Broadband γ-Ray Spectrum of Supernova Remnant Cassiopeia A

Z. Cao, F Aharonian, Y. Bai, Y. W. Bao, D. Bastieri, Xiao-Jun Bi, Y.j Bi, Weixin Bian, A.v Bukevich, Chufan Cai, Wenjing Cao, J. Chang, A. M. Chen, E. S. Chen, H. X. Chen, Liang Chen, Long Chen, M.j. Chen, M.l Chen, Qingze Chen, Shaw H. Chen, S.z. Chen, T. L. Chen, Xiang‐Bai Chen, Ye Chen, Ning Cheng, Y. D. Cheng, M. C. Chu, Maxwell Cui, S. W. Cui, X. H. Cui, Yongde Cui, B. Z. Dai, H. L. Dai, Z. G. Dai, Danzengluobu, Yingxue Diao, X.q Dong, K. K. Duan, Junhui Fan, Y. Z. Fan, Jun Fang, Kun Fang, Chunsheng Feng, Haoran Feng, Li Feng, F. Shi, X.t Feng, Yuliang Feng, S. Gabici, Bo Gao, Chuyue Gao, Qi Gao, Wei Gao, M.m Ge, Tingting Ge, Li‐Sheng Geng, Gwenael Giacinti, G.h Gong, Q. B. Gou, M. H. Gu, Fu-Ming Guo, J. Guo, Xu Guo, Y. Q. Guo, Yunping Han, O. A. Hannuksela, M. Zahid Hasan, H.h He, Hongbin He, Jiangbiao He, Xiaoying He, Y. He, S. Hern ndez-Cadena, Y. K. Hor, Bowen Hou, Chao Hou, Xingsong Hou, H.b Hu, S. C. Hu, Chun-Hao P. Huang, D.h Huang, J. J. Huang, T. Q. Huang, Weidong Huang, X. T. Huang, Yumin Huang, Xiangdong Ji, Hy Jia, Ke JiaThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a detailed broadband gamma-ray spectrum of the supernova remnant Cassiopeia A (Cas A) using data from the LHAASO and Fermi-LAT observatories. They find a spectral break around 0.63 TeV, with a significantly softer spectrum at higher energies than previously reported by IACTs, suggesting potential contributions from surrounding regions or complex particle acceleration processes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Supernova remnants (SNRs) are considered prime candidates for accelerating cosmic rays to very high energies. Understanding the gamma-ray emission from SNRs like Cassiopeia A (Cas A) is crucial for deciphering these acceleration mechanisms and the origin of cosmic rays. While Cas A has been studied across the electromagnetic spectrum, its high-energy gamma-ray emission, particularly at TeV energies, has presented some discrepancies between different instruments. Specifically, Imaging Air Cherenkov Telescopes (IACTs) and the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory (LHAASO) have reported different spectral characteristics for Cas A above 1 TeV. This paper aims to reconcile these observations and provide a more comprehensive broadband spectrum to constrain theoretical models of particle acceleration and emission in SNRs.

Methods

The study combines data from two major gamma-ray observatories:

  • LHAASO (Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory): This array, specifically its Water Cherenkov Detector Array (WCDA) and Kilometer-Square Array (KM2A), was used to observe Cas A in the energy range of 0.8 TeV to 25 TeV. The analysis involved event selection criteria and a "direct integration method" for background estimation. The spectral energy distribution (SED) was calculated using a forward-folding method.
  • Fermi-LAT (Fermi Large Area Telescope): Data from Fermi-LAT, covering the energy range of 0.1 GeV to 1 TeV, was analyzed using the Easy Fermi software. A log-parabola function was initially used to fit the source, and then the data above 30 GeV was combined with LHAASO data.

The authors employed spectral modeling, comparing a simple power-law (PL) with a smoothly broken power-law (SBPL) and a smoothly broken power-law with an exponential cutoff (PSEC) to fit the combined data. They also explored hadronic and leptonic emission models to interpret the observed spectrum.

Datasets

  • LHAASO Data: Over 1000 days of data from LHAASO's WCDA (March 2021 - July 2024) and KM2A (July 2021 - July 2024) were used.
  • Fermi-LAT Data: 16.1 years of Pass8R3 Fermi-LAT data (August 2008 - September 2024) were analyzed.
  • Ancillary Data: The study also references and incorporates previously published data from IACTs (MAGIC, VERITAS), radio observations (Vinyaikin 2014), infrared data (De Looze et al. 2017), and X-ray data (Suzaku, INTEGRAL-IBIS).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Softer Spectrum Above 1 TeV: A significant finding is that the LHAASO spectrum above ~1 TeV is notably softer than that reported by IACTs, and its flux is about twice as high. This suggests a potential difference in how these instruments are capturing the emission or a more complex emission scenario.
  • Spectral Break Identified: The combined Fermi-LAT and LHAASO data strongly deviates from a single power-law above 30 GeV, being best described by a smoothly broken power-law with a break energy around 0.63 TeV. This break indicates a change in the particle acceleration or emission processes.
  • IACT vs. LHAASO Resolution: The difference in angular resolution between LHAASO and IACTs is highlighted as a potential reason for the spectral discrepancy. LHAASO's lower resolution might be capturing emission from regions surrounding the SNR that IACTs, with their sharper resolution, might exclude as background.
  • Constraining Particle Acceleration: The detailed spectral modeling, particularly the need for a broken power-law, provides crucial constraints on the mechanisms responsible for accelerating particles within the SNR, especially in its early evolutionary stages.
  • Hadrons vs. Leptons: The paper explores both hadronic and leptonic models for gamma-ray emission, finding that simple one-zone models struggle to fit the entire broadband spectrum, suggesting the need for more complex scenarios like two-zone models or accounting for particle transport.

Key Results

  • Spectral Fit: The combined Fermi-LAT and LHAASO data is best described by a smoothly broken power-law with spectral indices of 1.90 ± 0.15 (below break) and 3.41 ± 0.19 (above break) at a break energy of 0.63 ± 0.21 TeV.
  • Flux Comparison: The LHAASO flux near 1 TeV is approximately twice that reported by MAGIC and VERITAS.
  • Model Comparison: The smoothly broken power-law (SBPL) and sub-exponential cutoff (PSEC) models provide significantly better fits to the LHAASO data than a simple power-law, with SBPL showing a slightly better statistical fit.
  • Two-Zone Models: While a two-zone emission model can provide a reasonable fit to the broadband SED, it requires adjustments to explain the enhanced fluxes near 1 TeV, suggesting the need for more complex particle distributions or transport effects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Angular Resolution: The difference in angular resolution between LHAASO and IACTs is a significant limitation in directly comparing their results and interpreting the emission region. LHAASO's broader view might include emission from the SNR's halo or surrounding regions, which IACTs might treat as background.
  • Model Complexity: Simple one-zone emission models struggle to fully explain the observed broadband spectrum, particularly the TeV bump. This necessitates the exploration of more complex models, including those accounting for particle transport, clumpy media, or multiple emission zones.
  • Future Observations: The authors emphasize the need for future observations with improved angular resolution and sensitivity at TeV energies from both IACTs and LHAASO to better resolve the emission region and definitively understand the spectral bump. Detailed modeling is also warranted to fully explore the implications of nonlinear diffusive shock acceleration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The core-collapse supernova remnant (SNR) Cassiopeia A (Cas A) is one of the brightest galactic radio sources with an angular radius of <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" overflow="scroll"> <mml:mo>∼</mml:mo> <mml:mn>2</mml:mn> <mml:mover accent="true"> <mml:mrow> <mml:mi>.</mml:mi> </mml:mrow> <mml:mrow> <mml:mi>′</mml:mi> </mml:mrow> </mml:mover> <mml:mn>5</mml:mn> </mml:math> . Although no extension of this source has been detected in the γ -ray band, using more than 1000 days of LHAASO data above ∼0.8 TeV, we find that its spectrum is significantly softer than those obtained with Imaging Air Cherenkov Telescopes (IACTs), and its flux near ∼1 TeV is about 2 times higher. In combination with analyses of more than 16 yr of Fermi-LAT data covering 0.1 GeV–1 TeV, we find that the spectrum above 30 GeV deviates significantly from a single power law and is best described by a smoothly broken power law with a spectral index of 1.90 ± 0.15 stat (3.41 ± 0.19 stat ) below (above) a break energy of 0.63 ± 0.21 stat TeV. Given differences in the angular resolution of LHAASO-WCDA and IACTs, TeV γ -ray emission detected with LHAASO may have a significant contribution from regions surrounding the SNR illuminated by particles accelerated earlier, which, however, are treated as background by IACTs. Detailed modeling can be used to constrain the acceleration processes of TeV particles in the early stage of SNR evolution.
BibTeX
@article{cao2025broadband,
  author = {Z. Cao and F Aharonian and Y. Bai and Y. W. Bao and D. Bastieri and Xiao-Jun Bi and Y.J Bi and Weixin Bian and A.V Bukevich and Chufan Cai and Wenjing Cao and Zhe Cao and J. Chang and J. F. Chang and A. M. Chen and E. S. Chen and H. X. Chen and Liang Chen and Long Chen and M.J. Chen and M.L Chen and Qingze Chen and S. Chen and Shaw H. Chen and S.Z. Chen and T. L. Chen and Xiang‐Bai Chen and X. J. Chen and Ye Chen and Ning Cheng and Y. D. Cheng and M. C. Chu and Maxwell Cui and S. W. Cui and X. H. Cui and Yongde Cui and B. Z. Dai and H. L. Dai and Z. G. Dai and Danzengluobu and Yingxue Diao and X.Q Dong and K. K. Duan and Junhui Fan and Y. Z. Fan and Jun Fang and J. H. Fang and Kun Fang and Chunsheng Feng and Haoran Feng and Li Feng and F. Shi and X.T Feng and Yuliang Feng and Y. L. Feng and S. Gabici and Bo Gao and Chuyue Gao and Qi Gao and Wei Gao and Wei Gao and M.M Ge and Tingting Ge and Li‐Sheng Geng and Gwenael Giacinti and G.H Gong and Q. B. Gou and M. H. Gu and Fu-Ming Guo and J. Guo and Xu Guo and Y. Q. Guo and Yong Guo and Yunping Han and O. A. Hannuksela and M. Zahid Hasan and H.H He and Hongbin He and Jiangbiao He and Xiaoying He and Y. He and S. Hern ndez-Cadena and Y. K. Hor and Bowen Hou and Chao Hou and Xingsong Hou and H.B Hu and S. C. Hu and Chun-Hao P. Huang and D.H Huang and J. J. Huang and T. Q. Huang and Weidong Huang and X. T. Huang and X. Y. Huang and Yumin Huang and Y. Huang and Xiangdong Ji and HY Jia and Ke Jia},
  title = {{Broadband <i>γ</i>-Ray Spectrum of Supernova Remnant Cassiopeia A}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3847/2041-8213/adb97c},
}
Figure