Bullet trains and steam engines: Exogenous attention zips but endogenous attention chugs along

Ramakrishna Chakravarthi, Rufin VanRullenJournal of Vision 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel subtraction method to accurately measure pure attentional shift times, disentangling them from cue and target processing. They found exogenous attention is fast and distance-independent (like a bullet train), while endogenous attention is slower and highly distance-dependent (like a steam engine). Furthermore, endogenous shifts across the visual midline are faster, suggesting parallel processing by the two hemispheres.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how quickly we can shift our visual attention is crucial for fields ranging from cognitive psychology to human-computer interaction and even autonomous systems. However, previous studies have yielded widely varying estimates for these "attentional shift times." This discrepancy is largely due to the difficulty in isolating the pure time it takes for attention to move from the time spent processing the cue that directs attention and processing the target itself. This paper aims to resolve this by developing a method to precisely measure pure attentional shift times and to investigate how these shifts are affected by factors like distance and the visual hemifield.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is a subtraction method designed to isolate pure attentional shift times. They adapted a paradigm involving "clocks" with revolving hands arranged in a circle around a central fixation point.

Here's how it works:

  1. Baseline Latency Measurement: Observers are presented with a cue (either exogenous or endogenous) directing their attention to a specific clock. They then report the perceived hand position on that clock at the moment of the cue. The delay between the reported time and the actual time (the "latency") includes cue processing, attentional shift, and target/hand processing.
  2. Test Latency Measurement: In a separate condition, observers are again cued, but this time they are instructed to voluntarily shift their attention to a different clock (either a fixed number of steps away or in a different hemifield). They report the hand position on this new clock. This latency includes all the components of the baseline latency plus the time for the endogenous attentional shift.
  3. Subtraction: By subtracting the baseline latency from the test latency, the researchers can isolate the pure attentional shift time. This is because the cue and target processing times are assumed to be constant across these conditions.

They employed this method to measure both endogenous attention (voluntary, goal-directed shifts) and exogenous attention (automatic, stimulus-driven shifts). They also designed experiments to specifically test the effect of distance between the cued and target locations, and whether shifts across the vertical midline (between visual hemifields) differed from shifts within a hemifield.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on participant responses to carefully controlled visual stimuli presented on a computer monitor.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Attention is not monolithic: The paper clearly distinguishes between the "bullet train" speed of exogenous attention and the "steam engine" pace of endogenous attention. This highlights that different mechanisms drive these two types of attentional shifts.
  • Distance matters, but differently: The finding that endogenous shifts are highly sensitive to distance, while exogenous shifts are not, is a crucial insight. This suggests that endogenous attention requires more "computation" or "planning" to reach a distant target, whereas exogenous attention is more of a direct, automatic response.
  • Hemispheric collaboration: The observation that endogenous shifts are faster across the visual midline is particularly intriguing. It strongly suggests that the two brain hemispheres can work in parallel to facilitate attention shifts, a capability not observed for exogenous attention. This points to distinct neural architectures supporting these different attentional processes.
  • A refined measurement tool: The subtraction method itself is a significant contribution, offering a more precise way to quantify attentional shift times, which has been a persistent challenge in the field.

Key Results

  • Exogenous Attention:
    • Shift time: Approximately 100 ms.
  • Distance dependence: Minimal. Shift times showed little change regardless of the distance to the target clock.
  • Endogenous Attention:
    • Shift time: Approximately 250 ms for a nearby location.
  • Distance dependence: Steep. Shift times increased significantly with distance. For example, moving two steps away took considerably longer than moving one step.
  • Hemifield Effects (Endogenous Attention):
    • Shifts across the vertical midline (opposite hemifield) were significantly faster (340 ± 25 ms) than shifts within the same hemifield (398 ± 12 ms).
  • Hemifield Effects (Exogenous Attention):
    • No significant difference in shift times was observed between same-hemifield and opposite-hemifield shifts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Planning vs. Execution: The authors acknowledge that their method cannot separate the "planning" and "execution" stages of attentional shifts, as proposed by Hazlett and Woldorff (2004). Their measured "shift time" is the sum of these two stages.
  • Distance Measurement Ambiguity: For exogenous shifts, while they found minimal distance dependence, they note that the exact route taken by attention (straight line vs. curved path) is unknown, making it difficult to calculate precise speeds (e.g., in deg/s).
  • Potential Confounds in Experiment 2A: The authors acknowledge that in Experiment 2A, where they first observed the hemifield advantage, potential confounds like symmetrical neural representation and preferential allocation to certain locations might have contributed. However, they argue that Experiment 2B, with a larger shift distance, mitigates these confounds and still shows the hemifield advantage.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future research should directly test the hypothesis that the planning stage of endogenous attention is distance-dependent, while execution is not. Further investigation into the distinct neural mechanisms underlying endogenous and exogenous attention is also warranted. The authors also propose that the bilateral advantage for endogenous shifts could be further explored by examining how the two hemispheres share the "planning" cost of shifts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Analyzing a scene requires shifting attention from object to object. Although several studies have attempted to determine the speed of these attentional shifts, there are large discrepancies in their estimates. Here, we adapt a method pioneered by T. A. Carlson, H. Hogendoorn, and F. A. J. Verstraten (2006) that directly measures pure attentional shift times. We also test if attentional shifts can be handled in parallel by the independent resources available in the two cortical hemispheres. We present 10 "clocks," with single revolving hands, in a ring around fixation. Observers are asked to report the hand position on one of the clocks at the onset of a transient cue. The delay between the reported time and the veridical time at cue onset can be used to infer processing and attentional shift times. With this setup, we use a novel subtraction method that utilizes different combinations of exogenous and endogenous cues to determine shift times for both types of attention. In one experiment, subjects shift attention to an exogenously cued clock (baseline condition) in one block, and in other blocks, subjects perform one further endogenous shift to a nearby clock (test condition). In another experiment, attention is endogenously cued to one clock (baseline condition), and on other trials, an exogenous cue further shifts attention to a nearby clock (test condition). Subtracting report delays in the baseline condition from those obtained in the test condition allows us to isolate genuine attentional shift times. In agreement with previous studies, our results reveal that endogenous attention is much slower than exogenous attention (endogenous: 250 ms; exogenous: 100 ms). Surprisingly, the dependence of shift time on distance is minimal for exogenous attention, whereas it is steep for endogenous attention. In the final experiment, we find that endogenous shifts are faster across hemifields than within a hemifield suggesting that the two hemispheres can simultaneously process at least parts of these shifts.
BibTeX
@article{chakravarthi2011bullet,
  author = {Ramakrishna Chakravarthi and Rufin VanRullen},
  title = {{Bullet trains and steam engines: Exogenous attention zips but endogenous attention chugs along}},
  journal = {Journal of Vision},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1167/11.4.12},
}

Loading related content...

Figure