Brownfield Redevelopment Evaluation Based on Fuzzy Real Options

Hongjun Dai, Tao Sun, Wen GuoSustainability 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel fuzzy real option model to evaluate brownfield redevelopment projects in China, addressing the inherent uncertainties and expert risk preferences. By combining fuzzy numbers with the Black-Scholes real option framework, the model provides more objective and accurate valuations than traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Brownfield redevelopment, particularly in China's mining cities, faces significant challenges due to pollution, leading to high levels of uncertainty in project valuation. Traditional methods like Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) often underestimate the value of these projects because they fail to account for managerial flexibility and the inherent uncertainties. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a valuation model that can better capture these complexities, specifically addressing the fuzziness of expected future cash flows and incorporating expert opinions and their risk preferences.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of a fuzzy real option model. This model builds upon the established Black-Scholes (B-S) option pricing model but incorporates fuzzy mathematics to handle uncertainty.

Here's a breakdown of the key methodological steps:

  • Fuzzy Numbers for DCF Valuation: Instead of using single point estimates for the expected Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) value of a brownfield redevelopment project, the paper uses normal fuzzy numbers. This allows for the representation of a range of possible values, reflecting the inherent uncertainty.
  • Expert Opinion Integration: The model incorporates insights from a panel of experts. Each expert provides an estimation interval for the expected DCF value.
  • Weighting Expert Opinions: To account for varying levels of expertise and risk preferences, the paper uses a lattice closeness degree to determine the weights of each expert's opinion. This method objectively assigns weights based on how closely their estimations align with others, minimizing individual biases.
  • Volatility Estimation: The volatility of the expected DCF value, a crucial parameter in option pricing, is estimated using the assets price fluctuation method, adapted for fuzzy numbers.
  • Fuzzy Real Option Model: The fuzzy DCF value and its volatility are then integrated into the B-S real option framework. This results in a fuzzy real option value, which is still represented by fuzzy numbers.
  • Final Valuation: The expected value of the fuzzy real option is then calculated, providing a final valuation for the brownfield redevelopment project.

The paper specifically focuses on the "waiting option," allowing for the deferral of investment, which is a common flexibility in such projects.

Datasets

The paper uses a case study for evaluation.

  • Case Study Data: The study utilizes data from a specific brownfield redevelopment project in a mining subsidence area in a Chinese industrial city. This includes:
  • Initial investment cost: 432,000 Yuan (RMB).
  • Risk-free interest rate (r): 5%.
  • Maximum deferral time (T): two years.
  • Estimation intervals of the expected DCF value provided by five experts.

No new benchmarks or large-scale datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fuzzy Numbers as a Superior Tool for Uncertainty: The paper convincingly argues that normal fuzzy numbers are more appropriate than traditional point estimates for representing the uncertain DCF values in brownfield redevelopment. They capture not only the range of possibilities but also allow for the encoding of expert risk preferences.
  • Objective Expert Weighting is Crucial: Relying on a simple average of expert opinions can be misleading. The proposed method of using lattice closeness degree to weight expert opinions provides a more objective and robust approach, giving more influence to consensus views.
  • Real Options Add Significant Value: The study demonstrates that traditional DCF methods can significantly underestimate the value of brownfield redevelopment projects. Incorporating real options, particularly the "waiting option," reveals a much higher potential value, highlighting the importance of managerial flexibility in decision-making.
  • Bridging Finance and Environmental Economics: The paper effectively merges concepts from financial option theory with the practical challenges of environmental project assessment, offering a valuable interdisciplinary approach.

Key Results

The empirical results from the case study are compelling:

  • Traditional DCF Analysis: Based on the initial investment of 432,000 Yuan and an expected DCF value of 413,788 Yuan, the Net Present Value (NPV) was calculated as -18,212 Yuan. This indicated that the project was infeasible and should be abandoned under traditional analysis.
  • Fuzzy Real Option Analysis (Waiting Option): When the waiting option was considered, the investment value of the project was found to be significantly higher. The estimated value of the waiting option was calculated as 11,866 Yuan, leading to an expected value of the project of 30,078 Yuan. This positive value indicates that the project is feasible and should not be given up.
  • Conclusion: The fuzzy real option method, by accounting for project flexibility and uncertainty, provided a more accurate and positive valuation, suggesting that delaying the project for two years is a better strategy than immediate implementation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Waiting Option: The paper acknowledges that it only discusses the "waiting option" for simplification. It suggests that further study is needed to define and analyze other real options, such as options to contract or switch, and their combined influences on brownfield redevelopment projects.
  • Further Exploration of Fuzzy Numbers: While normal fuzzy numbers were used, exploring other types of fuzzy numbers or more advanced fuzzy set theories could potentially enhance the model's accuracy.
  • Broader Application: The paper's findings are based on a single case study. Applying the model to a wider range of brownfield redevelopment projects across different contexts would be beneficial for validating its generalizability.
  • Social Benefits: The study explicitly states that it does not take into account the social benefits of brownfield redevelopment, focusing solely on economic benefits. Future work could integrate these social aspects for a more holistic evaluation.

Summary updated

Abstract

There are a great amount of brownfield in Chinese mining cities. In order to promote mining cities sustainable development, it is necessary to redevelop brownfield. There is a great deal of uncertainty in the process of brownfield redevelopment owing to the influences of pollution. Normal fuzzy numbers were used to describe the fuzziness of the expected DCF (discounted cash flow) value of brownfield redevelopment projects. In view of experts’ preferences, the weight of fuzzed estimation intervals of the expected DCF value was determined by means of the lattice closeness degree to find the volatility of the expected DCF value. Combining the results with the B-S (Black-Scholes) real option model, we built a fuzzy real option model which could be applied to the brownfield redevelopment projects. The empirical results showed that the valuation results of the fuzzy real option model, considering the experts’ risk preferences, were relatively objective and accurate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dai2016brownfield,
  author = {Hongjun Dai and Tao Sun and Wen Guo},
  title = {{Brownfield Redevelopment Evaluation Based on Fuzzy Real Options}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/su8020170},
}
Figure