Calculation of Carbon Emissions and Study of the Emission Reduction Path of Conventional Public Transportation in Harbin City

Wenhui Zhang, Ge Zhou, Ziwen Song, Xintao Shi, Meiru Ye, Xirui Chen, Yuhao Xiang, Wenzhao Zheng, Pan ZhangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies carbon emissions from Harbin's conventional bus fleet and forecasts future emissions under various scenarios. It proposes a multi-factor grey prediction model (MGM) for population and bus fleet prediction, combined with scenario analysis for fuel structure, to identify emission reduction pathways for urban public transport.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The transportation sector is a significant contributor to global greenhouse gas emissions, and urban areas are particularly impacted. Harbin, as a large northern Chinese city with a substantial population and a reliance on conventional transport, faces challenges in reducing its carbon footprint. While general methods for calculating and predicting carbon emissions exist, there's a need for more refined analyses tailored to specific urban contexts, especially concerning conventional public transportation. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a detailed analysis of Harbin's bus emissions, predicting future trends, and suggesting concrete reduction strategies.

Methods

The research employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • Carbon Emission Calculation: A mileage-based method is used to calculate carbon emissions from conventional buses, differentiating by energy type (petrol, diesel, natural gas, electric, hybrid).
  • Population and Bus Fleet Prediction: A Multi-factor Grey Prediction Model (MGM) is developed. This model is an advancement over the classical GM(1,1) by incorporating multiple influencing factors (natural growth rate, population structure, economic level) to predict population size and, subsequently, the number of conventional buses.
  • Scenario Analysis: Three distinct scenarios (pessimistic, baseline, optimistic) are constructed to forecast the future fuel structure of Harbin's bus fleet. These scenarios consider factors like the pace of electric bus adoption and infrastructure development.
  • Emission Forecasting: Combining the predicted population, bus fleet size, and fuel structure scenarios, the paper forecasts carbon emissions for conventional buses from 2023 to 2030.
  • Emission Reduction Path: Based on the analysis of influencing factors and predicted emissions, a set of technical and management suggestions for reducing carbon emissions from public transportation is proposed.

Datasets

The study utilizes historical data for Harbin's population and influencing factors from 2011 to 2020, sourced from the Harbin Statistical Yearbook and the National Bureau of Statistics. Specific parameters for carbon emission evaluation, such as vehicle quantities, energy consumption, and carbon emission factors, are derived from the Heilongjiang Provincial Road Transport Statistical Analysis Report and Information Compilation, along with references [42-47].

Key Insights and Ideas

  • MGM's Advantage for Limited Data: The paper highlights that the MGM, while not a parameterized algorithm requiring extensive training data, demonstrates superior prediction accuracy compared to LSTM and GRU when dealing with limited time-series data, as is often the case in regional studies. Its ability to incorporate multiple influencing factors is a key strength.
  • Scenario-Dependent Emission Trajectories: The choice of fuel structure significantly impacts future carbon emissions. The optimistic scenario, with a high proportion of electric buses, shows the lowest emissions, while the pessimistic scenario, with slower electrification, results in higher emissions.
  • Population Growth as a Driver: Even with increasing electrification, population growth in Harbin is identified as a factor that can drive up overall carbon emissions if not managed effectively.
  • Holistic Emission Reduction: The proposed emission reduction path emphasizes a multi-faceted approach, moving beyond just vehicle technology to include optimizing energy structure, standardizing driving behavior, building intelligent transportation systems, prioritizing public transport, and improving road infrastructure.

Key Results

  • Population Prediction: The MGM predicts Harbin's population to reach approximately 9.5824 million by 2030.
  • Fuel Structure Forecast: By 2030, the proportion of pure electric buses is projected to be 75% (pessimistic), 85% (baseline), and 92% (optimistic).
  • Carbon Emission Forecasts (2030):
    • Pessimistic Scenario: 266,310.84 tons
    • Benchmark Scenario: 261,947.71 tons
    • Optimistic Scenario: 260,562.21 tons
  • Model Performance: The MGM showed slightly better prediction performance (lower RMSE, MAE, MAPE) compared to LSTM and GRU for the population prediction task.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data Debatability: The availability and comprehensiveness of carbon emission data for conventional buses in Harbin are noted as a potential area for improvement.
  • Quantification of Reduction Path: The proposed emission reduction path is qualitative. The authors suggest that quantifying these strategies with mathematical models would provide more scientific and actionable insights.

Future work could focus on refining data collection, developing more detailed and quantified emission reduction strategies, and potentially expanding the analysis to include other modes of transportation within Harbin.

Summary updated

Abstract

As the northernmost megacity in China, the long winters, large population size, and unsustainable transport structure in Harbin determine that the city will produce relatively large carbon emissions. The transportation industry is one of the three greenhouse gas emission sources; therefore, the development of low-carbon transportation is imperative. This work compares commonly used carbon emission measurement methods and chooses a mileage method to classify the carbon emissions of conventional buses of different energy types used in Harbin in 2020. A multi-factor grey prediction model was constructed to predict the population size of Harbin and the number of conventional buses. After that, a scenario analysis method was used to analyze the fuel structure of buses in Harbin from three perspectives: a pessimistic scenario, a baseline scenario, and an optimistic scenario. The carbon emissions of conventional buses were calculated for Harbin from 2023 to 2030. Finally, by combining the prediction results and factors influencing carbon emission, a regular bus path to minimize carbon emissions is proposed. The outcome of this study shows that the carbon emission environment in Harbin will be improved by reducing vehicle energy consumption, optimizing energy structure, standardizing driving behavior, building intelligent transportation, giving priority to public transportation, and improving the road network structure.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023calculation,
  author = {Wenhui Zhang and Ge Zhou and Ziwen Song and Xintao Shi and Meiru Ye and Xirui Chen and Yuhao Xiang and Wenzhao Zheng and Pan Zhang},
  title = {{Calculation of Carbon Emissions and Study of the Emission Reduction Path of Conventional Public Transportation in Harbin City}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su152216025},
}
Figure