Breeding the Cat Through Superposition of Two Schrodinger Kittens Based on Coupled Waveguides

Nuo Wang, Xinchen Zhang, Qi Liu, Feng-Xiao Sun, Qiongyi He, Ying GuarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have proposed a novel "breeding" technique to generate large-amplitude Schrödinger cat states—a vital resource for fault-tolerant quantum computing—by superimposing two smaller "kittens" in coupled waveguides. By exploiting quantum interference in phase space, this method breaks through previous theoretical amplification limits, achieving amplitudes greater than 2 with significantly higher success probabilities and fidelity than existing approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of quantum optics, a "Schrödinger’s Cat" (SC) state is a superposition of two macroscopically distinguishable coherent states (typically represented as $|\alpha\rangle + |-\alpha\rangle$). These states are the "gold nuggets" of quantum information processing, essential for fault-tolerant quantum computing and high-precision metrology.

However, there is a catch: for these states to be practically useful, their amplitude ($\alpha$) needs to be large—specifically, $\alpha > 2$. At lower amplitudes, the two "lives" of the cat (the coherent states) overlap too much, making them difficult to distinguish and prone to errors. To date, preparing high-amplitude cats has been a major bottleneck. Existing methods like photon subtraction are often probabilistic with vanishingly low success rates, while nonlinearity-based schemes are highly sensitive to experimental losses. Previous "amplification" schemes also hit a theoretical ceiling based on the size of the input states.

Methods

The authors introduce a principle they call "breeding," which uses the superposition of two smaller SC states (the "kittens") to create one larger "cat."

The core mechanism relies on coupled waveguides and conditional measurement:

  1. Input: Two "kittens" (small SC states) are fed into two separate but coupled waveguides.
  2. Interaction: As the light propagates, the waveguides act as a quantum beam splitter, allowing the states to interfere.
  3. Heralding: A Photon Number Resolving (PNR) detector is placed at one output port. When the detector registers zero photons (a "vacuum" state), it "heralds" the successful generation of the superposed state in the other waveguide.

The mathematical novelty lies in how they manipulate the Wigner function (a probability distribution in phase space). By carefully choosing the superposition coefficients and phases, they create a "repulsive interaction" between nearby coherent states. Essentially, destructive interference on the "inner" side of a peak "pushes" the peak further out in phase space, resulting in a state with a higher amplitude than either of the inputs.

Datasets

As a theoretical and computational study, this paper does not use traditional machine learning datasets. Instead, it utilizes numerical simulations to model quantum state evolution. The authors benchmarked their scheme using:

  • Input Parameters: Kittens with amplitudes $\alpha_0 = 1.7$ and $\beta_0 = 0.8$.
  • Comparative Benchmarks: They compared their results against the theoretical limits of standard multi-photon quantum interference amplification schemes (e.g., works by Lund et al. and Sychev et al.).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phase Space Repulsion: The most striking insight is that interference doesn't just add or subtract peaks; it can "move" them. By superimposing states with a $\pi$ phase difference, the authors show that the resulting peak position ($\alpha_3$) can be greater than the original positions ($\alpha_1, \alpha_2$).
  • Breaking the $\sqrt{\alpha^2 + \beta^2}$ Limit: Traditional beam-splitter-based amplification is limited to a maximum amplitude of $\sqrt{\alpha^2 + \beta^2}$. By treating the process as a superposition of two distinct cat states rather than just amplifying one, this scheme surpasses that limit.
  • Parity Sensitivity: The "breeding" success depends heavily on the parity (even or odd) of the input kittens. The authors found that inputting two odd cats or an even-odd pair works best for amplification, whereas two even cats tend to result in "attractive" interference that reduces the final amplitude.

Key Results

  • Amplitude Breakthrough: Starting with kittens that would traditionally be limited to an amplified amplitude of 1.88, the proposed scheme achieved a cat state with an amplitude of 2.10.
  • High Efficiency: The success probability for generating this state was 39.5%, a significant improvement over previous schemes which offered ~29.3% for smaller resulting states.
  • High Fidelity: The generated state maintained a 98.31% fidelity relative to an ideal Schrödinger cat state, proving that the "cat-like" state produced is of high quantum quality.
  • On-Chip Compatibility: Because the scheme is based on coupled waveguides, it is naturally suited for implementation on photonic integrated chips.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Squeezed Cats: The authors note that the generated states are often "squeezed" cat states (where the noise in one quadrature is reduced at the expense of the other). While useful, this adds a layer of complexity that requires further study.
  • Experimental Realization: This paper is a theoretical proposal. The next step is physical implementation using real-world silicon photonics or lithium niobate waveguides.
  • Complex Superpositions: The authors suggest that by varying the phases of the input cats, they could potentially breed "four-component" cat states, which would open even more doors for quantum error correction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Optical Schrodinger's cat (SC) is highly anticipated because of the potential of realizing fault-tolerant quantum computing, but the practical merit is only shown when the amplitude is larger than 2. However, such high-amplitude cats have not been prepared due to the limitations rooted in the existing method. Here, we demonstrate a principle that a large SC-like state can be generated by the superposition of two kittens in which two nearby coherent states interfere and grow to an enlarged coherent-like state. Further, we propose a scheme to breed the cat beyond the limitation in the former works with a high probability by realizing the superposition of two SCs in coupled waveguides. The principle and scheme demonstrated here provide a new perspective on understanding quantum superposition in phase space and a better solution for the efficient generation of SCs on chips.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2024breeding,
  author = {Nuo Wang and Xinchen Zhang and Qi Liu and Feng-Xiao Sun and Qiongyi He and Ying Gu},
  title = {{Breeding the Cat Through Superposition of Two Schrodinger Kittens Based on Coupled Waveguides}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.02784},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02784},
}
Figure