Buoyancy-driven bubbly flows: ordered and free rise at small and intermediate volume fraction

Aurore Loisy, Aurore Naso, Peter SpeltJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses direct numerical simulations to investigate how bubbles rise in liquids, both in ordered arrangements and as freely moving suspensions. It reveals that bubble rise velocity isn't always a simple decrease with bubble concentration, and that bubble shape and motion can become surprisingly complex due to wake interactions, even leading to oblique rising paths.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting how bubbles move in liquids is crucial for many industrial processes like chemical reactors and heat exchangers. While we have some models for how bubbles rise, they often simplify the complex interactions between bubbles, especially when the bubbles are not perfectly ordered or when they deform. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using advanced simulations to understand the rise velocity and behavior of bubbles in both ordered and more realistic, freely moving suspensions, across a range of conditions where inertia and bubble deformation are important.

Methods

The authors employ direct numerical simulations (DNS) using a one-fluid formulation of the Navier-Stokes equations. This approach treats the liquid and gas as a single fluid with discontinuous properties and incorporates surface tension using a continuum surface force model. A level-set method is used to capture the moving interface between the bubble and the liquid. To ensure accuracy and stability, they use high-order schemes for advection and spatial discretization, along with a volume conservation correction. They also perform analytical work, particularly in the dilute limit, to complement their numerical findings.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations and comparisons with existing experimental data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-monotonic rise velocity: Contrary to simple models, the average bubble rise velocity doesn't always decrease monotonically with increasing bubble concentration. Cooperative wake interactions can actually increase the rise velocity at low concentrations.
  • Shape transformation: Deformable bubbles, initially ellipsoidal, tend to become more spherical as their concentration increases. The fore-and-aft asymmetry of isolated bubbles is reversed in concentrated suspensions.
  • Oblique rise: Bubbles can rise in paths not perfectly aligned with gravity, a phenomenon that can be steady, oscillatory, or even chaotic. This oblique motion is linked to wake interactions and the resulting lift forces.
  • Ordered vs. Free: Surprisingly, freely moving bubbles in suspensions exhibit many similarities to bubbles in ordered arrays, suggesting that ordered models can offer valuable insights into real-world bubbly flows. This is attributed to free bubbles maintaining relatively stable neighbor relationships.

Key Results

  • The paper provides a comprehensive study of bubble rise velocity and shape for ordered arrays across various Archimedes and Bond numbers, covering spherical, ellipsoidal, and dimpled-cap bubble shapes.
  • They demonstrate that the rise velocity of ordered suspensions can increase with volume fraction at low concentrations due to cooperative wake effects, a finding supported by analytical work in the dilute limit.
  • Numerical simulations show that the fore-and-aft asymmetry of isolated ellipsoidal bubbles is reversed in concentrated suspensions, and their aspect ratio approaches unity.
  • The study identifies distinct regimes of bubble motion: steady vertical rise, steady oblique rise, oscillatory oblique rise, and chaotic oblique rise, depending on flow conditions and volume fraction.
  • Comparisons with experimental data show good agreement, particularly in the trends observed for bubble rise velocity with volume fraction, lending support to the relevance of their findings.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The study is restricted to bubbles rising at Reynolds numbers not exceeding 40. Higher Reynolds numbers might introduce path instabilities in single bubbles, requiring more advanced simulations.
  • The current conclusions apply to perfectly homogeneous, monodisperse, and clean bubble systems. Real bubbly flows often involve shear, polydispersity, and surfactants, which can significantly alter bubble behavior.
  • The authors suggest that their work forms a basis for investigating passive scalar transport and turbulent bubbly flows. Further research could explore the impact of these additional complexities on bubble dynamics.
  • The computational cost limits the exploration of very dilute regimes and very large numbers of bubbles in free arrays.

Summary updated

Abstract

Various expressions have been proposed previously for the rise velocity of gas bubbles in homogeneous steady bubbly flows, generally a monotonically decreasing function of the bubble volume fraction. For suspensions of freely moving bubbles, some of these are of the form expected for ordered arrays of bubbles, and vice versa, as they do not reduce to the behaviour expected theoretically in the dilute limit. The microstructure of weakly inhomogeneous bubbly flows not being known generally, the effect of microstructure is an important consideration. We revisit this problem here for bubbly flows at small to moderate Reynolds number values for deformable bubbles, using direct numerical simulation and analysis. For ordered suspensions, the rise velocity is demonstrated not to be monotonically decreasing with volume fraction due to cooperative wake interactions. The fore-and-aft asymmetry of an isolated ellipsoidal bubble is reversed upon increasing the volume fraction, and the bubble aspect ratio approaches unity. Recent work on rising bubble pairs is used to explain most of these results; the present work therefore forms a platform of extending the former to suspensions of many bubbles. We adopt this new strategy also to support the existence of the oblique rise of ordered suspensions, the possibility of which is also demonstrated analytically. Finally, we demonstrate that most of the trends observed in ordered systems also appear in freely evolving suspensions. These similarities are supported by prior experimental measurements and attributed to the fact that free bubbles keep the same neighbours for extended periods of time.
BibTeX
@article{loisy2017buoyancy,
  author = {Aurore Loisy and Aurore Naso and Peter Spelt},
  title = {{Buoyancy-driven bubbly flows: ordered and free rise at small and intermediate volume fraction}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1017/jfm.2017.64},
}

Loading related content...

Figure