Calculating Track-Based Observables for the LHC

Hsi-Ming Chang, Massimiliano Procura, Jesse Thaler, Wouter J. WaalewijnPhysical 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new theoretical framework, "track functions," to precisely calculate measurements at the LHC that rely only on charged particles. This approach is crucial for reducing "pileup" (background noise from multiple collisions) and for understanding the complex process of hadronization, where fundamental particles turn into the observable particles we detect.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is a powerful tool for exploring fundamental physics, but its measurements are often complicated by "pileup" – the overlapping signals from multiple proton-proton collisions happening simultaneously. Many important physics signals are carried by jets, which are sprays of particles produced from energetic quarks and gluons. Traditional methods for analyzing jets focus on "infrared and collinear-safe" (IRC-safe) observables, which are insensitive to soft (low-energy) or collinear (nearly parallel) particles. However, these methods often treat charged and neutral particles equally.

This paper addresses the challenge of developing precise theoretical predictions for observables that only depend on charged particles (tracks). Such "track-based" observables are highly desirable because tracking detectors at the LHC have better resolution than calorimeters, allowing for more precise measurements and a significant reduction in pileup contamination. The core problem is that these track-based observables are not infrared-safe in theoretical calculations. This means that standard perturbative QCD calculations, which rely on the cancellation of infrared divergences, break down. To overcome this, the paper proposes a way to incorporate the non-perturbative process of hadronization, where quarks and gluons transform into the charged particles we detect.

Methods

The authors introduce a new non-perturbative object called the track function, denoted as $T_i(x, \mu)$. This function describes the probability that a hard parton (like a quark or gluon) of type $i$ will fragment into charged hadrons carrying a fraction $x$ of its energy. The track function is defined in a way that absorbs the infrared divergences that plague track-based observables in perturbative calculations.

The key technique is matching: they match the partonic cross-sections (calculated in perturbative QCD) onto these new track functions. This is analogous to how fragmentation functions or parton distribution functions are used in other areas of QCD. They provide a field-theoretic definition of the track function and derive its renormalization group (RG) evolution equation. This equation describes how the track function changes with the energy scale $\mu$, allowing for predictions at different energy scales.

They demonstrate this formalism with two examples:

  1. $e^+e^- \to \text{hadrons}$: They perform a next-to-leading order (NLO) calculation of the total energy fraction carried by charged particles. This calculation involves matching the perturbative calculation of $e^+e^- \to q\bar{q}g$ onto track functions.
  2. Higgs + one jet events at the LHC: They show how to match the PYTHIA parton shower (a Monte Carlo simulation of hadronization) onto track functions to describe the track mass distribution in these events.

Datasets

The paper does not use "datasets" in the machine learning sense for training. Instead, they use the PYTHIA 8.150 event generator to extract initial, leading-order (LO) track functions. These extracted track functions are then used in their theoretical calculations and compared against PYTHIA's full simulation results. They also refer to a recent CMS study [25] for comparison with experimental data on charged particle energy fractions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Track functions as the missing piece: The paper provides a theoretical framework to handle observables that depend only on charged particles, which are crucial for reducing pileup at the LHC.
  • Bridging perturbative and non-perturbative QCD: Track functions act as a bridge, absorbing the non-perturbative effects of hadronization and allowing for precise predictions from perturbative calculations.
  • RG evolution for track functions: The derived RG evolution equation for track functions is a significant theoretical development, enabling predictions across different energy scales and showing excellent agreement with parton shower simulations.
  • Pileup suppression is achievable: By focusing on track-based observables and using this new formalism, experiments can significantly mitigate the impact of pileup, leading to cleaner signals and more precise measurements.
  • Dimensionless ratios reduce smearing: Measuring dimensionless ratios of track-based observables (like jet mass to jet $p_T$) can further reduce the smearing effects caused by hadronization fluctuations.

Key Results

  • They successfully define and derive the RG evolution for track functions, showing excellent agreement with the PYTHIA parton shower in both gluon and quark jets.
  • They perform an NLO calculation for the total energy fraction of charged particles in $e^+e^- \to \text{hadrons}$, demonstrating good convergence between LO and NLO predictions and agreement with PYTHIA.
  • They show how to apply the track function formalism to LHC-relevant processes, specifically matching PYTHIA onto track functions to describe the track mass distribution in Higgs + jet events, finding good agreement with PYTHIA's Lund string model.
  • They illustrate that dimensionless ratios of track-based observables can reduce smearing effects compared to direct measurements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hadronization correlations: The current formalism assumes independent fragmentation of partons. While this is a good approximation for many observables, hadronization correlations (which are power-suppressed) are not included and could be important for more precise calculations.
  • Power corrections: Non-perturbative power corrections, which can affect observables like jet mass, are only discussed qualitatively and are not fully incorporated into the presented formalism.
  • Extraction from data: The track functions used in the paper are extracted from PYTHIA. The ultimate goal is to extract these functions from actual LHC data, similar to how PDFs are determined, to achieve the highest precision.
  • Higher-order calculations: While the paper outlines how to perform higher-order calculations for the matching coefficients, these are computationally intensive and are a direction for future work.
  • More complex observables: Extending the formalism to more complex track-based observables, such as N-subjettiness ratios, is a promising avenue for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

By using observables that only depend on charged particles (tracks), one can efficiently suppress pileup contamination at the LHC. Such measurements are not infrared safe in perturbation theory, so any calculation of track-based observables must account for hadronization effects. We develop a formalism to perform these calculations in QCD, by matching partonic cross sections onto new nonperturbative objects called track functions which absorb infrared divergences. The track function Ti(x) describes the energy fraction x of a hard parton i which is converted into charged hadrons. We give a field-theoretic definition of the track function and derive its renormalization group evolution, which is in excellent agreement with the pythia parton shower. We then perform a next-to-leading order calculation of the total energy fraction of charged particles in e+ e-→ hadrons. To demonstrate the implications of our framework for the LHC, we match the pythia parton shower onto a set of track functions to describe the track mass distribution in Higgs plus one jet events. We also show how to reduce smearing due to hadronization fluctuations by measuring dimensionless track-based ratios.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chang2013calculating,
  author = {Hsi-Ming Chang and Massimiliano Procura and Jesse Thaler and Wouter J. Waalewijn},
  title = {{Calculating Track-Based Observables for the LHC}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.111.102002},
}
Figure