Abstract With the tide of Internet plus and Industry 4.0, cloud computing technology has got rapid development and extensive application while the issues of security in cloud computing platform has attracted more attentions. Initially, this paper analyzes the necessity of a comprehensive and scientific security assessment to actual cloud computing platform. In addition, it focuses on researching test method of the security performance, security risk assessment of cloud information and security assessment index system in the world, and then it establishes a scientific and complete cloud platform security assessment system. From above, it proves the effectiveness of security technology measures in cloud computing platform, with using standard specifications for security assessment of cloud computing platform. This article could provide the relative reference for security construction, security supervision and security management of cloud computing platform, and developing of cloud computing security standards.
Introduction
As cloud computing becomes the backbone of national information infrastructure, security has emerged as the primary bottleneck for its adoption in sensitive sectors like government, the military, and heavy industry. A critical gap exists in current methodologies: while many security standards exist, there is a lack of a unified, system-level testing and risk assessment framework. Most existing approaches are either too high-level or focus only on specific technical silos. This research seeks to create a "scientific and complete" assessment system that evaluates a cloud platform's security posture by looking at both the underlying technology and the management structures governing it.
The Proposed Framework
The authors propose a Security Assessment Index System structured into a four-layer hierarchy designed to quantify cloud security objectively. This structure ensures that the assessment is comprehensive, covering both technical and organizational aspects.
The hierarchy is organized as follows:
- First Level: Splits the assessment into two broad categories: Technical Requirements and Management Requirements.
- Second Level: Technical requirements are classified by service models (IaaS, PaaS, SaaS) and "Common Security." Management requirements are classified by management systems, agencies, and personnel security.
- Third Level: Decomposes the second level into specific domains. For example, IaaS is broken down into virtualization security, host security, and storage security.
- Fourth Level: Contains the specific, measurable security requirements and test points.
Scoring Methodology
A key innovation of this framework is its bottom-up weighted average approach to calculate a final security score ($S$). The system handles diverse data types through:
- Data Mapping: Raw data (Boolean, integers, or decimals) collected from network interfaces are mapped to a normalized score between 0 and 1.
- "Weakest Link" Logic: For "key" indexes, the system uses a
Minoperation. This ensures that if a critical security component fails, the score for that entire index reflects that failure, preventing a high average from masking a catastrophic vulnerability. - Weighted Averaging: For non-key indexes, an arithmetic mean or weighted average is used to roll scores up to the next layer.
Evaluation and Results
To validate the mathematical consistency of the scoring formulas, the authors provide a theoretical demonstration using a sample set of fourth-level indexes ($P_0$ through $P_6$).
By applying the formulas to sample scores (e.g., $P_0$ having sub-scores of 0.3, 0.6, and 0.8), the authors demonstrate how diverse data points—from Boolean "pass/fail" checks to granular performance metrics—can be aggregated into a single, actionable security grade. This proof-of-concept shows that the system can successfully identify bottlenecks where the Min function is applied while providing a balanced view for other components.
Conclusion and Future Work
The proposed framework provides a robust blueprint for moving from subjective checklists to objective, data-driven cloud security assessments. It acknowledges that security looks different across service models and that management is as critical as technical implementation. However, challenges remain regarding the granularity of the fourth-level tests and the subjectivity of preset weights. Future work should focus on developing standardized assessment tools based on this index to enable automated, continuous security monitoring of cloud platforms.
Summary updated