TL;DR
This study investigates how the built environment in Hong Kong influences physical activity (PA) among adults. It finds that while street centrality is linked to moderate PA, this relationship is partially mediated by sports facilities. Importantly, the presence of sports facilities has a stronger positive association with MPA for individuals who perceive barriers to PA, suggesting targeted interventions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Physical inactivity is a major global health concern, and the built environment is known to play a role in shaping physical activity behaviors. However, much of the existing research has been conducted in Western contexts, and findings may not directly translate to densely populated Asian cities like Hong Kong, which have unique urban characteristics. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining the associations between specific built environment features (public leisure facilities and street centrality) and physical activity in Hong Kong. It also explores the mediating role of leisure facilities in the street centrality-PA relationship and investigates whether perceived barriers to PA influence these associations.
Methods
The researchers employed a cross-sectional survey design, collecting data from 1977 adults in Hong Kong. They used objective Geographic Information System (GIS) data to characterize the built environment and self-reported data for physical activity and other variables.
Key methodological aspects include:
- Built Environment Measures:
- Public Leisure Facilities: Density of four types of facilities (gyms, parks, recreational facilities, sports facilities) within a 1 km buffer around respondents' homes.
- Street Centrality: A composite index calculated using Urban Network Analysis (UNA) in ArcGIS, incorporating reach, betweenness, straightness, and intersection density of street networks.
- Physical Activity Measures: Assessed using the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) short form, focusing on vigorous physical activity (VPA), moderate physical activity (MPA), and prolonged sitting. These were often dichotomized into "yes/no" for performing the activity.
- Statistical Analysis:
- Logistic Regression Models: Used to examine independent associations between built environment features and PA outcomes, controlling for socio-demographic variables, perceived PA barriers, and neighborhood environmental problems.
- Mediation Analyses: Employed to test whether public leisure facilities mediate the relationship between street centrality and PA.
- Stratified Models: Used to investigate whether the association between sports facility density and MPA differs based on perceived PA barriers.
Datasets
- Survey Data: A representative sample of 1977 Hong Kong adults from the Strategic Public Policy Research (SPPR) project. This dataset included socio-demographic information, perceived neighborhood environmental problems, perceived PA barriers, and PA outcomes.
- Built Environment Data:
- Public Leisure Facilities: Data obtained from the Leisure and Cultural Service Department (LCSD) of Hong Kong.
- Street Network Data: Obtained from the Transport Department, Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond Simple Density: The study highlights that not all public leisure facilities have the same impact. While gym density was initially linked to VPA, this association disappeared after controlling for other factors, suggesting it might not be a primary driver of vigorous activity in this context.
- Sports Facilities as Mediators: Sports facilities play a crucial role in connecting street centrality to moderate physical activity (MPA) and even prolonged sitting. This suggests that the "walkability" or connectivity of an area (street centrality) might encourage PA indirectly by facilitating access to sports facilities.
- Perceived Barriers Matter: The impact of sports facilities on MPA is significantly amplified for individuals who report barriers to physical activity. This is a critical insight, suggesting that providing accessible facilities can be particularly beneficial for those who face challenges in engaging in PA.
- Parks for Sedentary Behavior Reduction: While parks didn't strongly correlate with VPA or MPA, they were associated with lower odds of prolonged sitting. This suggests parks might be more effective for reducing sedentary time rather than promoting intense exercise.
- Context is Key: The findings underscore the need for context-specific research, as the unique urban density and characteristics of Hong Kong influence the relationship between the built environment and PA.
Key Results
- Sports Facility Density: Associated with a greater probability of moderate physical activity (MPA). This association was stronger for individuals who perceived PA barriers.
- Street Centrality: Significantly associated with MPA.
- Mediation: Sports facilities partially mediated the association between street centrality and MPA. They also fully mediated the association between street centrality and prolonged sitting.
- Park Density: Associated with lower odds of prolonged sitting.
- Gym Density: Initially associated with VPA, but this association became non-significant after controlling for covariates.
Limitations and Future Work
- Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits causal inference. It's difficult to determine if the built environment influences PA or if people choose to live in environments that match their existing PA behaviors (attitude-induced residential self-selection).
- Self-Reported PA: The reliance on self-reported PA data is a limitation, as it can be subject to recall bias and social desirability.
- Lack of Walking Data: The study did not include walking as a PA outcome, which is a common behavior influenced by the built environment.
- Objective Environmental Features: The study did not consider other objective environmental features like street-level greenery or population density.
- Causal Mechanisms: The mediation analysis relies on assumptions that may be violated, potentially biasing the estimation of mediation effects.
Future research could address these limitations by:
- Employing longitudinal designs to establish causality.
- Incorporating objective measures of PA (e.g., accelerometers).
- Including walking behavior and other objective environmental features in analyses.
- Exploring the impact of specific park characteristics and the reasons behind the counterintuitive finding of sports facilities potentially being linked to prolonged sitting.
- Investigating the role of public versus private housing in shaping built environments and PA.
Summary updated