TL;DR
This paper shows that rational functions and neural networks using rational activation functions can approximate functions and their derivatives with high accuracy. This is a significant step towards understanding the expressive power of neural networks and has direct implications for symbolic regression tasks, like learning physical laws.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Neural networks are known for their "universal approximation property," meaning they can approximate a wide range of functions. However, most theoretical analyses focus on approximating the function itself, not its derivative. This is a crucial limitation for applications like optimal control and model learning, where understanding the rate of change is essential. Furthermore, while neural networks with standard activation functions like ReLU have been studied extensively, the approximation capabilities of networks using rational functions as activations, and their ability to achieve C¹-approximation (uniform approximation of both the function and its derivative), remain less understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing theoretical guarantees for C¹-approximation using rational functions and rational neural networks.
Methods
The core of the paper's methodology involves two main strategies:
- Approximating ReQU with Rational Functions: The authors first focus on the Rectified Quadratic Unit (ReQU) activation function, which is a polynomial. They demonstrate that ReQU can be approximated in the C¹-norm by specific types of rational functions (fractions of polynomials) with a provably good rate. This is achieved by leveraging Newman polynomials and constructing specific rational functions that mimic the behavior of ReQU and its derivative.
- Transferring Approximation to General Functions and Architectures:
- Rational Neural Networks: They define "rational neural networks" where the activation functions are rational functions. By replacing the ReQU activations in existing neural network architectures with their rational approximations, they construct rational neural networks that can approximate functions and their derivatives.
- Tensor-Product Splines: A key part of the proof involves approximating tensor-product splines (a type of piecewise polynomial function) using rational neural networks. This is done by breaking down the splines into simpler components (like ReQU terms) and approximating each component with rational functions.
- General Functions: Finally, they leverage results from prior work that show certain classes of smooth functions can be approximated by ReQU neural networks. By combining this with their finding that ReQU neural networks can be approximated by rational neural networks, they establish C¹-approximation results for general smooth functions using rational neural networks.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical approximation guarantees rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.
Key Insights and Ideas
- C¹-Approximation is Achievable with Rationals: The most significant insight is that functions can be approximated not just in value but also in their rate of change (derivative) using rational functions and rational neural networks. This is a non-trivial result, as derivatives of rational functions are not always easily approximated by simpler rationals.
- Rational Activations Offer Strong Approximation Power: The paper demonstrates that rational functions, when used as activation functions in neural networks, can achieve approximation rates that are competitive with, and in some cases better than, polynomial approximations.
- Bridging Theory and Practice: The work connects theoretical approximation capabilities of rational functions to practical neural network architectures, particularly those relevant for symbolic regression (like EQL⁺ and ParFam).
- ReQU as a Bridge: The ReQU activation function serves as a crucial intermediate step, allowing the authors to bridge the gap between standard polynomial-based approximations and the more general rational function approximations.
Key Results
- ReQU Approximation: The Rectified Quadratic Unit (ReQU) can be approximated in C¹([-1,1]) by rational functions of type (n+1, n-1) with an error rate that decays exponentially with n.
- Rational Neural Networks for Smooth Functions: For a class of sufficiently regular functions (specifically, those in a Hölder ball), rational neural networks can achieve C¹-approximation with rates that are better than polynomial approximations.
- Approximation for Specific Architectures: The theoretical results directly imply C¹-approximation capabilities for architectures like ParFam and EQL⁺, which are used in symbolic regression for physical law learning.
- Tensor-Product Spline Approximation: The paper provides a detailed construction and error analysis for approximating tensor-product splines using rational neural networks, showing a rate of $O(N^{-(\beta-1)})$ for functions in a Hölder ball of order $\beta$.
Limitations and Future Work
- Assumptions on Activations: The theoretical results for general neural network architectures (like in Lemma 16) rely on assumptions about the activation functions, specifically that their inverses are in a certain Hölder space. This condition can be restrictive.
- Generalization to Higher-Order Derivatives: The current work focuses on C¹-approximation (first-order derivatives). Future research directions include investigating higher-order approximation power and Cᵏ-approximability for k ≥ 2.
- Lower Degree Rational Functions: Exploring better first-order approximation power under a lower degree of the rational functions is also suggested.
- Alternative Approximations: The paper mentions that other rational approximation techniques (e.g., using Zolotarev sign functions) could potentially be explored for approximating activation functions.
- Practical Performance: While the paper provides theoretical guarantees, it acknowledges that practical performance of optimally trained networks of the discussed types can be strong, suggesting that further investigation into practical aspects is warranted.
Summary updated