Cadre Modeling: Simultaneously Discovering Subpopulations and Predictive Models

Alexander New, Curt M. Breneman, Kristin P. BennettIJCNN 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces the Supervised Cadre Model (SCM), a novel framework that simultaneously discovers hidden subpopulations within data and learns predictive models for each. Unlike traditional methods, SCM performs feature selection for both subpopulation discovery and prediction, leading to more interpretable and robust models, as demonstrated in a cheminformatics case study predicting polymer glass transition temperature.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world scenarios, data naturally falls into distinct groups (subpopulations or cohorts) that exhibit different underlying relationships between features and a target variable. For instance, accident rates might differ significantly between young and old drivers. However, these subpopulations are often unknown a priori. Traditional approaches either assume known cohorts or use general, complex models that can be hard to interpret. This paper addresses the challenge of simultaneously discovering these hidden subpopulations and learning interpretable predictive models for each, going beyond simple clustering by integrating feature selection directly into the discovery and prediction process.

Methods

The core contribution is the Supervised Cadre Model (SCM). SCM divides the input space into probabilistic subpopulations called "cadres." Each cadre is associated with a predictive model, and importantly, the model learns both the cadre membership probabilities and the predictive models simultaneously.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Simultaneous Learning: Cadre membership and target prediction functions are learned together, not sequentially.
  • Probabilistic Subpopulations: Cadres are defined by soft assignments (probabilities) rather than hard partitions, allowing for smoother transitions and more nuanced modeling.
  • Feature Selection: Sparsity-inducing priors (elastic net) are used on model parameters, enabling independent feature selection for both cadre assignment and target prediction. This means different features can be important for defining a subpopulation versus predicting the target within that subpopulation.
  • Interpretable Models: The goal is to learn interpretable models for both cadre characterization and target prediction, achieved through sparsity and the inherent structure of the SCM.
  • Adaptive Optimization: The model is trained using adaptive step-size stochastic gradient descent (Adam) to handle the non-convex optimization problem.

Datasets

The paper evaluates SCM on:

  • Simulated Data: Used for a motivating two-dimensional example.
  • Cheminformatics Dataset: A real-world dataset for predicting polymer glass transition temperature (Tg), with 262 polymers and initially 119 features, reduced to 28 after correlation filtering.
  • UCI Repository Benchmarks: Several standard datasets were used for broader evaluation, including: Airfoil Self Noise (Airfoil), AirQuality, Boston Housing (Boston), Concrete Compressive Strength (Concrete), Facebook Comment Volume (Facebook), SkillCraft1 Master Table (GameSkill), and Parkinson's Telemonitoring (Parkinson). For the Parkinson's dataset, two targets were considered, leading to separate models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Feature Selection is Crucial for Discovery: The SCM's ability to perform feature selection independently for cadre assignment and prediction is key. This allows it to identify subpopulations based on specific features, even if those features aren't the primary predictors for the target within that subpopulation.
  • Interpretability Through Sparsity: By enforcing sparsity in both cadre membership and prediction functions, SCM provides insights into which features define the subpopulations and which features are important for prediction within each. This is a significant advantage over black-box models.
  • Cadres as "Chemically Meaningful" Groups: In the polymer example, the discovered cadres were not just arbitrary groupings but corresponded to chemically distinct types of polymers with different sensitivities to structural changes, offering valuable design insights.
  • Beyond K-Means: The paper demonstrates that standard clustering methods like K-means can fail to discover true subpopulations when the clustering rule doesn't align with the predictive task, whereas SCM, by integrating prediction, succeeds.

Key Results

  • Generalization Performance: SCM achieved state-of-the-art prediction accuracy for the polymer Tg dataset. On benchmark datasets, SCM's generalization error (MSE) was competitive with, and often superior to, linear, piecewise-linear, and even some nonlinear regression models (like RBF SVR), particularly when interpretability was also considered.
  • Robust Subpopulations: The "average best match" metric showed that SCM consistently identified stable subpopulations across bootstrap samples.
  • Sparse Models: Cadre assignment mechanisms were found to be very sparse (e.g., only 11 out of 28 features used for cadre assignment in the polymer case study), enhancing interpretability.
  • Distinct Cadre Models: Regression weights varied significantly across cadres, indicating that different underlying relationships govern the target variable within each subpopulation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Linear Models: The current work focuses on linear prediction functions within cadres. Future work could extend this to nonlinear functions.
  • Generalizability to Other Tasks: While the framework is presented as applicable to classification and other supervised learning tasks, the paper primarily demonstrates regression. Further exploration of its application to other problem types is suggested.
  • Hyperparameter Tuning: Like most machine learning models, SCM relies on hyperparameter tuning (e.g., number of cadres, regularization strengths), which was performed via cross-validation.
  • Computational Cost: While using adaptive gradient descent helps, training complex models on large datasets can still be computationally intensive.

The authors suggest that SCM can be customized for different subpopulation definitions, base functions, and learning tasks by modifying the gating, emission, and loss functions. They are actively applying cadre analysis to other problem classes, including classification and risk analysis, highlighting its potential for discovering informative subpopulations across various domains.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{new2018cadre,
  author = {Alexander New and Curt M. Breneman and Kristin P. Bennett},
  title = {{Cadre Modeling: Simultaneously Discovering Subpopulations and Predictive Models}},
  booktitle = {IJCNN},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1109/ijcnn.2018.8489618},
}
Figure