) that is intrinsically consistent with the smoothed mass and momentum fields.
  • Theoretical Comparison: They mathematically prove that while their method aligns with Murdoch’s previous work for separable kernels, it reveals an "intrinsic difference" compared to simple time-averaged Hardy stress.

Datasets

The authors validated their theory using Molecular Dynamics simulations of FCC Aluminum (Al).

  • Potential Model: They used the Embedded-Atom Model (EAM), which is a standard, reliable way to describe the interatomic interactions in metals.
  • Conditions: Simulations were conducted in an NVE ensemble (constant number of atoms, volume, and energy) at temperatures ranging from 0K to 300K.
  • Software/Tools: Standard neighbor list methods and Verlet time integration were employed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Physics First: The "Aha!" moment is that temporal averaging shouldn't be an afterthought. If you want your macroscopic "stress" to mean anything physically, it must be derived from a momentum balance that already accounts for the time-averaging.
  • The Kinetic Discrepancy: The difference between the g-IK stress and traditional time-averaged stress lies almost entirely in the "kinetic" part of the stress (the part related to atomic fluctuations).
  • Vanishing Differences: The authors show that the discrepancy between different stress definitions vanishes under two conditions: when the temporal averaging window goes to zero, or when the spatial averaging window becomes very large.
  • Stress Relationships: The classical relationship between Cauchy stress and Piola-Kirchhoff stress (often used in engineering) is shown to hold in atomistic systems only when the system is at zero temperature or when a sufficiently large temporal average is applied to cancel out thermal oscillations.

Key Results

  • Stability: The g-IK stress provides a much smoother and more stable physical field compared to the fluctuating Hardy stress.
  • Conservation Law Validation: Numerical experiments confirmed that the g-IK definitions satisfy the momentum conservation equation, whereas simple time-averaging of previous definitions leads to a "residual" error.
  • Convergence: Figure 4 in the paper demonstrates that the mean difference between g-IK stress and time-averaged Hardy stress decreases as the spatial radius ($r_s$) increases, confirming their theoretical predictions.
  • Temperature Effects: At higher temperatures (e.g., 150K vs 50K), the "viscous" and "kinetic" terms of the stress increase in absolute value but continue to cancel each other out effectively under temporal averaging, maintaining the validity of the Cauchy/Piola-Kirchhoff relationship.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Kernel Selection: While the paper provides four "types" of kernels, it doesn't definitively state which kernel is "best" for specific engineering applications; this likely depends on the specific material and scale being studied.
  • Computational Cost: Incorporating a full space-time integral is computationally more demanding than simple spatial averaging.
  • General Kernels at Finite Temp: The authors acknowledge that generalizing the relationship between Cauchy and Piola-Kirchhoff stress for any kernel shape at finite temperatures is difficult to estimate explicitly and suggest this as a complex area for further study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Irving and Kirkwood formulism (IK formulism) provides a way to compute continuum mechanics quantities at certain location in terms of molecular variables. To make the approach more practical in computer simulation, Hardy proposed to use a spacial kernel function that couples continuum quantities with atomistic information. To reduce irrational fluctuations, Murdoch proposed to use a temporal kernel function to smooth the physical quantities obtained in Hardy's approach. In this paper, we generalize the original IK formulism to systematically incorporate both spacial and temporal average. The Cauchy stress tensor is derived in this generalized IK formulism (g-IK formulism). Analysis is given to illuminate the connection and difference between g-IK formulism and traditional temporal post-process approach. The relationship between Cauchy stress and first Piola-Kirchhoff stress is restudied in the framework of g-IK formulism. Numerical experiments using molecular dynamics are conducted to examine the analysis results.
BibTeX
@misc{yang2014calculation,
  author = {Jerry Zhijian Yang and Shukai Du},
  title = {{Calculation of Cauchy stress tensor in molecular dynamics system with a generalized Irving-Kirkwood formulism}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1411.2227},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.2227},
}

Loading related content...

Figure