BUILD BACK BETTER WITH BROADBAND

Ki‐Hong Park, Mohamed‐Slim Alouini, Yunfei Chen, Edward Asiedu, David Botchie, Weifeng Chen, Shang Gao, Michael P. Cañares, François Van Schalkwyk, Wondwossen Mulualem Beyene, Abraham Tulu Mekonnen, Samson Alemayehu MamoSYNCHROINFO 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper synthesizes findings from 15 global research projects under the ITU’s Connect2Recover initiative, aimed at bridging the digital divide exposed by COVID-19. It moves beyond simple "coverage" metrics to argue that true digital inclusion requires a four-pillar approach: resilient infrastructure, innovative service delivery, revamped inclusive policy, and deep investments in human digital literacy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the COVID-19 pandemic accelerated digital adoption for many, it simultaneously widened the chasm for the "unconnected." As of 2022, approximately 2.7 billion people (one-third of the global population) remain offline.

The authors tackle the "connectivity paradox": even in areas with physical network coverage, barriers like high costs, lack of digital skills, and outdated regulatory frameworks prevent meaningful use. The paper specifically examines how these barriers affected education, healthcare, and MSMEs (Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises) in 17 countries across Africa, the Americas, Arab States, and Asia-Pacific.

Methods

As a synthesis of 15 distinct winning research proposals, the paper employs a meta-analysis of diverse methodologies:

  • Mathematical Modeling: Used specifically in the "Network-in-a-box" (NIB) study to optimize throughput for remote health services using Gaussian density functions to characterize user distribution.
  • Qualitative Fieldwork: In-depth interviews and focus groups with stakeholders in Ghana (telemedicine) and higher education leaders in South Africa, Australia, and the Philippines.
  • Quantitative Surveys: For example, a stratified proportionate sampling of 418 undergraduate students in Ethiopia to determine device ownership vs. actual usage patterns.
  • Desktop Research: Comparative analysis of national ICT policies and regulatory frameworks across different regions.

Datasets

The paper draws from several primary and secondary data sources across 22 countries:

  • Ethiopian Higher Ed Dataset: Survey data from five major universities (including Addis Ababa and Hawassa Universities) regarding student ICT access.
  • Ghanaian Telemedicine Stakeholder Data: Interviews with 63 relevant stakeholders, including health practitioners and Ministry of Communication staff.
  • Connect2Recover Global Repository: Insights distilled from 307 initial research proposals and the final 15 selected reports.
  • ITU/UN Statistics: Global connectivity benchmarks and the UN Secretary-General’s Roadmap for Digital Cooperation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Coverage $\neq$ Connectivity: The "aha moment" here is that infrastructure is necessary but insufficient. In Ethiopia, while 90% of surveyed students owned smartphones, they remained "digitally excluded" due to poor campus Wi-Fi, high data costs, and a lack of localized digital content.
  • The "Network-in-a-box" (NIB) Concept: To solve the "last mile" problem in rural areas, researchers proposed a portable, low-cost networking package that integrates core network and access functions. This allows for "pop-up" medical connectivity during natural disasters or pandemics.
  • The Democratization Myth: The paper notes that technology and open educational resources do not automatically democratize education. In highly unequal societies, the shift to digital can actually exacerbate existing inequalities if institutional support (like "zero-rated" data access) isn't provided.
  • Informal vs. Formal Digital Health: In Ghana, researchers found that while formal telemedicine was hindered by policy gaps, people were already practicing "informal telemedicine" (calling health workers via mobile) to cope with lockdowns, suggesting a ready market for formal systems if regulated correctly.

Key Results

  • The Four Enablers: The research distilled a framework for recovery:
  • Resilient Infrastructure: Ubiquitous, affordable, and reliable networks.
  • Innovative Solutions: Prioritizing e-health, e-business, and digital financing.
  • Policy Revamping: Moving away from outdated, restrictive regulations toward inclusive, "fit-for-purpose" policies.
  • Institutional Capacity: Targeted digital skills training for teachers, healthcare providers, and MSME owners.
  • Throughput Optimization: Mathematical validation showed that deploying multiple NIBs near user clusters can maximize network throughput while maintaining low-latency connections for critical IoT health sensors.
  • MSME Vulnerability: The research highlighted that financial institutions failed to address the digital needs of small enterprises, which are the backbone of many developing economies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Implementation Gap: The paper is a synthesis of research; the authors acknowledge that the next step is moving from "insights" to "implementation" through pilot projects and multi-stakeholder partnerships.
  • Data Granularity: Because this is a high-level summary of 15 different studies, some specific technical parameters (like exact latency requirements for the NIB models) are referenced but not detailed in full within this specific document.
  • Sustainability: Future work needs to address the long-term financial sustainability of "Network-in-a-box" deployments once initial research funding or emergency subsidies expire.

Summary updated

Abstract

The United Nations Secretary-General’s Roadmap for Digital Cooperation states that “meaningful participation in today’s digital age requires a high-speed broadband connection to the Internet”, and that every person should have “safe and affordable access to the Internet by 2030, including meaningful use of digitally enabled services”. As part of efforts to achieve these goals, ITU launched the Connect2Recover initiative in September 2020, to help countries transition from responding to the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic and natural hazards to building back better with broadband. The initiative has the strong support of Australia, Japan, Lithuania and Saudi Arabia. As part of the Connect2Recover initiative, a research competition was launched in July 2021 to identify promising research proposals from across the world to accelerate digital inclusion during recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic. This resulted in the selection of 15 winning research proposals in December 2021. The 15 research teams, which represent 43 universities and institutions from 22 countries, focused on the themes of digital inclusion (in the areas of education, health care, enterprises and job creation, and vulnerable groups), and digital connectivity and resilience. The wealth of knowledge and insights compiled within are based on diverse methodologies, including desktop research, surveys, interviews and focus groups, which covered 17 countries in Africa, the Americas, Arab States and Asia-Pacific. The research showed that, while the use of broadband and digital technologies has been critical for coping with the pandemic, many people faced challenges and barriers in their adoption and use. In schools and universities, teachers and students struggled to get access to online education. During lockdowns, many in rural communities were isolated from healthcare providers in cities. In the business sector, the financial needs of micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) were not adequately addressed by financial institutions. The digital needs of vulnerable groups – such as women and girls, ageing populations and persons with disabilities – were also not adequately addressed. Ubiquitous and reliable network infrastructure, as well as affordable and accessible services, are essential to deliver digital solutions such as telemedicine, e-education and e-business services. Policy and regulatory enablers are also critical. Outdated policies or regulations that are not inclusive or do not meet post-pandemic recovery requirements need to be revamped. Digital skills gaps need to be addressed through sustained efforts for institutional and human capacity building. For instance, teachers, health-care providers and enterprises require digital skills and competencies to thrive and be successful; digital literacy is important for everyone, including vulnerable groups, so that they can fully participate in digital societies and economies. An estimated 2.7 billion people – or one-third of the world’s population – remain unconnected to the Internet in 2022. The goal of universal and meaningful connectivity cannot be addressed through improving coverage alone. By leveraging the lessons learned from these 15 published research reports – and working to ensure access, adoption, affordability and resiliency of broadband services – together we can build back better with broadband.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{park2022build,
  author = {Ki‐Hong Park and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini and Yunfei Chen and Edward Asiedu and David Botchie and Weifeng Chen and Shang Gao and Michael P. Cañares and François Van Schalkwyk and Wondwossen Mulualem Beyene and Abraham Tulu Mekonnen and Samson Alemayehu Mamo and Abraham Tulu Mekonnen and Samson Alemayehu Mamo},
  title = {{BUILD BACK BETTER WITH BROADBAND}},
  booktitle = {SYNCHROINFO},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.36724/2664-066x-2022-8-6-33-42},
}
Figure