BUFFALO wild wings: a high-precision free-form lens model of MACSJ0416 with constraints on dark matter from substructure and highly magnified arcs

Derek Perera, Liliya L. R. Williams, Jori Liesenborgs, Patrick L. Kelly, Sarah H Taft, Sung Kei Li, Mathilde Jauzac, J. M. Diego, Priyamvada Natarajan, Charles L. Steinhardt, Andreas L. Faisst, R. Michael Rich, Marceau LimousinMonthly 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the most precise lens model of the galaxy cluster MACS J0416 to date, using a novel free-form reconstruction method. This detailed model reveals two potential dark matter substructures and offers a compelling explanation for highly magnified transient events in the "Spock" arc, while also constraining the properties of a mysterious "Mothra" millilens.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Galaxy clusters are dominated by dark matter, whose distribution is difficult to map directly. Gravitational lensing, where the cluster's mass bends light from background galaxies, offers a powerful way to probe this dark matter distribution. However, accurately reconstructing these complex mass distributions, especially in regions with substructures or high magnification, has been a significant challenge. This paper tackles the problem of creating an exceptionally precise mass model for the galaxy cluster MACS J0416, aiming to resolve fine-scale structures and explain puzzling astronomical phenomena like highly magnified transient events and unusual lensing signatures.

Methods

The authors employ a sophisticated free-form lens inversion technique called GRALE (Genetic Algorithm based Lens Inversion). This method uses a genetic algorithm to optimize a mass distribution composed of projected Plummer spheres. They also explore hybrid models that incorporate physically motivated parametric profiles (Sersic and NFW) for bright cluster galaxies and specific arc-related galaxies. A key aspect of their approach is the use of a large number of spectroscopically confirmed multiple images as input, leading to a highly constrained model. They also develop a statistical framework using a Metropolis-Hastings algorithm to model the millilens associated with the Mothra transient.

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of 237 spectroscopically confirmed multiple images of background sources in the MACS J0416 cluster, compiled from Hubble Space Telescope (HST) and VLT MUSE observations. Additionally, they utilize photometric data for transient events in the Spock and Mothra arcs, and structural parameters for cluster member galaxies from Tortorelli et al. (2023).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unveiling Dark Matter Substructures: The high precision of their free-form model allowed for the identification of two potential dark matter substructures (M1 and M2) that are not associated with visible light. This is a significant finding, as such substructures are predicted by cosmological simulations but are challenging to detect.
  • Explaining Transient Events: The model's unique critical curve structure around the "Spock" arc, featuring two crossings, provides sufficient magnification to potentially explain the observed high rate of transient events as microlensing of supergiant stars. This offers a compelling solution to a long-standing puzzle.
  • Constraining Millilensing: The development of a millilens model for the "Mothra" transient has yielded some of the tightest constraints yet on such compact substructures, suggesting it could be a small globular cluster or even a dark matter subhalo.
  • Dark Matter Nature Probes: The identified substructures and the millilens properties offer avenues to constrain fundamental properties of dark matter, such as the axion mass in wave dark matter models and the self-interaction cross-section in SIDM models.

Key Results

  • High Precision Model: The primary free-form lens model (FF00) achieves a lens plane RMS (ARMS) of 0.191 arcsec, representing one of the most precise reconstructions of MACS J0416 to date.
  • Substructure Detection: Two light-unaffiliated substructures (M1 and M2) are identified, with masses of approximately $9.5 \pm 0.5 \times 10^{11} M_{\odot}$ and $5.7 \pm 0.2 \times 10^{11} M_{\odot}$, respectively.
  • Spock Arc Magnification: The model predicts multiple critical curve crossings around the Spock arc, leading to magnifications $\mu > 50$ across the arc, consistent with microlensing explanations for transients.
  • Mothra Millilens Constraints: The millilens magnifying Mothra is constrained to have a mass $\lesssim 10^6 M_{\odot}$ and a core radius $\lesssim 17$ pc.
  • Dark Matter Constraints: The millilens analysis places an upper limit on the axion mass in wave dark matter models of $\lesssim 3.0 \times 10^{-21}$ eV.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Substructure Reality: While M1 and M2 persist across multiple models, the authors caution that more data and detailed analysis are needed to definitively confirm their existence as real substructures, as lensing degeneracies can sometimes mimic such features.
  • Mothra Millilens Assumptions: The interpretation of Mothra as a binary supergiant star and the assumption that the millilens is tidally truncated are sensitive points that could affect the derived constraints. Spectroscopic observations of Mothra are needed for more accurate characterization.
  • Dark Matter Model Specificity: The dark matter constraints are based on specific models (wave dark matter, SIDM) and require more sophisticated analysis to formalize.
  • Future Work: The authors propose incorporating the full JWST image catalog (343 images) for an even more precise reconstruction. They also suggest comparing GRALE models with other lens inversion techniques and further investigating the nature of the Spock arc transients and the Mothra millilens with future observations. The development of hybrid GRALE models also warrants further study to understand their performance and potential systematic effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT We present new free-form and hybrid mass reconstructions of the galaxy cluster lens MACS J0416.1$-$2403 at $z=0.396$ using the lens inversion method GRALE. The reconstructions use 237 spectroscopically confirmed multiple images from Bergamini et al. (2023) as the main input. Our primary model reconstructs images to a positional accuracy of 0.191 arcsec, thus representing one of the most precise reconstructions of this lens to date. Our models find broad agreement with previous reconstructions, and identify two $\sim 10^{12}\, {\rm M}_{\odot }$ light-unaffiliated substructures. We focus on two highly magnified arcs: Spock and Mothra. Our model features a unique critical curve structure around the Spock arc with 2 crossings. This structure enables sufficient magnification across this arc to potentially explain the large number of transients as microlensing events of supergiant stars. Additionally, we develop a model of the millilens substructure expected to be magnifying Mothra, which may be a binary pair of supergiants with $\mu \sim 6000$. This model accounts for flexibility in the millilens position while preserving the observed flux and minimizing image position displacements along the Mothra arc. We constrain the millilens mass and core radius to $\lesssim 10^6 {\rm M}_{\odot }$ and $\lesssim 17$ pc, respectively, which would render it one of the smallest and most compact substructures constrained by lensing. If the millilens is dominated by wave dark matter, the axion mass is constrained to be $\lesssim 3.0 \times 10^{-21}$ eV. Further monitoring of this lens with JWST will uncover more transients, permitting tighter constraints on the structure surrounding these two arcs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{perera2024buffalo,
  author = {Derek Perera and Liliya L. R. Williams and Jori Liesenborgs and Patrick L. Kelly and Sarah H Taft and Sung Kei Li and Mathilde Jauzac and J. M. Diego and Priyamvada Natarajan and Charles L. Steinhardt and Andreas L. Faisst and R. Michael Rich and Marceau Limousin},
  title = {{BUFFALO wild wings: a high-precision free-form lens model of MACSJ0416 with constraints on dark matter from substructure and highly magnified arcs}},
  booktitle = {Monthly},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/mnras/stae2753},
}
Figure