TL;DR
This paper explores the nascent field of data science and the emerging community of data scientists. It argues that while challenges exist, the rapid development of data science, coupled with growing recognition and support from international organizations and governments, creates significant potential for building a robust global community of data scientists.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The paper addresses the question of how a community of data scientists is forming and what factors contribute to its development. It highlights that data science is still in its "embryonic stage," and the concept of a "data scientist" and their community is not yet widely understood or established. The authors aim to analyze the definitions of data science and data scientists, identify the drivers for community formation, and acknowledge the obstacles that need to be overcome.
Methods
This paper employs an explorative analysis approach. The authors:
- Define key terms: They analyze existing definitions of "data science" and "data scientist" from various sources, including academic papers and reports.
- Identify driving factors: They examine the inherent logical results of data science development, the fast pace of S&T advancement, the increasing strategic value of scientific data, and the role of scientific exchanges.
- Analyze institutional support: They highlight the promotion efforts by organizations like CODATA and the support from various countries and regions.
- Consider social needs: They discuss how societal demands are accelerating the formation and development of scientific communities.
- Acknowledge challenges: They identify obstacles such as the time-consuming nature of developing a new discipline and the comparative scarcity of data scientists.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Data Science as an Emerging Discipline: The paper emphasizes that data science is a rapidly developing field, driven by the explosion of scientific data and the need for better ways to manage, analyze, and utilize it.
- The Evolving Role of the Data Scientist: Data scientists are characterized as individuals involved in the capture, analysis, mining, visualization, and management of data, often bridging the gap between research and application.
- Community Formation is Inevitable but Challenging: The formation of a data scientist community is seen as a natural consequence of the discipline's growth, but it faces hurdles like a lack of clear definitions, career structures, and academic recognition.
- CODATA's Crucial Role: The Committee on Data for Science and Technology (CODATA) is identified as a key international organization actively promoting data science and fostering community through its conferences, publications (like the Data Science Journal), and working groups.
- Global Support and Investment: Many countries and regions are increasingly recognizing the strategic importance of scientific data and are investing in cyberinfrastructure and data sharing initiatives, which indirectly supports the growth of data science professionals.
- Social Need as a Powerful Driver: The increasing complexity of data-related projects and the societal need for data-driven solutions are significant motivators for the development of data science and its practitioners.
Key Results
The paper does not present quantitative results in the traditional sense. Instead, its "results" are qualitative insights derived from its analysis:
- Potential for Community: The paper concludes that building a community of data scientists is full of potential and hope due to the confluence of factors like the discipline's development, organizational support, governmental efforts, and social demand.
- Obstacles Identified: Key challenges include the slow public perception and popularization of data science, the comparative scarcity of dedicated data scientists, the lack of a defined career structure, and the need for more formal academic programs and textbooks.
- Examples of Progress: The paper cites examples of universities and organizations (e.g., MIAS Data Sciences Summer Institute, Datascience @ RPI, Osaka University, Keio University) developing data science programs and research groups, indicating concrete steps towards building the field.
Limitations and Future Work
Limitations:
- Explorative Nature: The paper acknowledges its explorative nature, meaning it provides an overview and analysis rather than definitive conclusions or prescriptive solutions.
- Definition Ambiguity: The authors highlight the ongoing challenge of defining "data science" and "data scientist" precisely, which can hinder community building.
- Time-Consuming Development: The paper emphasizes that establishing data science as a recognized discipline and fostering a strong community will take considerable time, similar to the evolution of computer science.
Future Work:
- Further Promotion by CODATA: The CODATA Data Science Journal is expected to play an even more significant role in promoting the data science community.
- International Collaboration: The paper suggests that an international data science society, potentially under CODATA's guidance, could be a valuable step in consolidating the global community.
- Addressing Career Structure: The need for a defined career structure for data scientists is identified as a critical area that needs resolution.
- Continued Support and Investment: Ongoing support and efforts from countries, regions, and institutions are crucial for the continued growth of data scientists and their communities.
Summary updated