Calculating the chemical exergy of materials

Charalampos Michalakakis, Jeremy Fouillou, Rick Lupton, Ana Gonzalez Hernandez, Jonathan M. CullenJournal of Industrial Ecology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel exergy calculator tool that compiles chemical exergy data for over 1400 materials, addressing a critical gap in resource efficiency analysis. This tool was used to create a global exergy flow map for 2013, revealing that the upstream material supply chain is only 72% resource efficient, with significant losses in refining, utilities, and industry sectors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern society's reliance on materials leads to substantial greenhouse gas emissions. While energy efficiency has been a focus, material efficiency is equally crucial for effective climate policy. Exergy analysis offers a powerful way to quantify the thermodynamic value of energy and material resources, identifying opportunities for improvement. However, a major hurdle has been the lack of comprehensive, readily accessible datasets for the chemical exergy of a wide range of materials. This scarcity makes large-scale exergy analyses computationally expensive and challenging, hindering the development of effective resource management strategies.

Methods

The core of this work is the development of an "exergy calculator" tool. This tool integrates various established methods for calculating chemical exergy, catering to different material types:

  • Homogeneous Mixtures: Utilizes Szargut's reference species and reactions method, drawing on pre-calculated standard chemical exergies from literature.
  • Organic Materials: Employs empirical correlations derived from experimental data, using either ultimate analysis (UA) data (elemental composition) or heating values (Higher Heating Value - HHV, Lower Heating Value - LHV).
  • Inorganic Materials: Includes pre-calculated values for specific inorganic materials and allows for user-defined mixtures of up to eight elements.

The calculator was initially built in Microsoft Excel using VBA and later developed into an online version using Python, Django, and HTML. The paper also details the use of Sankey diagrams to visualize global exergy flows, a technique chosen for its ubiquity in sustainability literature and its ability to represent exergy destruction as a distinct flow.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly list training datasets for the calculator. Instead, it relies on:

  • Literature Data: Pre-calculated chemical exergy values for various chemical species and materials from existing academic studies and textbooks.
  • Global Material and Energy Flow Data: Data on global flows of common materials and energy resources for the year 2013, sourced from organizations like the International Energy Agency (IEA), World Aluminium, and others (detailed in Supporting Information S2).

The paper introduces a new, comprehensive database of chemical exergy values for over 1400 substances within the developed exergy calculator, serving as a valuable resource for future research.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Exergy as a Unified Metric: Exergy is highlighted as a superior metric for resource analysis because it unifies energy and materials, accounts for their thermodynamic value, and, unlike energy, is not conserved, thus directly indicating potential for improvement.
  • The Criticality of Chemical Exergy Data: The lack of accessible chemical exergy data is identified as a significant bottleneck for large-scale exergy analysis, making the developed calculator a crucial tool for advancing the field.
  • Global Resource Inefficiency: The global exergy map reveals a surprisingly low upstream resource efficiency of 72% for 2013, indicating substantial room for improvement in how we extract and process materials.
  • Sectoral Bottlenecks: The refining, utilities, and industry sectors are pinpointed as major contributors to exergy losses, with utilities showing particularly low efficiency (44% when renewable electricity is excluded).
  • Policy Implications: The findings directly inform policymakers by identifying high-impact sectors (power generation and chemicals manufacturing) that, despite relatively low energy consumption, are responsible for a disproportionately large share of exergy losses and destruction.

Key Results

  • Exergy Calculator: Developed a tool with a database of over 1400 substances, capable of calculating chemical exergy for a wide range of materials.
  • Accuracy: Calculated chemical exergy values typically differ by less than 10% from literature estimates.
  • Global Exergy Map (2013):
    • Upstream global material supply chain efficiency: 72%.
  • Total exergy losses and destruction: 170 EJ.
  • Sectoral Analysis:
    • Refining sector efficiency: 92% (input-output definition). Losses: 15 EJ.
  • Utilities sector efficiency: 44% (excluding renewables). Losses: 101 EJ.
  • Industry sector efficiency: 50%. Losses: 54 EJ.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Physical Exergy Neglect: The study focuses solely on chemical exergy, neglecting physical exergy (due to temperature and pressure differences from the environment). This simplification was made due to the infeasibility of collecting such data for a global scope.
  • Input-Output Efficiency Definition: The use of an input-output definition for efficiency, rather than a product-fuel definition, may artificially inflate efficiency values for some sectors (e.g., refining).
  • Simplified Sankey Diagrams: The global Sankey diagram is at a relatively low level of detail, with some industrial sectors (e.g., manufacturing) not fully represented.
  • Nuclear Exergy: The calculator currently omits nuclear exergy, which is significant for materials like uranium ore.
  • Future Work:
    • Expand the calculator to include physical, kinetic, and potential exergy calculations by incorporating temperature, pressure, and height inputs.
  • Integrate nuclear exergy calculation into the tool.
  • Develop more detailed Sankey diagrams by breaking down sectors into finer stages and incorporating manufacturing processes.
  • Consider adding a "Useful Exergy" stage to the Sankey diagrams to better represent end-use efficiencies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Modern society requires large amounts of materials which lead to emissions of greenhouse gases. Effective climate policy should focus on not just energy efficiency but material efficiency as well. Exergy analysis is a powerful metric used to identify opportunities for efficiency improvement in industrial resource flow systems. Exergy offers a single unified measure of energy and material resources and indicates the real thermodynamic value of these resources, but the method suffers from a lack of comprehensive specific material chemical exergy datasets. The variety of different materials used in the global resource supply chain necessitates a combination of exergy calculation approaches. These approaches are combined into a single exergy calculator tool with over 1400 substances in the dataset. The chemical exergy values computed for key materials typically differ by less than 10% from values estimated in literature. The calculator is used in a case study of the upstream global material supply chain in 2013. The exergy resource map is visualized in a Sankey diagram and is found to be 72% resource efficient with 170 EJ of combined exergy losses and destruction. Further analysis is conducted on the refining, utilities, and industry sectors which are found to be 72%, 44%, and 50% resource efficient, respectively. Their combined losses and destruction are 15, 101, and 54 EJ, respectively. This study and the calculator developed provide a comprehensive dataset of chemical exergy values for a wide range of materials and can be applied in a variety of studies using exergy analysis.
BibTeX
@article{michalakakis2021calculating,
  author = {Charalampos Michalakakis and Jeremy Fouillou and Rick Lupton and Ana Gonzalez Hernandez and Jonathan M. Cullen},
  title = {{Calculating the chemical exergy of materials}},
  journal = {Journal of Industrial Ecology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1111/jiec.13120},
}
Figure