Ca2Ru1-xCrxO4 (0 < x < 0.13): Negative volume thermal expansion via orbital and magnetic orders

T. F. Qi, O. B. Korneta, Meng Ge, L. E. De Long, Guang‐Han Cao, Sean ParkinarXiv 2010 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Ca2RuO4 undergoes a metal-insulator transition at $T_{MI} = 357$ K, followed by a well-separated transition to antiferromagnetic order at $T_N = 110$ K. Dilute Cr doping for Ru reduces the temperature of the orthorhombic distortion at $T_{MI}$ and induces ferromagnetic behavior at $T_C$. The lattice volume $V$ of $Ca_2Ru_{1-x}Cr_xO_4$ ($0 < x < 0.13$) abruptly expands with cooling at both $T_{MI}$ and $T_C$, giving rise to a total volume expansion $\Delta V/V \approx 1\%$, which sharply contrasts the smooth temperature dependence of the few known examples of negative volume thermal expansion driven by anharmonic phonon modes. In addition, the near absence of volume thermal expansion between $T_C$ and $T_{MI}$ represents an Invar effect. The two phase transitions suggest an exotic ground state driven by an extraordinary coupling between spin, orbit and lattice degrees of freedom.

Introduction

Most materials follow a fundamental thermodynamic trend: they expand when heated and contract when cooled. Negative Volume Thermal Expansion (NVTE)—where a material expands upon cooling—is a rare and highly prized property in materials science. NVTE materials are essential for engineering high-precision composites with zero or controlled thermal expansion, such as those used in aerospace components or dental fillers. Typically, NVTE is a continuous process driven by anharmonic phonon modes (atomic vibrations).

This study investigates the ruthenate $Ca_2RuO_4$, a "Mott insulator" where electron-electron repulsion dominates physical behavior. In its pure form, $Ca_2RuO_4$ exhibits a severe structural distortion that often shatters crystals during cooling. By introducing dilute Chromium (Cr) doping, researchers have "unlocked" the lattice, revealing a unique two-step NVTE mechanism driven not by vibrations, but by discrete quantum phase transitions involving electron orbitals and magnetic alignment.

Experimental Methods

High-quality single crystals of $Ca_2Ru_{1-x}Cr_xO_4$ (with $x$ ranging from 0 to 0.135) were synthesized using a floating zone optical furnace. This method ensures the high purity necessary for observing subtle phase transitions in correlated electron systems.

To characterize the relationship between the crystal structure and electronic states, the team employed several techniques:

  • Single-crystal X-ray diffraction (XRD): Conducted between 90 K and 295 K to track precise changes in the $a, b,$ and $c$ lattice axes.
  • Energy Dispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis: Used to verify the exact stoichiometry and Chromium concentration in the samples.
  • Magnetization and Resistivity measurements: Performed using Physical Property Measurement Systems (PPMS) to correlate structural changes with the material's magnetic state and electrical conductivity.

Crucially, measurements were performed on the same single crystals for each composition to ensure that structural, electronic, and magnetic data were directly comparable.

Key Insights and Results

The Two-Step Expansion Mechanism

Unlike traditional NVTE materials that expand smoothly, Cr-doped $Ca_2RuO_4$ exhibits two distinct "jumps" in volume as it cools. The first jump occurs at the Metal-Insulator transition ($T_{MI}$), where the ordering of electron orbitals forces a structural reconfiguration. The second jump occurs at the magnetic transition ($T_C$), where electron spins align. For a representative sample ($x = 0.067$), the volume expanded abruptly by approximately 0.66% at $T_{MI}$ (~210 K) and by an additional 0.2% at $T_C$ (~130 K), totaling a massive 1% expansion.

The Invar Effect

Between these two transition temperatures, the material exhibits an "Invar effect," where the volume remains nearly constant despite changes in temperature. This window of dimensional stability (spanning approximately 100 K) is of significant interest for applications requiring high precision across varying thermal environments.

Spin-Orbit-Lattice Coupling

The research demonstrates that Cr doping "softens" the buckled crystal structure of the parent compound. This allows the lattice to respond dramatically to changes in the electronic and magnetic ground states. The results provide clear evidence of an "extraordinary coupling" where the magnetic state of the electrons can physically force the entire crystal lattice to expand, rather than contract.

Phase Diagram and Critical Concentration

The study mapped the evolution of these properties as a function of Cr concentration. The researchers identified a critical point at $x \approx 0.135$, beyond which the structural distortions and the NVTE effect vanish, and the material reverts to standard thermal contraction behavior.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The discovery of two-step NVTE in $Ca_2Ru_{1-x}Cr_xO_4$ highlights the potential of using Mott insulators to design materials with extreme thermal properties. While the experimental evidence for spin-orbit-lattice coupling is robust, several questions remain. The exact nature of the orbital ground state in ruthenates is still debated, and a comprehensive microscopic theory explaining why these transitions favor expansion over contraction is still under development. Future research may also explore whether these effects can be replicated in polycrystalline or thin-film formats, which would be more suitable for large-scale industrial applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ca2RuO4 undergoes a metal-insulator transition at TMI = 357 K, followed by a well-separated transition to antiferromagnetic order at TN = 110 K. Dilute Cr doping for Ru reduces the temperature of the orthorhombic distortion at TMI and induces ferromagnetic behavior at TC. The lattice volume V of Ca2Ru1-xCrxO4 (0 &lt; x &lt; 0.13) abruptly expands with cooling at both TMI and TC, giving rise to a total volume expansion ΔV/V {\simeq} 1 %, which sharply contrasts the smooth temperature dependence of the few known examples of negative volume thermal expansion driven by anharmonic phonon modes. In addition, the near absence of volume thermal expansion between TC and TMI represents an Invar effect. The two phase transitions suggest an exotic ground state driven by an extraordinary coupling between spin, orbit and lattice degrees of freedom.
BibTeX
@misc{qi2010ca,
  author = {T. F. Qi and O. B. Korneta and Meng Ge and L. E. De Long and Guang‐Han Cao and Sean Parkin},
  title = {{Ca2Ru1-xCrxO4 (0 \&lt; x \&lt; 0.13): Negative volume thermal expansion via orbital and magnetic orders}},
  year = {2010},
  eprint = {1009.6177},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1009.6177},
}
Figure