Broadband visual stimuli improve neuronal representation and sensory perception

Elisabeta Balla, Christopher Wiesbrock, Jenice Linde, Simon Musall, Björn M. Kampa, Bjoern KampabioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the visual system, particularly V1 neurons, responds more robustly to stimuli with a broad range of orientations, mimicking natural scenes. This enhanced response is primarily driven by a reduction in surround suppression, leading to improved neural representation and ultimately better visual perception.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The visual system is constantly bombarded with complex natural scenes that contain a rich distribution of features like orientations and spatial frequencies. While we understand how neurons respond to simple, isolated features (like a single orientation), it's less clear how they process the broadband distributions found in nature. This paper investigates how varying the "bandwidth" of orientations and spatial frequencies in visual stimuli affects neural responses in the primary visual cortex (V1) and ultimately impacts visual perception. The challenge is to understand if and how the visual system is optimized for the statistical properties of natural scenes, moving beyond simplified stimuli.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Stimulus Generation: They created "motion clouds," which are parametrically controlled visual stimuli with adjustable bandwidths of orientations and spatial frequencies. This allowed for precise manipulation of feature distributions, mimicking aspects of natural scenes.
  • In Vivo Neural Recordings:
    • Two-photon calcium imaging: Used to record neural activity in superficial layers (L2/3) of V1 in awake mice. This technique allows for imaging of neuronal populations with high spatial resolution.
  • Electrophysiology (Neuropixels probes): Used to record from deeper cortical layers and the superior colliculus (SC), providing a broader view of neural processing across different brain regions and depths.
  • Computational Modeling: A Gabor filter bank model was developed to simulate V1 responses. This model was used to test hypotheses about the roles of orientation tuning and surround suppression in broadband stimulus processing.
  • Behavioral Experiments: Mice were trained on visual discrimination tasks (orientation and spatial frequency discrimination) to assess how neural changes translate to perceptual improvements.
  • Widefield Imaging: Used to measure cortical activity across larger visual areas, including V1 and higher visual areas (HVAs).

Datasets

  • Natural Image Library: Used for analyzing natural orientation and spatial frequency distributions (Figure 1a, 2a).
  • Motion Cloud Stimuli: The primary dataset generated by the authors, with parametrically controlled bandwidths of orientation and spatial frequency.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Orientation Bandwidth is Key: The visual system is highly sensitive to the range of orientations present. Broadening this range, similar to natural scenes, significantly boosts V1 neuron activity and recruitment.
  • Surround Suppression is the Mechanism: The enhanced response to broadband orientation stimuli isn't just about recruiting more neurons with specific tuning. It's largely due to a reduction in surround suppression. When the surrounding visual information is less predictable (as with broadband orientations), the center of the receptive field is less inhibited, leading to stronger responses.
  • Spatial Frequency Bandwidth Matters Less: Unlike orientation, expanding the spatial frequency bandwidth of stimuli did not lead to a significant increase in V1 neuron responses or recruitment. This suggests a specialization in how the visual cortex processes these different feature dimensions.
  • Deeper Layers and SC are Activated: Broadband stimuli, especially mixed ones, strongly activate deeper V1 layers and the superior colliculus, indicating a more widespread impact beyond superficial V1.
  • Neural Improvements Translate to Perception: The enhanced neural representation of broadband stimuli directly leads to improved performance in visual discrimination tasks, demonstrating a clear link between neural processing and perception.

Key Results

  • Increased V1 Neuron Recruitment: Broadening orientation bandwidth more than doubled the number of visually responsive neurons.
  • Increased Response Amplitude: Response amplitude of V1 neurons increased significantly with broader orientation bandwidth.
  • No SF Bandwidth Effect: Expanding spatial frequency bandwidth did not increase the number or amplitude of responsive neurons.
  • Surround Suppression Reduction: Broadband orientation stimuli significantly reduced center-surround inhibition.
  • Improved Discrimination: Mice showed significantly better performance in discriminating spatial frequencies when orientation bandwidth was expanded.
  • Model Accuracy: A computational model incorporating surround suppression accurately predicted neural responses to broadband stimuli, outperforming a "tuning-only" model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Animal Model: The study was conducted in mice, and while V1 shares many fundamental properties with primate visual cortex, direct translation of all findings requires caution.
  • Stimulus Simplification: While motion clouds are parametrically controlled, they are still simplified representations of natural scenes. Future work could explore more complex, naturalistic stimuli.
  • Subcortical Processing: While the SC was investigated, a more detailed comparison of cortical and subcortical processing of broadband stimuli is suggested for future studies.
  • Speed Perception: The paper notes that visual speed processing depends on spatial frequency bandwidth in humans, and it would be interesting to test speed perception in mice with different bandwidth-enriched stimuli.

Summary updated

Abstract

Natural scenes consist of complex feature distributions that shape neural responses and perception. However, in contrast to single features like stimulus orientations, the impact of broadband feature distributions remains unclear. We, therefore, presented visual stimuli with parametrically-controlled bandwidths of orientations and spatial frequencies to awake mice while recording neural activity in their primary visual cortex (V1). Increasing orientation but not spatial frequency bandwidth strongly increased the number and response amplitude of V1 neurons. This effect was not explained by single-cell orientation tuning but rather a broadband-specific relief from center-surround suppression. Moreover, neurons in deeper V1 and the superior colliculus responded much stronger to broadband stimuli, especially when mixing orientations and spatial frequencies. Lastly, broadband stimuli increased the separability of neural responses and improved the performance of mice in a visual discrimination task. Our results show that surround modulation increases neural responses to complex natural feature distributions to enhance sensory perception.
BibTeX
@misc{balla2023broadband,
  author = {Elisabeta Balla and Christopher Wiesbrock and Jenice Linde and Simon Musall and Björn M. Kampa and Simon Musall and Bjoern Kampa},
  title = {{Broadband visual stimuli improve neuronal representation and sensory perception}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.05.03.539238},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure