Byzantine Fault-Tolerant Min-Max Optimization

Shuo Liu, Nitin H. VaidyaarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Min-max optimization is a cornerstone of robust decision-making, yet it remains highly susceptible to Byzantine failures. This paper presents the first framework for Byzantine fault-tolerant min-max optimization. By shifting the objective from the absolute maximum to the $(f+1)$-th largest cost, the proposed method ensures a consensus that remains unaffected by up to $f$ malicious participants. We detail a distributed implementation using the DIRECT (DIviding RECTangles) algorithm, providing theoretical guarantees on convergence and accuracy even in non-convex landscapes.

1. Introduction

Standard min-max optimization seeks to minimize the "worst-case" cost among $n$ different functions. This is a common objective in engineering and social choice, such as finding a meeting location that minimizes the maximum travel time for any participant. However, this approach is extremely fragile: a single "Byzantine" agent—one who is malicious or faulty—can provide a fabricated cost function that forces the entire group to a location of the attacker's choosing.

While significant research has addressed fault-tolerant minimization of sums (common in federated learning), min-max optimization in the presence of adversaries has remained largely unexplored. The challenge lies in the fact that we do not know which agents are faulty a priori, and a clever adversary can hide their behavior behind seemingly plausible data.

2. The Rank-Based Objective

To address this vulnerability, this work moves away from minimizing the absolute maximum (Rank 1) and instead proposes a Rank-based Byzantine Fault-Tolerant Algorithm.

The core of the framework is the objective function $g_{f+1}(x)$, defined as the $(f+1)$-th largest value among all $n$ cost functions at point $x$. By "skipping" the top $f$ values, the algorithm effectively ignores the potential influence of up to $f$ malicious actors. This $(f+1)$-th rank represents the tightest possible bound achievable without knowing which agents are faulty; if one attempts to bound more than $f$ functions, an adversary can still lead the optimization arbitrarily far astray.

3. Optimization Strategy: Beyond Gradient Descent

A significant hurdle in this approach is that $g_{f+1}(x)$ is often non-convex, even if the underlying individual cost functions are convex. The authors explicitly demonstrate that standard gradient descent is unsuitable for this problem. A Byzantine agent can create "unlucky" local minima or manipulate gradients to ensure the algorithm never reaches a globally meaningful solution.

To navigate this non-convex landscape, the authors adapt DIRECT (DIviding RECTangles), a deterministic global optimization algorithm. The process is implemented via a server-client architecture:

  1. Space Partitioning: A trusted server partitions the search space into hypercubes.
  2. Function Evaluation: The server requests specific function evaluations from the agents.
  3. Iterative Refinement: The server identifies "potentially optimal" regions and iteratively narrows the search.

4. Theoretical Results and Guarantees

The paper provides several key mathematical guarantees regarding the performance and convergence of the algorithm:

  • Robustness Bound: The authors prove that if $n \ge 2f + 1$, the algorithm produces an output $\hat{x}$ that is "accurate" relative to the set of non-faulty agents. Specifically, the output is strictly bounded between the minimum of the "best" non-faulty function and the minimum of the "worst" non-faulty function.
  • Convergence: For the approximate version of the algorithm, the output is proven to be bounded by a factor of $\frac{1}{1-\epsilon}$ relative to the ideal non-faulty solution.
  • Global Reach: The DIRECT-based distributed algorithm is proven to produce a set of sampled points that is "everywhere dense" in the search space, ensuring it eventually finds the global minimum of the rank-based objective.

5. Discussion and Limitations

While this framework provides a robust theoretical foundation for Byzantine fault-tolerant min-max optimization, several practical challenges remain. The DIRECT algorithm, while robust, typically struggles with the "curse of dimensionality," making it difficult to scale to very high-dimensional spaces. Additionally, the current model assumes a "trusted" server to coordinate the agents; future research may explore fully decentralized (peer-to-peer) settings.

Finally, while evaluating the $(f+1)$-th rank at every sampling step adds sorting overhead, this cost is generally manageable compared to the computational expense of function evaluations in complex engineering contexts. This work marks a significant step toward making robust optimization resilient against active sabotage.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{liu2022byzantine,
  author = {Shuo Liu and Nitin H. Vaidya},
  title = {{Byzantine Fault-Tolerant Min-Max Optimization}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2205.14881},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.14881},
}
Figure