Bunch coalescing in the main ring to form intense proton and antiproton bunches without RF counterphasing

Jim E. Griffin, J. MacLachlan, G.n. Nicholls, Z. Qian1984 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a simplified method for bunch coalescing in particle accelerators, crucial for creating intense proton and antiproton beams for collisions. Instead of complex RF counterphasing to reduce voltage, they introduce a "shearing" technique using RF-off drifting and high-voltage rotation, which is technically simpler and potentially more reliable for routine operation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

To achieve high-luminosity collisions in particle colliders like the Tevatron, beams need to be very intense. This requires packing a large number of particles into a small number of bunches. However, the initial bunches injected into the main ring have a longitudinal emittance (a measure of their spread in energy and time) that is too large to be efficiently accelerated without significant particle loss and emittance growth.

The standard solution involves "bunch coalescing," where multiple smaller bunches are combined into fewer, larger ones. A key step in this process is reducing the RF voltage in the accelerating cavities to allow the bunches to spread out and then be rotated in phase space to merge. The challenge lies in reducing the RF voltage from the megavolt level down to a few kilovolts. The previously proposed method, "RF counterphasing," achieves this by carefully shifting the phase of RF power between two groups of cavities. While effective, this method is technically demanding and requires precise control. This paper seeks a simpler, more robust alternative.

Methods

The core innovation presented is a "shearing" technique that replaces the complex adiabatic voltage reduction of RF counterphasing. The proposed method involves:

  1. RF-off Drift: The main RF system is turned off for a specific duration (milliseconds). During this time, the bunches drift, allowing their phase spread to increase.
  2. High-Voltage Rotation: The RF is briefly turned back on at high voltage (around 1 MV) for a short period (microseconds). This rotates the already spread-out bunches in phase space, effectively "shearing" them.
  3. Low-Voltage Debunching and Recapture: A low-voltage RF system (around 100 V) is then used for a longer period (seconds) to further debunch the particles. Finally, a high-voltage 53 MHz RF system is used to recapture the coalesced particles into a single, intense bunch.

This method bypasses the need for precise phase shifting and the extremely low voltages required by counterphasing, relying instead on a simpler off/on sequence at high voltage followed by a more manageable low-voltage stage.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments described were conducted using the Fermilab Main Ring accelerator.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shearing as a Simpler Alternative: The paper demonstrates that a "shearing" technique, involving RF-off drifting followed by high-voltage rotation, can effectively replace the complex RF counterphasing for bunch coalescing. This simplifies the process and reduces technical demands.
  • High-Voltage Rotation for Debunching: The key insight is that a brief, high-voltage RF pulse can achieve significant bunch spreading and rotation, which is then followed by a lower-voltage stage for final debunching and recapture. This avoids the difficulty of achieving very low voltages with high-Q cavities.
  • Trade-offs in Emittance Control: While the shearing method is simpler, the paper acknowledges that it might be slightly less optimal in terms of emittance preservation compared to perfectly adiabatic debunching. However, the practical difficulties of achieving adiabatic debunching make the shearing method attractive for routine operation.
  • Proton vs. Antiproton Coalescing: The study highlights that while antiproton coalescing is often considered more challenging due to their capture from a matched 8 GeV bucket, proton coalescing also presents significant difficulties, particularly in matching the initial proton bunches to the RF buckets.

Key Results

  • Successful Demonstration: Experimental studies in the Main Ring on July 7th and July 11th, 1984, showed promising results for bunch narrowing using the proposed shearing technique.
  • Reduced Complexity: The new method replaces a ~100 ms smooth voltage reduction with a less than 10 ms off/on/off sequence at high voltage, significantly simplifying the RF control requirements.
  • Emittance Growth: While the shearing method is effective, the paper notes that for the required intensity of 10¹¹ particles per bunch, the full scheme including low-voltage adiabatic debunching will likely be necessary for a clean coalesced bunch. The observed emittance growth in the experimental studies was around 24% for proton bunches.
  • Calculated Optimum vs. Experimental: Calculations indicated that the experimental parameters used in the July 11th study were not fully optimized, suggesting that further improvements are possible with refined timing. For instance, a drift time of 8.5 ms was calculated as optimal, compared to the 12 ms used.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Emittance Preservation: The paper acknowledges that the shearing technique might lead to slightly more emittance dilution compared to perfectly adiabatic debunching, especially for the high-intensity beams required for the TeV I program.
  • Need for Low-Voltage System: While the shearing method simplifies the high-voltage requirements, a low-voltage 53 MHz system is still needed for final debunching and recapture, though its requirements are less stringent than those for counterphasing.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further optimization of timing and parameters is needed to achieve the desired beam quality for the TeV I project. The paper also implies that the simplicity and reliability of the proposed method make it a strong candidate for future implementation, provided the remaining emittance challenges can be managed. The comparison between proton and antiproton coalescing also suggests that further investigation into optimizing both cases is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Both the proton and antiproton bunches which will collide in the Tevatron have longitudinal emittance greater than can be accelerated by the main ring from 8 GeV without large loss and emittance growth. We have previously described the technique of combining several smaller bunches at the Tevatron injection energy with little increase in the total emittance and negligible loss. This technique requires adiabatic debunching of several adjacent 53 MHz bunches by smooth reduction of the RF voltage from approx. 1 MV to approx. 100 V. The very low voltage is extremely difficult to attain with a high-Q system designed for megavolt accelerating potential. The counterphasing technique of voltage reduction which we have used in main ring experiments and proposed for the TeV I project is to divide the accelerating cavities into two closely matched groups and to smoothly shift the relative phase of the drive to the two groups by 180 degrees. When the net voltage has been reduced by this means to the lowest practical level, about 10 kV, the final voltage reduction may be performed by turning off the high-Q system and using a low-Q cavity. The voltage induced on the undriven gaps of the high-Q system is low enough not to be a major problem because the total intensity is low. However, the effects are not negligible, and dynamic beam loading compensation is required. This memo proposes that the process described above be simplified somewhat by replacing the counterphasing voltage reduction with a zero-voltage spreading of the bunches for several milliseconds followed by a few hundred microseconds of rotation to minimum energy spread in buckets produced at high voltage.
BibTeX
@misc{griffin1984bunch,
  author = {Jim E. Griffin and J. MacLachlan and G.N. Nicholls and Z. Qian},
  title = {{Bunch coalescing in the main ring to form intense proton and antiproton bunches without RF counterphasing}},
  year = {1984},
  doi = {10.2172/6557129},
}

Loading related content...

Figure