Calculating the Projective Norm of Higher-Order Tensors Using a Gradient Descent Algorithm

Atri Rudra, Maria Anastasia JivulescuMathematics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel gradient descent algorithm to efficiently calculate the projective norm of higher-order tensors, a crucial measure for detecting quantum entanglement that is notoriously difficult to compute. The algorithm demonstrates stable convergence and is extended to handle symmetric tensors and density matrices, offering a practical tool for quantum information science.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In quantum information science, entanglement is a key resource. The projective norm of a quantum state's tensor representation is a powerful tool for detecting and quantifying this entanglement. However, calculating this norm for higher-order tensors (representing multipartite systems with more than two parts) is an NP-hard problem. This computational intractability arises from the exponentially growing parameter space, making it challenging to find the exact projective norm for complex quantum states. Existing methods often struggle with convergence or are limited to simpler cases. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a robust and efficient algorithm for computing the projective norm of these complex, higher-order tensors.

Methods

The core of this paper is a novel gradient descent-based algorithm designed to estimate the projective norm of higher-order tensors. The algorithm is built upon the concept of Canonical Polyadic Decomposition (CPD), which approximates a tensor as a sum of rank-one tensors. The authors introduce modifications to CPD, specifically an "adaptive rank" approach and a "nuclear rank" optimization, to directly target the projective norm.

Key algorithmic components include:

  • Gradient Descent: The algorithm uses gradient descent to iteratively update parameters, aiming to minimize an objective function that incorporates both reconstruction error and a "rank cost" and "norm cost."
  • Nuclear Rank Canonical Polyadic Decomposition (NRCPD): This is a crucial extension of CPD. It simultaneously optimizes for the tensor decomposition (cores) and the nuclear rank, aiming to converge to the nuclear rank and the projective norm.
  • Adaptive Rank: The algorithm adaptively determines the effective rank of the tensor decomposition, allowing it to converge towards the minimal rank required for accurate approximation.
  • Extension to Symmetric Tensors: A specialized version, the Symmetric Nuclear Rank Canonical Polyadic Decomposition (SNRCPD), is developed to leverage the symmetry of certain tensors, simplifying computations and potentially improving bounds.
  • Extension to Density Matrices: The framework is further extended to handle density matrices, which represent mixed quantum states, by adapting the objective function and parameter space.

The algorithm is implemented using Python and the PyTorch library, leveraging its automatic differentiation and GPU acceleration capabilities.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses well-defined quantum states (both pure and mixed, and for various numbers of qubits/systems) for which analytical or previously computed numerical results are available. These include:

  • 2-qubit Bell states
  • 3-qubit GHZ and W states
  • Specific 3x3 and 4x4 bipartite mixed states with parameterized entanglement
  • Higher-order (4, 5, and 6 qubit) non-symmetric and symmetric states.

The goal is to compare the algorithm's output against these known values to validate its accuracy and effectiveness.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gradient Descent for NP-Hard Problems: The paper demonstrates that a gradient descent approach can be effectively applied to an NP-hard problem like projective norm computation, offering a practical solution where exact methods are infeasible.
  • Nuclear Rank as a Target: By explicitly optimizing for the nuclear rank alongside tensor decomposition, the algorithm directly targets the projective norm, providing a more direct path to the desired quantity.
  • Unified Framework: The algorithm's ability to be extended to symmetric tensors and density matrices highlights its versatility and potential as a general tool for analyzing quantum states.
  • Entanglement Detection Beyond Simple States: The application to higher-order tensors and mixed states allows for the analysis of more complex and realistic quantum systems, pushing the boundaries of entanglement characterization.
  • Sensitivity to Noise: The analysis of mixed states with parameterized noise demonstrates the algorithm's ability to reveal how entanglement measures change under realistic conditions.

Key Results

The paper presents extensive numerical results demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed gradient descent algorithm.

  • Accurate Convergence: For various pure and mixed quantum states (from 2-qubit systems up to 6-qubit systems), the algorithm consistently converges to values very close to analytically calculated projective norms. The difference between calculated and analytical values is typically on the order of $10^{-3}$ or less.
  • Correct Nuclear Rank: The algorithm also accurately computes the nuclear rank for these states, matching analytical results.
  • Scalability: The algorithm is shown to work for higher-order tensors (up to order 6), although computation time increases with tensor dimensionality.
  • Density Matrix Analysis: The algorithm successfully computes projective norms for both pure and mixed state density matrices, correctly identifying separable states (norm = 1) and quantifying entanglement in mixed states.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: For mixed states with tunable parameters, the algorithm effectively visualizes how the projective norm (and thus entanglement) varies, confirming known separability criteria.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost: While more efficient than exact methods, the gradient descent approach still incurs computational costs, especially for very high-order and high-dimensional tensors. The paper notes that computation time increases drastically with tensor dimensionality.
  • Convergence to Global Minimum: The paper states the algorithm "guarantees convergence to a minimum nuclear rank decomposition" and "global minimum norm values" in its abstract and introduction. However, in the description of the Alternating Method (Section 3.1), it's mentioned that this method "does not guarantee a global optimum, and might even converge to a local minimum or critical point." While the new gradient descent method is presented as an improvement, a formal proof of global convergence for all cases might be a future direction.
  • Analytical Results for High Orders: For tensors of order 4 and higher, analytical results are scarce due to the NP-hard nature of the problem. The paper relies on numerical results from other algorithms as a benchmark for these cases, which is a practical necessity but highlights the challenge.

Future work could focus on further optimizing the algorithm for speed and scalability, providing formal proofs of global convergence, and exploring its application to even more complex quantum systems or different entanglement measures. The availability of the code on GitHub suggests a path for community-driven development and application.

Summary updated

Abstract

Projective Norms are a class of tensor norms that map from the input to the output spaces. These norms are useful for providing a measure of entanglement. Calculating the projective norms is an NP-hard problem, which creates challenges in computing due to the complexity of the exponentially growing parameter space for higher-order tensors. We develop a novel gradient descent algorithm to estimate the projective norm of higher-order tensors. The algorithm exhibits stable convergence to a minimum nuclear-rank decomposition of the given tensor in all our numerical experiments. We further extend the algorithm to symmetric tensors and to density matrices. We demonstrate the performance of our algorithm by computing the nuclear rank and the projective norm for both pure and mixed states and provide numerical evidence supporting these results.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rudra2025calculating,
  author = {Atri Rudra and Maria Anastasia Jivulescu},
  title = {{Calculating the Projective Norm of Higher-Order Tensors Using a Gradient Descent Algorithm}},
  booktitle = {Mathematics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/math14010105},
}
Figure