Broadening the scope: Multiple functional connectivity networks underlying threat conditioning and extinction

Cody A. Cushing, Yujia Peng, Zachary Anderson, Katherine S. Young, Susan Y. Bookheimer, Richard E. Zinbarg, Robin Nusslock, Michelle G. CraskeImaging 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses fMRI and a data-driven approach (group ICA) to reveal that threat learning and extinction involve multiple, distinct brain networks working in parallel, rather than a single core network. Understanding these dynamic network interactions is crucial for comprehending anxiety and fear-related disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional research on threat learning, a fundamental process implicated in anxiety disorders, has often focused on isolated brain regions. While this approach has yielded insights, it overlooks the complex, whole-brain dynamics and functional connectivity that likely underlie these processes. The authors argue that moving beyond "regions of interest" to examine large-scale brain networks is essential for a comprehensive understanding of threat learning, especially in the context of human neuropathology. They aim to identify and characterize these distributed networks during threat acquisition, extinction, and extinction recall.

Methods

The researchers employed a 2-day Pavlovian threat conditioning paradigm while participants underwent fMRI scanning. The core analytical technique was group Independent Component Analysis (ICA). This data-driven method allows for the identification of spatially independent functional networks and their associated time courses directly from the fMRI data, without pre-defining specific regions. This contrasts with traditional ROI-based analyses.

Specifically:

  • fMRI Acquisition: Standard fMRI data was collected during threat acquisition, extinction, and extinction recall phases.
  • Preprocessing: This involved standard steps like motion correction, smoothing, and artifact removal (using ICA-AROMA).
  • Group ICA: This was applied to the preprocessed fMRI data from all participants to extract 20 independent components (ICs), representing distinct functional connectivity networks.
  • Dual Regression: This technique was used to obtain participant-specific spatial maps and time courses for each identified IC, enabling statistical analysis.
  • GLM Modeling: A general linear model was fitted to the time courses of each IC to assess how network activity responded to different task conditions (e.g., threat vs. safety cues, early vs. late trials).
  • Statistical Analysis: Mixed linear models were used to test for interactions and main effects of condition and time on network activity, with Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons.
  • Canonical Network Overlap: The identified ICs were compared to established canonical brain networks (e.g., default mode, salience) to characterize their functional localization.

Datasets

The study utilized fMRI data from 223 participants who completed a 2-day Pavlovian threat conditioning paradigm. These participants were recruited as part of a larger cross-site Brain, Motivation, and Personality Development (BrainMAPD) study at UCLA and Northwestern University. The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Threat Learning is Network-Based: The most significant insight is that threat learning and extinction are not localized to a few key brain areas but are orchestrated by multiple, distinct functional connectivity networks operating in parallel.
  • Default Mode Network (DMN) Involvement: A network overlapping with the DMN (including hippocampus, vmPFC, posterior cingulate) is consistently implicated in both the acquisition and extinction of learned threat. This challenges the view of the DMN as solely involved in "deactivation" and suggests an active role in threat processing.
  • Salience Network's Dual Role: Another key network, overlapping with the salience network (dACC, mPFC, inferior frontal gyrus), plays a role in both initial threat acquisition and the expression of extinction memory 48 hours later, suggesting its importance for both rapid and long-term threat memory.
  • Dynamic Network Engagement: Different networks are engaged at different stages and for different aspects of threat learning. For instance, some networks show stimulus specificity during acquisition, while others are more involved in the general process of extinction.
  • Beyond the Amygdala: The study's findings, consistent with other recent research, highlight that while the amygdala is a key region in animal models, its role in human fMRI studies of threat learning is often minimal or absent, suggesting that distributed networks are more critical for understanding human threat processing.

Key Results

  • Threat Acquisition: A DMN-overlapping network showed increased activity for safety cues (CS-) over threat cues (CS+) in late acquisition, suggesting a role in threat extinction processes. A salience network-overlapping region showed greater activation to threat cues (CS+) than safety cues (CS-). Somatomotor and insula-centered networks also showed distinct responses to CS+ and CS- during acquisition.
  • Extinction: The same DMN-overlapping network showed a shift from decreased to increased activation during extinction. A visual network showed increased activity over the extinction period, potentially tracking the processing of new safe contexts.
  • Extinction Recall (48 hours later): The salience network-overlapping region showed decreased activation for unextinguished cues (CS+U) compared to extinguished cues (CS+E), indicating the retention of extinction memory.
  • No Stimulus Specificity in Extinction: Interestingly, no network showed stimulus-specific responses (CS+ vs. CS-) during the extinction phase itself, though this was observed during acquisition and extinction recall.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study is cross-sectional, limiting conclusions about the temporal dynamics and development of these networks. A longitudinal analysis is suggested for future work.
  • Subjective Experience: The study did not directly measure participants' subjective experience of fear, focusing instead on physiological and neural responses. Future work could integrate subjective ratings.
  • Amygdala Absence: The conspicuous absence of significant amygdala involvement in the identified networks is noted, aligning with some literature but also prompting discussion about the differences between animal and human threat processing and the limitations of fMRI in capturing transient responses.
  • Data-Driven Approach Nuances: The authors acknowledge that the data-driven nature of ICA, with minimal inclusion criteria, might reveal findings that don't immediately fit canonical theories, but argue this is necessary for exploring novel network interactions.
  • Future Directions: The authors emphasize the need for future research to disentangle the roles of these networks in automatic defensive responses versus conscious fear experience, to better tailor clinical interventions for anxiety and fear-related disorders. They also suggest testing more specific hypotheses and expanding investigations beyond traditional fear network regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Threat learning processes are thought to be foundational to anxiety and fear-related disorders. However, the study of these processes in the human brain has largely focused on specific brain regions, owing partly to the ease of translating between these regions in human and nonhuman animals. Moving beyond analyzing focal regions of interest to whole-brain dynamics and connectivity during threat learning is essential for understanding the neuropathology of fear-related disorders in humans. In this study, 223 participants completed a 2-day Pavlovian threat conditioning paradigm while undergoing fMRI. Participants completed threat acquisition and extinction. Extinction recall was assessed 48 hours later. Using a data-driven group independent component analysis (ICA), we examined large-scale functional connectivity networks during each phase of threat learning. Connectivity networks were tested to see how they responded to conditioned stimuli during early and late phases of threat acquisition and extinction as well as during early trials of extinction recall. A network overlapping with the default mode network involving hippocampus, ventromedial prefrontal cortex (vmPFC), and posterior cingulate was implicated in threat acquisition and extinction. Another network overlapping with the salience network involving dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC), mPFC, and inferior frontal gyrus was implicated both in threat acquisition and in extinction recall. Other networks overlapping with parts of the salience, somatomotor, visual, and frontoparietal networks were involved in the acquisition or in the extinction of learned threat responses. These findings help support the functional cooperation of specific brain regions during threat learning in a model-free fashion while introducing new findings of spatially independent functional connectivity networks during threat and safety learning. Rather than being a single process in a core network of regions, threat learning involves multiple brain networks operating in parallel performing different functions at different timescales. Understanding the nature and interplay of these dynamics will be critical for comprehensive understanding of the multiple processes that may be at play in the neuropathology of anxiety and fear-related disorders.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cushing2024broadening,
  author = {Cody A. Cushing and Yujia Peng and Zachary Anderson and Katherine S. Young and Susan Y. Bookheimer and Richard E. Zinbarg and Robin Nusslock and Michelle G. Craske},
  title = {{Broadening the scope: Multiple functional connectivity networks underlying threat conditioning and extinction}},
  booktitle = {Imaging},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1162/imag\_a\_00213},
}
Figure