Broken Physics: A Conjunction-Fallacy Effect in Intuitive Physical Reasoning

Ethan Ludwin-Peery, Neil R Bramley, Ernest Davis, Todd M. GureckisPsychological 2020 · DOI

Abstract

One remarkable aspect of human cognition is our ability to reason about physical events. This article provides novel evidence that intuitive physics is subject to a peculiar error, the classic conjunction fallacy, in which people rate the probability of a conjunction of two events as more likely than one constituent (a logical impossibility). Participants viewed videos of physical scenarios and judged the probability that either a single event or a conjunction of two events would occur. In Experiment 1 (<i>n</i> = 60), participants consistently rated conjunction events as more likely than single events for the same scenes. Experiment 2 (<i>n</i> = 180) extended these results to rule out several alternative explanations. Experiment 3 (<i>n</i> = 100) generalized the finding to different scenes. This demonstration of conjunction errors contradicts claims that such errors should not appear in intuitive physics and presents a serious challenge to current theories of mental simulation in physical reasoning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ludwinpeery2020broken,
  author = {Ethan Ludwin-Peery and Neil R Bramley and Ernest Davis and Todd M. Gureckis},
  title = {{Broken Physics: A Conjunction-Fallacy Effect in Intuitive Physical Reasoning}},
  booktitle = {Psychological},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1177/0956797620957610},
}

Loading related content...

Figure