Büchi, Lindenbaum, Tarski: A Program Analysis Appetizer

Vijay D'Silva, Caterina UrbanIJCAI 2016

Introduction

Program verification—the formal proof that software behaves as intended—has historically been divided into three distinct mathematical schools: deductive reasoning (logic), automata theory (model checking), and abstract interpretation (lattices). While these fields share a common goal, their disparate terminologies and formalisms have hindered cross-pollination. This paper presents a mathematical "Rosetta Stone," unifying these approaches by applying classic theorems from Büchi, Lindenbaum, and Tarski.

The Unified Framework

The central contribution of this work is the formalization of the relationships between program representations across different domains. By treating program executions as words in a language, logical constraints as formulas, and abstract states as elements of a lattice, the authors demonstrate that these perspectives are mathematically interchangeable.

The Unified Framework of Program Analysis

As shown in Figure 1, the framework connects:

  • Automata and Logic via Büchi’s Theorem.
  • Logic and Lattices via the Lindenbaum-Tarski construction.
  • Automata and Lattices through the mapping of control flow to abstract states.

Bridging the Domains

The authors utilize two primary mathematical bridges to link these fields:

  1. Büchi’s Theorem: Traditionally used to prove the equivalence of finite automata and monadic second-order logic (WS1S), the authors extend this to show that Control Flow Graphs (CFGs) can be translated into a specific logic called WS1S(T). This allows reachability problems to be solved as logical satisfiability problems.
  2. Lindenbaum-Tarski Construction: This method transforms a formal logic into a mathematical lattice. The authors apply this to a newly defined "Interval Logic," proving it is isomorphic to the "Interval Lattice" commonly used in static analysis to track variable ranges.

Illustrative Example

To demonstrate these theoretical connections, the paper employs a running example of a simple program loop. This program increments a variable $x$ by 2 until it reaches 10.

Control Flow Graph (CFG) of the Running Example

The CFG in Figure 2 serves as the basis for showing how the same property (e.g., "is the error state er reachable?") can be evaluated as an automaton acceptance problem, a logical formula, or a fixed-point calculation in an interval lattice.

Key Insights

  • Programs as Formulas: A program can be viewed as a massive logical formula in second-order logic. Reachability is mathematically identical to formula satisfiability.
  • Lattices as Logics: The authors provide a formal proof for the "folk wisdom" that abstract interpretation lattices behave like restricted logics. Specifically, the Interval Lattice is shown to be a logic that supports conjunction but excludes disjunction and negation.
  • Fixed Points as Deductions: Iterative calculations in abstract interpretation are revealed to be a form of logical deduction, allowing proof theory to be applied to the study of analyzer performance and precision.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This unification opens the door for hybrid verification tools that combine the speed of lattice-based approximation with the precision of logical solvers. Future work aims to extend this framework to handle infinite executions (using Büchi automata for liveness properties) and more complex language features such as recursion and concurrency.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{dsilva2016buchi,
  author = {Vijay D'Silva and Caterina Urban},
  title = {{Büchi, Lindenbaum, Tarski: A Program Analysis Appetizer}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure