Burkholderia cepacia Enhanced Electrokinetic-Permeable Reaction Barrier for the Remediation of Lead Contaminated Soils

Yun He, Linlin Yang, Chi He, Feifei WangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study introduces an enhanced electrokinetic-permeable reactive barrier (EK-PRB) system for lead-contaminated soil remediation. By developing a novel iron-manganese modified attapulgite (FeMn-ATP) sheet material and integrating it with Burkholderia cepacia bioaugmentation, the researchers achieved significantly improved lead removal efficiency and reduced energy expenditure compared to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heavy metal contamination, particularly lead (Pb), poses a significant threat to soil health and human well-being. While electrokinetic (EK) and permeable reactive barrier (PRB) technologies show promise for in-situ soil remediation, their practical application is often hindered by high energy costs and limitations in material effectiveness. Existing PRB materials can be costly, difficult to handle, or lack sufficient adsorption capacity. Furthermore, the synergistic effects of combining advanced PRB materials with microbial enhancements in an EK system, especially within a hexagonal electric field configuration, remain an area ripe for investigation. This paper aims to address these challenges by developing a cost-effective, high-performance PRB material and leveraging microbial activity to boost the efficiency of EK-PRB remediation for lead-contaminated soils.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel sheet-form PRB material based on natural attapulgite (ATP) modified with iron and manganese oxides (FeMn-ATP). This material was prepared through a precipitation and calcination process, followed by incorporation into a hydrogel matrix using sodium alginate and polyvinyl alcohol. The FeMn-ATP material was then tested for its lead adsorption capacity.

For the remediation experiments, a hexagonal rod electrode configuration was employed within an electrokinetic reactor. This setup was designed to create a non-uniform electric field, potentially enhancing remediation efficiency. The FeMn-ATP sheet material was integrated as a PRB adjacent to the electrodes.

A key innovation was the use of Burkholderia cepacia as a bioaugmentation agent. The soil was pre-treated with this bacterium to induce changes in soil pH and promote lead dissolution. The study compared the performance of the EK-PRB system with and without microbial pre-treatment.

Characterization techniques included:

  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): To observe the surface structure of the PRB materials.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To analyze the crystal phase and composition of the PRB materials.
  • Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR): To identify functional groups and chemical bonds.
  • Inductively Coupled Plasma Atomic Emission Spectrometry (ICP-OES): To quantify lead concentrations in soil and PRB materials.
  • Selective Sequential Extraction: To determine the chemical forms (fractions) of lead in the soil before and after remediation.

Datasets

The study utilized actual contaminated soil collected from a former film machinery factory site in Shanghai, China. The physical and chemical properties of this soil were characterized and are presented in Table 1. No other specific datasets were mentioned for training or evaluation purposes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • FeMn-ATP as a Superior Adsorbent: The FeMn-ATP material demonstrated significantly higher lead adsorption capacity compared to other modified ATP materials, suggesting that the combination of iron and manganese is crucial for effective lead binding.
  • Sheet PRB Advantage: The development of a sheet-form PRB material offers practical advantages in terms of handling and integration into engineering applications compared to traditional powder forms.
  • Microbial Synergy: Burkholderia cepacia pre-treatment played a critical role in enhancing lead removal. The bacterium's ability to lower soil pH and produce organic acids facilitated the dissolution of lead, making it more accessible for adsorption by the PRB and removal via electrokinetics.
  • Hexagonal Electrode Field: The use of a hexagonal rod electrode configuration appears to be beneficial, potentially creating a more effective electric field distribution for pollutant migration.
  • Transformation of Lead Fractions: Microbial activity not only removed lead but also transformed its chemical forms, shifting it from less mobile fractions (e.g., Fe-Mn oxidation) to more mobile ones, thereby facilitating its removal.

Key Results

  • The FeMn-ATP material exhibited the highest lead adsorption performance, reaching 2521 ± 377.1 mg/kg.
  • In the microbial group, the adsorption amount of lead by the FeMn-ATP PRB at the anode and cathode increased by 69.1% and 42.1%, respectively, compared to the control group.
  • The concentration of residual lead in the anode soil was significantly lower in the microbial group, and the overall lead removal rate was increased by 26%.
  • The adsorption process of Pb2+ by FeMn-ATP material followed quasi-first-order reaction kinetics, suggesting physical adsorption as the primary mechanism.
  • The adsorption isotherm fit the Freundlich model, indicating heterogeneous multi-layer adsorption.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Energy Expenditure: While the study aimed to reduce energy expenditure, the paper notes that high energy expenditure is still a limitation of EK-PRB technology in general. Further optimization for energy efficiency is likely needed.
  • Long-term Stability: The long-term stability and effectiveness of the FeMn-ATP PRB material and the microbial community in situ were not extensively studied.
  • Scale-up: The study was conducted at a laboratory scale. Further research is needed to assess the feasibility and effectiveness of this technology for large-scale field applications.
  • Microbial Community Dynamics: While Burkholderia cepacia was identified as beneficial, a more in-depth analysis of the overall microbial community dynamics and their long-term impact on soil health and remediation efficiency would be valuable.
  • Other Heavy Metals: The study focused specifically on lead. Investigating the effectiveness of this enhanced EK-PRB system for other heavy metal contaminants would broaden its applicability.

Summary updated

Abstract

The combination of electrokinetic (EK) and permeable reactive barrier (PRB) is a potentially effective technology for the remediation of heavy-metal-contaminated soils, but high energy expenditure limits its application in practice. In order to further improve the remediation efficiency and reduce the cost, some improvements were made in this study in terms of new PRB material, the spatial configuration of the rod electrode, and the microbial enhancement. Differently from previous powder PRB materials, six thin-film PRB materials were prepared using cheap natural attapulgite (ATP) and metal salts. PRB is a tough material that can be plugged and pulled out in engineering. The heavy metals adsorbed on it can be extracted from the soil, eliminating the risk of subsequent secondary pollution. Therefore, it has a strong operational ability. Among them, the FeMn-ATP material exhibited the best adsorption performance (2521 ± 377.1 mg/kg) for Pb. The results of the transmission electron microscope, X-ray diffractometer, and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy showed that iron and manganese were successfully loaded on the material. The Burkholderia cepacia pre-treatment led to soil pH decrease and the dissolution of Pb, and the morphological composition of Pb in the soil was also changed. In the microbial group, the adsorption amount of Pb by PRB at the anode and cathode increased by 69.1% and 42.1%, respectively. The concentration of the residual lead in the anode soil was significantly lower than that in the control group without microorganisms, and the removal rate of Pb was increased by 26%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2022burkholderia,
  author = {Yun He and Linlin Yang and Chi He and Feifei Wang},
  title = {{Burkholderia cepacia Enhanced Electrokinetic-Permeable Reaction Barrier for the Remediation of Lead Contaminated Soils}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141811440},
}
Figure