Abstract
Collaborative tree exploration involves a team of $k$ robots mapping an unknown tree-shaped environment. The objective is to visit every node and return to the root in minimum time. This paper introduces Breadth-First Depth-Next (BFDN), a novel algorithm that achieves near-optimal performance by combining global breadth-first coordination with local depth-first exploration. We demonstrate that BFDN significantly reduces additive overhead compared to previous state-of-the-art methods, particularly for trees where depth $D$ is small relative to the number of nodes $n$.
Introduction
The problem of exploring an unknown graph with a team of mobile agents is a fundamental challenge in distributed computing, with applications ranging from search-and-rescue to web crawling. In the specific case of tree exploration, robots start at a root node and must traverse every edge at least twice (once in each direction). In an ideal scenario with $n$ nodes and $k$ robots, the exploration time would approach $2n/k$. However, the lack of a prior map introduces unavoidable overhead due to coordination delays and redundant traversals.
Previous algorithms, such as the recursive Yo or the CTE* algorithm, often suffered from either high competitive ratios or significant additive costs that hindered performance in practical scenarios. BFDN addresses these inefficiencies through a hybrid strategy.
The BFDN Algorithm
BFDN operates by alternating between two distinct modes of behavior to balance global efficiency with local thoroughness:
- Breadth-First Coordination (Global): When a robot requires a new task, it is assigned an "anchor"—an already explored node that leads to unexplored territory. The algorithm prioritizes anchors closest to the root, effectively implementing a Breadth-First Search (BFS) logic for task distribution. This ensures the team remains spread out across the tree's frontier.
- Depth-Next Exploration (Local): Once a robot reaches its assigned anchor, it switches to a local Depth-First Search (DFS). The robot explores all reachable unexplored edges in its current branch, only returning to the root for a new assignment once its local subtree is fully mapped.
To analyze the efficiency of this approach, we utilize a "Balls in Urns" mathematical model. By treating robots as balls and tree branches as urns, we prove that BFDN minimizes the frequency of "re-anchoring" events, which are the primary source of idle time and wasted movement.
Performance and Comparative Analysis
The theoretical runtime of BFDN is bounded by: $$\frac{2n}{k} + D^2(\min\{\log \Delta, \log k\} + 2)$$ where $n$ is the number of nodes, $k$ is the number of robots, $D$ is the tree depth, and $\Delta$ is the maximum degree of the tree.
As shown in the phase diagram above, BFDN is "order-optimal" for trees where the depth $D = o(\sqrt{n})$. In these regimes, the algorithm's performance is nearly indistinguishable from an offline optimal solution. BFDN outperforms the previous benchmark established by Brass et al. (2011) across all values of $n$ and $D$. Furthermore, the algorithm is robust; it maintains efficiency even in the presence of robot failures or when applied to grid-like graphs with obstacles.
Conclusion
BFDN provides a simple yet powerful framework for multi-robot exploration. By decoupling task assignment from task execution, it achieves a superior balance between coordination and local efficiency. While the $D^2$ term in the overhead suggests limitations for extremely deep, narrow trees, the proposed Recursive BFDN variant offers a path forward for such structures. Future research will explore extending these principles to more complex graph topologies where distance from the root is not immediately known.
Summary updated