Breaking Supercapacitor Symmetry Enhances Electrochemical Carbon Dioxide Capture

Zhen Xu, Xinyu Liu, Grace Mapstone, Zeke Coady, Carol A. Seymour, Sven Wiesner, Svetlana Menkin, Alexander C. ForseJournal of the American Chemical Society 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed an asymmetric supercapacitor design that significantly boosts electrochemical CO2 capture. By breaking the symmetry of traditional supercapacitors with a non-porous metallic zinc counter electrode, they suppressed competing CO2 release processes, leading to a 200% increase in capture capacity and a more straightforward understanding of the underlying mechanisms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Electrochemical CO2 capture using supercapacitors, known as supercapacitive swing adsorption (SSA), is a promising energy-efficient method for mitigating CO2 emissions. However, the performance of these systems has been limited by relatively low CO2 capture capacities. A key challenge identified is the presence of competing CO2 capture and release processes occurring simultaneously at both electrodes in conventional symmetric supercapacitors. This competition becomes particularly pronounced at slower charging rates, hindering overall efficiency. The authors aim to overcome this limitation by designing an asymmetric electrochemical cell that suppresses these detrimental competing processes.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the design of an asymmetric supercapacitor-battery hybrid system. Instead of using two identical porous carbon electrodes as in traditional symmetric supercapacitors, this new system employs a porous carbon electrode as the working electrode (where CO2 capture primarily occurs) and a nonporous metallic zinc electrode as the counter electrode. This asymmetry is crucial because the metallic zinc electrode is designed to primarily facilitate charge storage through redox reactions (like zinc plating and stripping) without significant CO2 capture or release.

The researchers utilized a custom-built electrochemical gas cell setup to conduct galvanostatic charge-discharge (GCD) experiments under a CO2 atmosphere. They measured both the electrochemical performance (capacitance) and the CO2 capture/release dynamics by monitoring pressure changes within the sealed cell. To further explore the generality of their approach, they also tested asymmetric supercapacitors using two different types of porous carbon electrodes with varying pore structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symmetry is the enemy of efficient SSA: The paper strongly suggests that the inherent symmetry of traditional supercapacitors leads to competing CO2 capture and release at both electrodes, limiting overall performance.
  • Non-capacitive counter electrodes are key: Using a counter electrode that primarily stores charge electrochemically (like metallic zinc) without significant CO2 interaction effectively suppresses the competing release processes at that electrode.
  • Asymmetry simplifies mechanism understanding: The use of a non-capacitive counter electrode helps to isolate the CO2 capture and release phenomena to the working electrode, providing clearer insights into the "ionic liquid-solid" mechanism.
  • Kinetic vs. Thermodynamic Control: The study highlights that CO2 capture is a kinetic process, and breaking symmetry can shift the balance towards capture by minimizing release.
  • Generality of Asymmetry: The concept of asymmetry isn't limited to carbon-metal systems; using different types of porous carbons as electrodes also demonstrates enhanced performance, albeit to a lesser extent than the carbon-zinc system.

Key Results

  • The asymmetric hybrid capacitor with a porous carbon working electrode and a metallic zinc counter electrode achieved a maximum CO2 capture capacity of 208 mmol CO2 kg⁻¹ at a low current density of 1 mA g⁻¹. This significantly surpasses the capacity of analogous symmetric supercapacitors, which showed reduced capacities under slow charging.
  • The energy consumption for CO2 capture in the hybrid capacitor was 51 kJ mol CO2⁻¹, considerably lower than the 126 kJ mol CO2⁻¹ required by the symmetric supercapacitor.
  • Asymmetric supercapacitors using two different porous carbon electrodes (YP80F and ACC-10/ACC-20) demonstrated a 200% increase in CO2 capture capacity at slow charging rates (e.g., 1 mA g⁻¹), reaching up to 64 mmol CO2 kg⁻¹ with ACC-10.
  • The hybrid capacitor exhibited good stability, operating reliably over 400 cycles with minimal degradation in capacitance and CO2 adsorption capacity.
  • The system showed high CO2 selectivity, with negligible pressure changes observed when tested under pure N2 and O2 atmospheres.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the metallic zinc electrode in the hybrid system might have limitations regarding long-term stability due to dendrite formation and potential oxidation by dissolved O2. They suggest that strategies developed for stabilizing aqueous Zn-ion batteries could be applied, and exploring air-stable materials with similar functions to metallic zinc is a promising avenue.

Future work should focus on further resolving the mechanistic complexities of electrochemical CO2 capture, as different mechanisms ("ionic liquid-solid," "molecular liquid-solid," or "pH-swing") may dominate under varying conditions. The study also suggests that further optimization of electrode materials, electrolyte compositions, and cell engineering could lead to even greater enhancements in CO2 capture capacity and reduced energy consumption.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electrochemical CO<sub>2</sub> capture using supercapacitors offers an energy-efficient approach for mitigating CO<sub>2</sub> emissions, but its performance is thought to be hindered by competing CO<sub>2</sub> capture and release processes at two identical porous carbon electrodes. To address this, we introduce an asymmetric supercapacitor-battery hybrid system with porous carbon and nonporous metallic zinc as the working and counter electrodes, respectively. The CO<sub>2</sub> capture capacity continuously increases as the charging rate decreases with a maximum capacity of 208 mmol<sub>CO2</sub> kg<sup>-1</sup>, surpassing that of an analogous symmetric supercapacitor. Our findings suggest that breaking device symmetry enhances CO<sub>2</sub> uptake in capacitive systems by suppressing competing processes, while the noncapacitive zinc counter electrode simplifies the mechanistic picture of capacitive CO<sub>2</sub> capture. Extending this approach, we develop asymmetric supercapacitors with two different porous carbon electrodes, demonstrating a 200% increase in CO<sub>2</sub> capture capacities at low charging rates. In summary, this study pioneers asymmetric systems for electrochemical CO<sub>2</sub> capture and establishes a general strategy to enhance both understanding and performance.
BibTeX
@article{xu2025breaking,
  author = {Zhen Xu and Xinyu Liu and Grace Mapstone and Zeke Coady and Carol A. Seymour and Sven Wiesner and Svetlana Menkin and Alexander C. Forse},
  title = {{Breaking Supercapacitor Symmetry Enhances Electrochemical Carbon Dioxide Capture}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.5c00999},
}
Figure