Abstract
In ${e}^{+}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}}$ event shapes studies at LEP, two different measurements were sometimes performed: a calorimetric'' measurement using both charged and neutral particles and atrack-based'' measurement using just charged particles. Whereas calorimetric measurements are infrared and collinear safe, and therefore calculable in perturbative QCD, track-based measurements necessarily depend on nonperturbative hadronization effects. On the other hand, track-based measurements typically have smaller experimental uncertainties. In this paper, we present the first calculation of the event shape ``track thrust'' and compare to measurements performed at ALEPH and DELPHI. This calculation is made possible through the recently developed formalism of track functions, which are nonperturbative objects describing how energetic partons fragment into charged hadrons. By incorporating track functions into soft-collinear effective theory, we calculate the distribution for track thrust with next-to-leading logarithmic resummation. Due to a partial cancellation between nonperturbative parameters, the distributions for calorimeter thrust and track thrust are remarkably similar, a feature also seen in LEP data.
Introduction
Event shapes in high-energy physics provide a window into the dynamics of quark and gluon radiation. A classic example is "thrust," which measures how collimated an event is along a specific axis. Traditionally, these are measured calorimetrically, incorporating all particles. Such observables are Infrared and Collinear (IRC) safe, allowing for direct calculation via perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD).
However, experimentalists often prefer track-based measurements, which utilize only charged particles. These benefit from the superior resolution of magnetic tracking systems but are IRC unsafe. Because they ignore neutral particles, they depend heavily on the non-perturbative process of hadronization.
Theoretical Framework: Track Functions and SCET
The breakthrough in this work is the application of track functions ($T_i(x, \mu)$). A track function describes the probability that a parton $i$ fragments into a set of charged tracks carrying a total energy fraction $x$. Unlike standard fragmentation functions, track functions capture correlations between all charged particles within a jet.
By integrating these functions into Soft-Collinear Effective Theory (SCET), the authors derived a factorization theorem for track thrust. This allows the cross-section to be decomposed into hard, jet, and soft components. The calculation was performed at Next-to-Leading Logarithmic (NLL') accuracy, which involves resumming infinite series of logarithmic terms to ensure stability at small thrust values.
Results and Comparison with LEP Data
The theoretical predictions were compared against historical data from the ALEPH and DELPHI experiments at the Large Electron-Positron Collider (LEP). The track functions themselves were characterized using parameters extracted from Pythia 8 simulations.
A striking observation in the experimental data is the similarity between calorimeter thrust ($\tau$) and track thrust ($\bar{\tau}$). The NLL' calculation provides an analytical explanation for this, revealing a partial cancellation between the logarithmic moments of quark and gluon track functions. Specifically, the cumulative distribution follows a simple relation: $\Sigma(\bar{\tau}^c) \simeq \Sigma(\tau^c) \times (3\bar{\tau}^c)^\Delta$, where the exponent $\Delta \approx 0.004$ is remarkably small.
The NLL' results show excellent quantitative agreement with DELPHI data, particularly in the "tail" region where perturbative effects are dominant. The inclusion of track functions effectively shifts the soft function by a non-perturbative parameter $\Omega_1$, capturing the bulk of the track-based effects.
Conclusion
This work provides the first rigorous analytical calculation of track thrust, bridging the gap between high-precision track-based measurements and first-principles QCD theory. The formalism of track functions is process-independent and can be evolved to different energy scales, making it a powerful tool for future studies at the LHC and beyond. Future work will focus on performing global fits of track functions directly from experimental data and extending the framework to more complex jet substructure observables.
Summary updated