Brief Announcement: Efficient Collaborative Tree Exploration with Breadth-First Depth-Next

Romain Cosson, Laurent Massoulié, Laurent ViennotPODC 2023 · OpenReview

Abstract

Collaborative tree exploration involves a team of $k$ robots mapping an unknown tree-shaped environment. The objective is to visit every node and return to the root in minimum time. This paper introduces Breadth-First Depth-Next (BFDN), a novel algorithm that achieves near-optimal performance by combining global breadth-first coordination with local depth-first exploration. We demonstrate that BFDN significantly reduces additive overhead compared to previous state-of-the-art methods, particularly for trees where depth $D$ is small relative to the number of nodes $n$.

Introduction

The problem of exploring an unknown graph with a team of mobile agents is a fundamental challenge in distributed computing, with applications ranging from search-and-rescue to web crawling. In the specific case of tree exploration, robots start at a root node and must traverse every edge at least twice (once in each direction). In an ideal scenario with $n$ nodes and $k$ robots, the exploration time would approach $2n/k$. However, the lack of a prior map introduces unavoidable overhead due to coordination delays and redundant traversals.

Previous algorithms, such as the recursive Yo or the CTE* algorithm, often suffered from either high competitive ratios or significant additive costs that hindered performance in practical scenarios. BFDN addresses these inefficiencies through a hybrid strategy.

The BFDN Algorithm

BFDN operates by alternating between two distinct modes of behavior to balance global efficiency with local thoroughness:

  1. Breadth-First Coordination (Global): When a robot requires a new task, it is assigned an "anchor"—an already explored node that leads to unexplored territory. The algorithm prioritizes anchors closest to the root, effectively implementing a Breadth-First Search (BFS) logic for task distribution. This ensures the team remains spread out across the tree's frontier.
  2. Depth-Next Exploration (Local): Once a robot reaches its assigned anchor, it switches to a local Depth-First Search (DFS). The robot explores all reachable unexplored edges in its current branch, only returning to the root for a new assignment once its local subtree is fully mapped.

To analyze the efficiency of this approach, we utilize a "Balls in Urns" mathematical model. By treating robots as balls and tree branches as urns, we prove that BFDN minimizes the frequency of "re-anchoring" events, which are the primary source of idle time and wasted movement.

Performance and Comparative Analysis

The theoretical runtime of BFDN is bounded by: $$\frac{2n}{k} + D^2(\min\{\log \Delta, \log k\} + 2)$$ where $n$ is the number of nodes, $k$ is the number of robots, $D$ is the tree depth, and $\Delta$ is the maximum degree of the tree.

Figure 1: Comparison of exploration algorithms across different regimes of tree size (n) and depth (D). BFDN shows superior performance in the regime where depth is moderate.

As shown in the phase diagram above, BFDN is "order-optimal" for trees where the depth $D = o(\sqrt{n})$. In these regimes, the algorithm's performance is nearly indistinguishable from an offline optimal solution. BFDN outperforms the previous benchmark established by Brass et al. (2011) across all values of $n$ and $D$. Furthermore, the algorithm is robust; it maintains efficiency even in the presence of robot failures or when applied to grid-like graphs with obstacles.

Conclusion

BFDN provides a simple yet powerful framework for multi-robot exploration. By decoupling task assignment from task execution, it achieves a superior balance between coordination and local efficiency. While the $D^2$ term in the overhead suggests limitations for extremely deep, narrow trees, the proposed Recursive BFDN variant offers a path forward for such structures. Future research will explore extending these principles to more complex graph topologies where distance from the root is not immediately known.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cosson2023brief,
  author = {Romain Cosson and Laurent Massoulié and Laurent Viennot},
  title = {{Brief Announcement: Efficient Collaborative Tree Exploration with Breadth-First Depth-Next}},
  booktitle = {PODC},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=USfoZtZGsX},
}
Figure